The debate over the Allegheny County budget formally started Oct. 8, when County Executive Sara Innamorato had an ask for council in her first budget proposal: a 2.2 mill increase in property taxes, to help pay for a budget plan of over $3 billion.
Since then, county council and she have been locked in a battle that could finally come to an end Tuesday evening — if 10 council members can agree on a budget and tax rate to fund it.
Council — after weeks of public and private debate over what to fund, and how much of a property tax increase to put on county residents — meets at 5 p.m. in the Gold Room in the county courthouse. They have until Friday, per the county charter, to approve a budget, and Tuesday night is the legislative body’s last scheduled meeting before that deadline.
Here’s where the debate stands.
What proposals are being considered?
As of Tuesday, at least two proposals are before the council for consideration: the initial budget plan by Ms. Innamorato, and another by the council’s budget and finance committee, which approved a plan in a 4-3 vote last week.
Ms. Innamorato’s budget plan is about $3.1 billion, and calls for a 2.2 mill increase, bringing the millage rate up from 4.73 mills to 6.93 mills. It also increases the homestead exemption from $18,000 to $21,000. County officials that for a property owner at $110,400, the median value in the county, that equates to about $15 a more in property taxes a month.
Read More
Council’s committee cut about $70 million in revenue in the budget, while raising the millage rate by 1.35 mills. That would bring the millage rate up to 6.08 mills, but the proposal would keep the homestead exemption at $18,000. For this option, county officials estimate that property owners with a home assessed at $100,000 would pay roughly $11 to $12 a month more in property taxes.
Are more changes possible?
Absolutely. Multiple news outlets reported Monday that County Council Member Dan Grzybek was planning to introduce a compromise proposal of a 1.66 mill increase, which would be between Ms. Innamorato’s initial proposal and the first counter proposal by council of a one mill increase — a plan that County Manager John Fournier said would greatly hurt county operations in a letter to council.
Mr. Grzybek’s proposal would raise monthly property taxes by about $12.75 on the median assessed property of $110,400.
In theory, any council member, as long as they make a motion to amend the budget and tax rate, can propose any millage increase — as long as they get a fellow council member to “second” their motion, opening up the floor for discussion.
How many votes are needed to approve a county budget plan and property tax rate?
Ten votes. There are 15 council members. According to county law, “Any ordinance which changes the rate of taxation on the valuation of taxable real property from the rate of taxation levied during the prior fiscal year shall be enacted only upon the affirmative vote of at least 2/3 of the seated members of County Council.”
Can the county executive veto the budget plan and tax rate?
Yes. The county executive has line-item veto power in the county charter over any budget council approves. Council has three business days to get their approved plan to Ms. Innamorato’s desk. She then has seven days to sign it, allow it to become law without her signature, or line-item veto. In theory, she could line-item the entire plan. But council could override that (or any) veto with the vote of 10 members, within seven business days of any action she takes.
How did we get here?
Political observers have said this is maybe the most contentious budget season in the charter’s history. The last time the council raised property taxes was in 2011, when Democrats voted in a 11-4 party line vote to approve a one mill increase in the property tax.
Since then, good economic conditions and assistance from the federal government during the COVID-19 pandemic have prevented another tax increase from occurring. But Ms. Innamorato’s administration said that with structural deficits looming — $81 million by the end of 2024 and $148 million in 2025 if no tax increase is approved — a tax increase is needed to avoid service cuts and further fiscal issues.
What happens if council doesn’t strike a deal on Tuesday?
Council missing its budget deadline would be unprecedented, so that question is difficult to answer. Some political observers, and Council President Patrick Catena, and Budget and Finance Committee Chair Robert Palmosina, have said that the courts would need to intervene.
It’s not clear if a lawsuit would need to be filed to prompt such intervention. Another scenario is a “special meeting” could be called by Mr. Catena, Ms. Innamorato, or a majority of council members (8), as directed to Mr. Catena.
“A written notice of each special meeting shall be delivered to each County Council member, the Chief Executive and the Manager at least 24 hours before a special meeting is held,” according to county law. “Such notice shall specify the time and place of the special meeting and the business to be transacted. County Council shall consider no other business at such meeting.”
In order to comply with the state’s Sunshine Act, the legislative body must notify the public at least 24 hours in advance of the meeting time.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.