HARRISBURG  — The state House on Wednesday approved legislation that would create a state-run retirement savings program for workers employed by businesses that don’t offer 401(k) or other retirement programs.

House Bill 577 passed 106-95 with five Republicans – Rep. Joe Hogan, R-Bucks; Lee James, R-Venango; Eric Nelson, R-Westmoreland; Kathleen Tomlinson, R-Bucks; and Martina White, R-Philadelphia – joining all Democrats in support of the legislation.

Other Republicans protested that the measure will be a burden on small employers.

House Republican Leader Bryan Cutler, R-Lancaster, said that the program should be optional and that most workers who want to save for retirement do so even if they don’t have access to employer-sponsored retirement programs.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cutler said that for workers trying to build wealth, eliminating debt and acquiring a home may be more important than being able to set aside money for retirement.

Under the legislation, employers would be required to withhold the employees’ contributions from their paychecks. Businesses with fewer than five employees would be exempt from the requirement.

Republicans sought to amend the bill on the floor by exempting part-time employees and raising the threshold for covered businesses to those with 25 or more employees. But both amendments were voted down.

Proponents say that as many as 2 million workers in the state stand to benefit from the legislation.

While most Republicans in the House were critical of the measure, state Treasurer Stacy Garrity, a Republican, has called for the legislation amidst warnings that the state stands to be faced with a crisis as too many people hit retirement age with insufficient savings to live comfortably.

Advertise with us

“The State Treasurer’s Retirement Security Task Force Report highlighted the vast number of Pennsylvanians who are seriously unprepared for the financial challenges of retirement. It’s a problem not just for retirees but also for the Commonwealth as financially unprepared retirees are projected to cost the state an additional $14 billion in social services between 2015 and 2030 (an average of nearly $1 billion per year). Additionally, lower consumer spending by retirees over this same time is estimated to cost the state roughly $1.4 billion in reduced tax collections, putting additional pressures on the state’s finances,” according to the cosponsor memo for the bill, circulated by Rep. Kyle Mullins, D-Lackawanna, the prime sponsor of HB 577.

On the House floor on Wednesday, Mr. Mullins said that when the bill was introduced last session, as HB 2156 with a Republican prime sponsor (Tracy Pennycuick, who is now in the Senate) 25 other Republicans signed on as cosponsors.

“I have the receipts,” he said.

In his cosponsor memo, Mr. Mullins asserted that research shows that workers with access to employer-sponsored retirement plans are “15 times more likely to save than employees” who don’t.

In Pennsylvania, 78% of workers with access to employer-sponsored retirement plans take advantage of them.