Abby Cartus has worked for years to earn entry to the doctoral program in epidemiology at the University of Pittsburgh, and she loves her chosen field. But lately she is feeling dread.

It’s not the workload or job prospects that suddenly are weighing on her. Rather, it is legislation racing through Congress that is touted as tax relief but could send her own bill skyrocketing, driving the 29-year-old North Side resident from campus and dashing her career ambition.

She said her stipend as a graduate assistant barely covers rent, car payments and other living expenses and would be unsustainable except for a tax-free tuition waiver she receives from Pitt on her $26,000-plus classroom bill. If a congressional proposal to tax that benefit as income becomes law, she said, it would cost her $5,000 — a quarter of her yearly stipend — and make it impossible to continue.

“It’s genuinely terrifying,” Ms. Cartus said. “If I have to drop out of school, I will have lost almost four years of work. It shouldn’t be this hard to do science.”

Advertise with us

Alarm over the tax legislation is reverberating on college campuses nationwide, from university employees who for decades have put their kids through college on a tax-free tuition benefit, to those with student loans who may lose a tax deduction, and even lifelong learners whose education benefit could be at risk.

The Republican-drafted legislation is seen by supporters as long-overdue tax code reform. It would trim the number of brackets and offer relief to middle-income families, supporters say.

Many of those households and corporations stand to save substantially, even if tax breaks, allowances and deductions popular with segments of the population are eliminated, they contend.

A tax bill passed the House on Nov. 16, and a Senate version moved though that body’s finance committee the same day. A full Senate vote could occur this week, and should it pass, both chambers would then reconcile their bills in hopes of final passage this year.

The legislation, in particular the House version, has huge implications for academia, college and university leaders say.

Advertise with us

It could ultimately repeal $71 billion in provisions intended to keep college affordable for millions of undergraduate and graduate students, including older adults and those seeking job retraining, said the Washington D.C-based American Council on Education, echoing government projections.

For instance, the House version would repeal the tax exemption that now covers tuition waivers and scholarships for employees and graduate assistants, ACE says.

Getting education dollars without being taxed has helped generations of those workers, from janitors to tenured professors, put their children through college. It has kept grad-student employees financially afloat.

Losing that would be the equivalent of a pay cut, and it would weaken an incentive used by campuses to attract and retain talented instructors and researchers.

For Dean Julian, 64, of Uniontown, who once worked as a $6-an-hour janitor at Pitt, the benefit not only put his sons through college but propelled him to advanced university study. He is now director of enrollment management at Penn State Fayette, The Eberly Campus.

Advertise with us

“I’m getting kind of emotional because I know what this did for me and my boys and my family,” he said Wednesday, choking up as he tried to describe the potential impact of what Congress may do.

“It really cuts the legs off of Middle America trying to provide opportunity for their families,” said Mr. Julian, noting that he was expressing his opinion and not that of his institution.

The House version also would repeal student loan interest deductions, as well as education deductions now utilized by part-time students, graduate students and lifelong learners, according to ACE.

Republican lawmakers push back on the idea that higher education is being singled out. They insist tax reform will help the economy, including those on campuses.

U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said student loan tax deductions and tax-free tuition waivers are among an array of direct and indirect federal subsidies that have failed to hold down college costs.

Advertise with us

“Congress must re-evaluate the federal government’s role with regard to higher education in order to address this crisis,” he said.

But college groups say they don’t understand the logic.

“You have to wonder about the politics of taking these benefits away from students and families across the country,” said Steven Bloom, ACE’s director of government relations, government and public affairs. “It’s hard to understand when you hear lots of members of Congress talk about the importance of increasing access to higher education.”

About 145,000 graduate students have their tuition waived in return for work in the classroom and research labs, according to ACE, which represents college and university presidents. About 60 percent of those students are pursuing careers in the STEM fields of science, technology, engineering and math that have been deemed crucial to the nation’s economic future.

The effects on colleges would not stop there.

Advertise with us

Both the House and Senate versions would double the standard deduction for individuals and couples, slashing the share who itemize. The resulting reduction in the value of a charitable deduction could curb giving to nonprofit organizations including colleges, according to ACE.

Both versions also would levy a 1.4 percent excise tax on certain private university endowments. Unlike the concept of using endowment funds to boost student aid, this “just sends it to Washington to be used for whatever,” Mr. Bloom said.

In Pittsburgh, about 40 students and faculty rallied Wednesday outside Pitt’s Cathedral of Learning against the legislation, part of protests scheduled across the nation.

Pitt has 2,420 graduate students on tuition waivers, said university spokesman Joseph Miksch.

“The federal tax plan under consideration is deeply concerning and includes a number of provisions that would be detrimental to our entire community,” Pitt chancellor Patrick Gallagher said in a statement.

Advertise with us

It would boost operating costs, limit charitable giving and undercut important research on Pitt’s campuses, he said.

At Carnegie Mellon University, interim president Farnam Jahanian said parts of the legislation threaten education access and the school’s ability to support work of its faculty and students.

“The education we provide undergraduates and graduate students is one of the most powerful engines for their future success and ability to contribute to society,” he said. “More broadly, the long-term health of government and industry depends on our graduates.”

In a message to campus Wednesday, Duquesne University president Ken Gormley said he had expressed concern to key lawmakers in Washington over specific aspects of the legislation he says “would only serve to make achieving a college or graduate degree even more difficult and costly for many Americans.”