WASHINGTON – Republicans fought off an attempt to return their controversial tax package to committee, but not before unexpected drama erupted on the floor of the U.S. Senate.
U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., appeared to be mollifier-in-chief as members of his caucus huddled around GOP holdout Bob Corker of Tennessee.
Mr. Corker along with Republican Sens. Jeff Flake of Arizona and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin were – briefly, it turned out – withholding their crucial votes to defeat Democrats’ motion to recommit, which could have jeopardized passage this year. The extended effort Thursday evening to send the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act back to the finance committee was marked by intense huddles on the floor and passionate arguments and floor speeches.
Mr. Toomey appeared increasingly frustrated and at one point clutched his glasses and stood face-to-face with Mr. Corker, who later relented and voted with his caucus. Mr. Corker’s earlier objections stemmed from concerns that the bill didn’t sufficiently offset newly project deficit increases. The Democrats were angling to capture some votes from Republicans unhappy with aspects of the legislation, including worries about deficits.
Between private conversations with Mr. Corker and others on the floor, Mr. Toomey took to the podium to make his case publicly for the tax plan he helped craft and is now shepherding through a floor vote. Most of his arguments came during a back-and-forth with U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vermont.
Mr. Toomey argued that the proposal to eliminate state and local tax deductions relieves taxpayers in states like Pennsylvania from “subsidizing” the federal taxes of wealthy people in expensive states like New York who have more to deduct. He argued that most people who take the standard deduction will pay less. And he argued that the proposal alleviates the burden of a tax penalty for low-income people who can’t afford the coverage now required under the Affordable Care Act.
Read More
Mr. Sanders responded with sarcasm.
“I am so happy that my colleague, friend from Pennsylvania, is concerned about fairness, which no doubt is why 62 percent of the benefits in this tax proposal are going to the top 1 percent, and after 10 years we’re going to see over 80 million middle-class families pay more in taxes while the richest people in the country get huge tax breaks,” he said. “If that is the definition of fairness then I don’t quite know what fairness is about.”
In a heated exchange, Mr. Sanders pressed Mr. Toomey on whether tax reform will lead to cuts to Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security.
“There is no secret plan to do any of the above,” Mr. Toomey responded.
U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., has repeatedly spoken out against the bill during speeches and press conferences.
“It is robbing people of an opportunity to get a better tax cut for the middle class … and giving away the store to the rich,” he said in a floor speech Wednesday. “Isn’t there a way to make the middle-class tax relief much more robust and substantial?”
The Senate will convene at 10 a.m. Friday to continue the debate on taxes, ahead of a possible final vote later in the day.
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.