What would you say to a graduate student who stands to lose tax breaks or tuition waivers and have concerns about tax reform legislation working its way through Congress?

If you’re a Republican member of Congress, you’ll likely say the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act will benefit everyone, including students and university employees. The legislation aims “to increase take-home pay for American workers while making our economy globally competitive, which will benefit Americans in every walk of life,” said Rep. Mike Kelly, R- Butler.

And if you’re a Democratic representative, you’ll probably express outrage. “The House GOP tax bill would be devastating for many college and university students, many of whom already struggle to pay for higher education,” said Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills. “The Republicans’ plan would eliminate the ability to deduct student loan interest from your federal taxes. Student loan debt is already a crisis in our country, and this provision will only make it worse. Taxing tuition waivers would make it much harder for many Americans to pursue advanced degrees.”

Members of Western Pennsylvania’s congressional delegation who responded to queries from the Post-Gazette about the effect of the tax legislation on universities followed their party lines.

Advertise with us

Said Sen. Bob Casey, a Democrat: “It’s clear congressional Republicans believe that massive student debt for our middle class students should just be a way of life. With colleges and universities taking a hit to the tune of $110 billion, the cost of obtaining higher education will rise for middle class families. The last thing middle class families need is a tax hike, loss of their health care, and a tuition jump to send their children to schools.

While representatives of universities and students strongly criticized the plan to end tax breaks and tuition waivers, Republican legislators defended the plan.

“The student loan interest deduction and the tax-free treatment of graduate tuition waivers are part of a patchwork of direct and indirect federal subsidies to higher education put in place over the last several decades,” said Mr. Kelly. “Despite these efforts, the cost of higher education has actually increased, as has student loan debt. Congress must re-evaluate the federal government’s role with regard to higher education in order to address this crisis. Because the tax code includes so many education-related provisions, part of this conversation must necessarily take place in the context of tax reform.”

Sen. Pat Toomey, a Republican, issued a statement that was less a specific defense of plans on educational tax breaks and waivers than a reminder that the legislation is still a work in progress: "Neither the House and Senate plan are finalized,” Mr. Toomey’s statement said. “The shared goal of Congressional Republicans and the administration on tax reform remains the same: delivering a direct pay raise to hardworking American families and creating incentives for economic growth with new, well-paying jobs.”

He echoed the argument that the net effect would be positive: “When looking at a tax reform package, it is important to remember that it extends beyond singular changes and deductions. So while both the House and Senate plans adjust tax treatment for certain entities and eliminate certain deductions, they both also lower rates, double the standard deduction, and increase the child tax credit, resulting in a net tax cut for millions of working-class and middle income Pennsylvanians.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Doyle said the issue goes beyond individual students: “These short-sighted changes in federal tax law wouldn’t just hurt individuals; it would also hurt colleges and universities, not to mention the economies in the surrounding communities. With so much of our region’s economy based on higher education and medical and scientific research, Pittsburgh would be especially hard-hit by these changes.”

Mr. Casey said it would undermine progress in the region: “Republican tax proposals will also hurt our economic growth and competitiveness. Pittsburghers know that world class institutions like Carnegie Mellon University and University of Pittsburgh have played a critical role in revitalizing the regional economy. But Republican proposals will make higher education more expensive, undercut critical research that fosters innovation, and take money away from needed scholarship funds. Hurting higher education only hurts our economy and our children.”

Mr. Kelly asserted that economic development wouldn’t suffer. “The health of the economy is a paramount concern for the congressman and guides all of his decision making. By dramatically lowering rates for individuals, families, and small businesses, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act will benefit all sectors of the economy.”