Since early October, county Executive Sara Innamorato and the Allegheny County Council have been engaged in a debate over one of the core decisions local governments must make: What should be funded in the budget, and at what level property taxes should be set?

At this point, about the only thing both Ms. Innamorato’s administration and the 15 County Council members agree on is that, after 13 years of no property tax increase, some level of an increase is needed.

Disagreements between the executive and legislative branches on the amount of a tax hike persist. And they continue, just days before the county charter says council must pass a budget and a corresponding property tax rate.

Some observers say it’s the most contentious budget fight in the quarter-century of charter government in Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

Ms. Innamorato, a Democrat, started the process Oct. 8, when she introduced a budget plan that called for a 2.2-mill county property tax increase, from 4.73 mills to 6.93 mills. Overall, it would fund about $3.1 billion — a $1.2 billion operating budget, $130.6 million capital budget, and $1.8 billion budget for grants and special accounts. It’s roughly a 3% increase over the adopted 2024 budgets: a $1.05 billion operating budget, $116.3 million capital budget, and $1.8 billion grants and special accounts budget.

County officials have said that for the median homeowner with a property assessed at $110,400, that equates to roughly $15 a month more in property taxes, accounting for an increased homestead exemption, from $18,000 to $21,000. Budget officials have said the county is in a structural deficit that will hit $81 million by the end of 2024 and $148 million next year if no tax increase is approved.

Council countered by suggesting only a 1 mill increase was needed.

County Manager John Fournier responded in a letter to council that such a tax rate would have severe impacts — including layoffs and massive service cuts. On Tuesday, council’s budget and finance committee voted, 4-3, to approve a budget with a 1.35-mill increase while keeping the homestead exemption at $18,000. On a home assessed at $100,000, that would mean a tax increase of $11 to $12 a month.

The committee also voted, 4-3, to cut about $70 million from the county executive’s budget plan. That allowed the council to take the proposed 2.2-mill increase in the property tax down to 1.35 mills.

Advertise with us

The cuts would be reflected mostly in the operating budget — responsible for the daily costs of running county government — but they would also come from the capital budget, which funds long-term county projects such as infrastructure. It also includes cuts in the grants and special accounts budget, which mostly consists of state and federal funds that require a small local match for programming in nonprofits and similar areas.

Perhaps the main point of contention on council is in Department of Human Services funding. Ms. Innamorato recommended $286.9 million for DHS in 2025.

The counterproposal cuts $4 million in local funding, which means another $17 million in matching state funding would be forfeited, according to county officials.

Opponents of council’s plan criticize the decision to forgo that state money.

Councilman Dan Grzybek, during the budget and finance committee meeting, compared the DHS matching state funds to having a more than 400% match on an individual’s 401K retirement plan through work. It would be idiotic not to take advantage of that, he said.

Advertise with us
Bethany Hallam, left, an Allegheny County councilperson, and Patrick Catena, county council president, chat inside the Allegheny County Courthouse in Downtown on Oct. 8, 2024. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Supporters, including Bob Palmosina, the committee chairman, said county officials should only choose to put into the budget what they can afford.

Councilwoman Bethany Hallam, a Democrat and a member of the budget and finance committee, perhaps has been most vocal in supporting Ms. Innamorato’s proposal.

“This truly breaks my heart that I serve on council with people who would vote to do this ... and affect this many people. This is hundreds of jobs. This is thousands and thousands of people being served ... it really, really hurts me to sit with people who could do this and sneak-attack it,” Ms. Hallam said Tuesday.

But opponents of the original 2.2-mill increase say council’s counterproposal would still give departments more money, just not as much as in the county executive’s plan.

That included Suzanne Filiaggi, one of two Republicans on council. She said the administration’s argument of the impact on the median homeowner is not entirely accurate, because many property owners have more expensive properties in her District 2, which includes prosperous communities such as Franklin Park, Richland, Pine and McCandless.

Advertise with us

“We asked and asked and asked for movement, and were told at every turn there was no ... wiggle room,” Ms. Filiaggi said of the administration’s stance on the budget.

“When we looked further into things, I see that there are some that we probably could [cut] and we were just told, well, it's just a million dollars. Who in this room thinks a million dollars isn't a lot of money in the scale of things?”

The other Republican on council, Sam DeMarco, agrees with those who support the 1.35-mill increase.

Here is where the process stands, days before the budget deadline.

What happens if council doesn’t strike a deal by deadline?

According to the county charter and county code, the deadline to pass a budget and property tax rate is 25 days before the end of the fiscal year. Since that is the calendar year, that makes the deadline Dec. 6, or Friday.

Advertise with us

Council has a scheduled meeting this Tuesday. Council President Patrick Catena also could call an emergency meeting between then and Friday.

