It took Aric Berning just five days to buy his Stanton Heights home. But selling it has been a much different story.
“To be honest, I’m surprised its been this hard,” said Berning, 35.
The housing market was hot when he and his wife, Anna, 32, spotted the three-bedroom, one-bath house in 2021, and they didn’t waste time making a move. It had been on the market for just five days when they snapped it up, locking in a mortgage rate of 2.7%.
“It was a really great starter home for that phase of my life,” said Berning, who was finishing his medical residency at UPMC when they made the purchase.
Now they are selling their home in a much different housing market.
Five years later, the tables have turned. Their house has sat for close to four months with no offers, even after reducing the price $14,000 to $255,000. Buyers today face a much steeper climb than they did in 2021, with higher home prices and mortgage rates topping 7% — more than twice Berning’s rate.
Read More
Like many home sellers in the Pittsburgh region, the Bernings are learning that today’s housing market is increasingly tilted in buyers’ favor.
More homes are piling up on the market, and fewer are selling. Rising mortgage costs have either made buyers more cautious or made them unable to afford a home. Sellers are being forced to either cut their prices, wait longer to sell or pull their houses off the market and wait for better days.
The slowdown is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
In Allegheny County, home sales have fallen to their lowest levels since 2012, underscoring just how much the housing market has cooled.
But nowhere is the market’s cooling more apparent than in the city of Pittsburgh, where home sales have fallen to levels not seen in 16 years.
Widening gap between supply and demand
The numbers tell the story of a housing market losing its heat and giving buyers more choices.
Home shoppers who once had to move quickly and outbid competing offers now have more breathing room. For the most part, they can take their time weighing their options and negotiating on price. They can ask sellers to cover closing costs and make other concessions that would have not been considered a short time ago.
Active listings across the Pittsburgh region climbed 15% last month from a year earlier — more than double the national increase of 7.4%, according to Realtor.com.
Sellers, meanwhile, are showing more signs of adjusting their expectations. Nearly 1 in 4 Pittsburgh-area listings — 22.9% — carried a price reduction last month, compared with 20.3% nationally.
The widening gap between supply and demand is also evident in West Penn Multi-List data, which covers 17 counties in the Pittsburgh region. Active listings jumped 16.05% in October to 7,995, up from 6,889 in October 2025. Meanwhile, closed sales moved in the opposite direction, falling 10.35% to 2,183 from 2,435 in October 2025.
The last time home sales were this slow in Allegheny County was in October 2012, when the county had only 1,010 closings, according to West Penn Multi-List data. The county had 1,013 closings last month.
The slowdown is particularly striking in the city of Pittsburgh, which saw 572 sales last month, which is the lowest number of sales in the month of October since 2010, when there were 474.
The supply of houses for sale in the city also has reached six months of unsold inventory, its highest level in 15 years.
“A six-month inventory is higher than we’ve seen in a while,” said Dustin Nulf, owner of Nulf Management Services on Washington’s Landing.
“If inventory stacks up more, we’ll definitely see prices start to drop and sellers start making some big concessions in order to move their listings,” Nulf said.
‘Deals fall through as fear sets in’
The days of sellers dictating the terms of a deal are fading.
After seeing their houses languish on the market for months, nervous sellers are accepting offers below their asking prices, contributing to buyers’ closing costs, buying down the interest rate, agreeing to make repairs and other concessions that were far less common when the market was hot.
Diana McKay, a Compass real estate agent based in Pine, recently represented a buyer who offered $490,000 for a house listed at $550,000. And the seller accepted.
“I’m seeing that prices are easier to negotiate,” McKay said.
One problem, she said, is that some homeowners haven’t adjusted their expectations to reflect the changing market.
“Homeowners think that their house is worth what their neighbor’s house was worth maybe two years ago,” McKay said. “We had a different market even a year ago.”
Buyers aren’t just driving harder bargains. They’re also walking away from deals more often when sellers won’t meet their demands.
Jason Dalbey, a Berkshire Hathaway agent in Squirrel Hill, said more deals are falling apart before they reach the closing table.
Nationally, about 10% to 11% of homes under contract never make it to closing. In the Pittsburgh market, that figure is higher — ranging from 14% to 15%, Dalbey said.
He said it’s another sign that buyers are exercising their newfound leverage.
During the pandemic-era bidding wars, buyers competing against multiple offers had plenty of incentive to stick with a deal. They knew other prospective buyers were waiting in the wings if they walked away, and they were less inclined to push sellers for concessions that might jeopardize the transaction.
Today, with far less competition, buyers are more willing to press their demands — and walk away if sellers won’t budge.
“We’re seeing because there’s no competition, buyers are suddenly asking for more than they would typically,” Dalbey said.
But not every seller has the financial flexibility to accommodate those demands, especially if accepting a lower price or paying for repairs would wipe out all their equity or leave too little room in the deal.
“Therefore, properties are falling through at a higher rate than they have been in the past,” he said.
Nulf, at Nulf Management Services, said the stock market can also play a role in whether a deal makes it to the closing table, particularly when it comes to wealthy people whose real estate purchases are tied to their investment portfolios.
“Usually, we see fall-through rates spike in higher-end markets when the stock market starts to sputter,” Nulf said.
“These buyers, a lot of times, are using market windfalls or savings to purchase, and when the stock market dips by 5% or more, we see deals fall though as fear sets in,” he said.
‘I can’t control what the Fed does’
With mortgage rates still hovering above 7%, buyers are getting creative about how they finance a home — and sellers are increasingly willing to help.
Dennis Cestra Jr., president of Howard Hanna Real Estate’s Pennsylvania Market, said buyers looking for more affordable ways to get into a home shouldn’t limit themselves to 30-year fixed-rate mortgages.
One increasingly popular option is a mortgage rate buydown, in which sellers contribute money at closing to temporarily lower the buyer’s interest rate. Depending on the arrangement, the rate can be reduced during the first, second and third year of the loan by as much as 2 percentage points.
“We see a lot of buyers and sellers working together and buyers using rate buydowns for the first, second and third year to get into a house at a rate that might be 2% lower,” Cestra said.
Adjustable-rate mortgages offer another alternative. With a 5/1 ARM, for example, the interest rate remains fixed for the first five years before adjusting annually for the remainder of the loan — subject to the loan’s caps and terms.
That gives buyers a longer window of predictable payments without having to count on mortgage rates falling in the near future.
“They don’t have to hope that rates will go down in a month, a quarter or a year,” Cestra said. “It can be two years, and they’re still in that lower rate, or adjustable rate mortgage.”
For Aric Berning, the changing market has been an expensive lesson in how difficult selling a home can be.
He and his wife are now carrying two mortgages at very different interest rates: their Stanton Heights home with its 2.7% rate, and an Altoona home they recently purchased with a 6.6% mortgage.
“We’re trading a 2.7% mortgage for a 6.6% mortgage, but I can’t control what the Fed does,” Berning said.
Berning paid $172,500 for the Stanton Heights house in March 2021. He initially listed it in July for $279,000.
“We kind of listed for the upper end of what we hoped we might be able to get for it,” Berning said. “We always kind of had the intention of dropping it if there were no bites.”
That’s exactly what happened. After two months of showings and open houses resulted in no offers, they lowered the asking price by $14,000, bringing it to $255,000.
“The only tool we had left in our arsenal really was to drop the price and maybe make it more attractive,” Berning said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.