Mr. Catena and Mr. Palmosina say the issue could be settled in court if an agreement can’t be reached by 10 council members — the minimum number needed to approve a property tax hike.

Political observers say it’s unclear how that would work — and whether a county taxpayer, employee union or other entity would need to file suit to compel a judge to intervene. There’s no outside enforcement agency to ensure council meets the Dec. 6 deadline, they say.

“I don't know what the grounds for the suit would be ... that is really, really strange,” said George Dougherty, a University of Pittsburgh professor and director of the university’s master of public policy and management degree program.

Who drafted the counterproposal?

That’s unclear.

Advertise with us

Council Vice President John Palmiere, a member of the budget and finance committee, introduced the amendments to the budget and tax rate. But it appeared after the committee meeting Tuesday that Ms. Filiaggi, Mr. Palmosina, and Mr. Catena likely had a part in writing them, as they all fielded questions from reporters about the new plan.

Some council members’ reaction at the meeting also indicated that they had little notice of the new budget plan and tax rate — perhaps indicating that this coming Tuesday’s debate over any eventual plan could be lengthy.

Where do all 15 council members stand?

This is a difficult question to answer until the final vote Tuesday — or beyond. But there are clues.

In the committee, Mr. Palmosina, Mr. Palmiere, Ms. Filiaggi, and Councilman Nick Futules voted yes for the council plan. Ms. Hallam and Councilmen Jack Betkowski and Paul Klein voted no.

Historically, Ms. Hallam has been joined by members Anita Prizio and Mr. Gryzbek in voting on various issues, including a failed effort earlier this year to support a ceasefire resolution in the Israel-Hamas War. If they are joined by Mr. Klein and Mr. Betkowski, that means all other council members must approve the budget, or it won’t have 10 votes.

Advertise with us

It’s unclear how DeWitt Walton, David Bonaroti and Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis will vote. Ms. Bonaroti and Ms. Naccarati-Chapkis made brief comments and asked some questions at the committee meeting Tuesday, but did not tip their hands.

If one of them votes against a 1.35-mill increase in favor of a higher tax rate, that could cause complications.

Mr. Catena said he won’t go above a 1.35-mill increase.

Bob Macey, one of the most conservative Democrats on council, provided written comments to the Post-Gazette, saying it would be difficult for him to support any tax increase above 1.2 mills. That’s because school boards and municipalities in his district might also have to increase taxes, creating what he called a “triple threat to homeowners.”

Essentially, if neither side gets 10 members to agree on a millage increase of either 1.35 mills and Ms. Innamorato’s 2.2 mills, the deadline would be missed.

Advertise with us

What could Innamorato do if council reaches a deal?

According to the county charter, the executive can sign the budget bills and tax rate increase, let them become law without her signature, or conduct line-item vetoes.

Council staff said that under county code, Ms. Innamorato would have to completely cut funding from line items she vetoed.

That means, in theory, that she could veto the entire plan, forcing council to override her with the vote of at least 10 members.

Administration officials have said they’re open to further negotiations with council.

When council approves a budget, it has three business days to get it to Ms. Innamorato’s desk, per the county charter. She then has seven business days to make any decision. Council then has seven business days to override the executive, if members deem that is necessary.

Advertise with us

How do political observers and taxpayers feel about the debate?

Supporters of Ms. Innamorato’s budget and property tax rate say the money is needed for critical services such as economic development, public safety and social services. They also note the county has not had a property tax increase in over a decade, and if a large enough one isn’t adopted, another tax increase might be needed next year.

Opponents say the increase is far too much and would hurt those who own more expensive property, along with seniors and others on fixed incomes.

Ben Wren, a Republican political strategist from Westmoreland County, said Ms. Innamorato’s administration and supporters of the budget need to take a harder look at what services can potentially be cut.

“When people have a budget crisis in their own homes, they have to look inward. They can't look outward,” Mr. Wren said. “They can't demand more money from from their sources of income; it doesn't work like that in the real world. Only in the government can you go and say that the people who are already struggling with higher costs [need to pay more in taxes].”

Mike Butler, a Democratic strategist in Pittsburgh, said the budget debate is a test of Ms. Innamorato’s political capital. He said he believes some of the human services funding could be restored because of how much matching state dollars are at stake.

Advertise with us

“She's in her first year. How many allies can she push who are right now kind of drifting against her?” Mr. Butler said. “What kind of maneuvering [can she do], and what is her relationship with the ones who are holding out?”

Mr. Wren, Mr. Butler and Mr. Dougherty at Pitt all agree this is likely the most tense budget season in the history of charter government.

But this is what politicians are elected to do, they said — and a fast-approaching deadline can be the motivation needed to strike a deal.

“The hard work of politics starts now,” Mr. Dougherty said.