Dec. 6, 2011 — that wasn’t just the day before the 70th anniversary of the attacks on Pearl Harbor, the event that pushed the United States into World War II. Students of Allegheny County government history know it’s also the last time the County Council raised the property tax rate to fund county budgets.
Both topics were front-page stories in the Post-Gazette on Dec. 7 that year. All of the Democratic County Council members voted in a 11-4 party-line vote to increase the millage rate from 4.69 to 5.69 mills, which raised annual property taxes $100 on a home assessed at $100,000.
A countywide property reassessment occurred in the following months, and the millage rate eventually dropped to 4.73 mills — where it has remained ever since.
Now, County Executive Sara Innamorato’s administration is in a tug-of-war with the council over the 2025 budget and what the corresponding tax rate should be.
Ms. Innamorato opened negotiations in October by proposing a 46.5% increase — 2.2 mills — about $15 a month more for the median homeowner whose house is assessed at $110,400, when accounting for an increased homestead exemption. Residents can see how much their taxes would go up using a tool on the county’s website.
The county executive has repeatedly said in recent weeks that raising property taxes is “a last resort” option for creating a fiscally responsible budget.
Read More
This past week, at a news conference highlighting funding for public safety, she cited a piece in the Mon Valley Independent newspaper, which equated the increase to making a kid eat vegetables instead of cupcakes for dinner — difficult but necessary.
As a vegetarian, Ms. Innamorato joked that the metaphor was a bit difficult for her to use — but added that it helps illustrate why the increase is needed.
“I would strongly prefer to not have to ask for a tax increase … my budget, if it's going to be compared to a plate full of spinach, and as a result, the people of Allegheny County, they get these critical public safety investments, they get their 911 calls answered — that is a trade-off that I'm going to make,” she said.
But Ms. Innamorato needs 10 County Council votes, and she doesn’t have them.
“No one is going to shut down county government, so I'm not even considering that,” said County Council President Pat Catena. “We’ll get whatever budget across the finish line. It’s not going to be 2.2 [mills] though. It’s not going to be a 46.5% tax increase.”
What the final increase will be is the question.
Joe DiSarro, a political science professor at Washington and Jefferson College, said it’s going to be a difficult few weeks for council and Ms. Innamorato. He has serious doubts they’ll be able to meet the deadline set in the county charter, and that no matter how large an increase, there’s going to be serious blowback. Many people’s wages haven’t risen to compensate for the level of inflation.
“When you talk about raising taxes, it's never popular, and that makes politicians very nervous,” Mr. DiSarro said.
Where we stand, and the deadline
Some council members have indicated in public meetings that their starting position is a 1 mill increase — which County Manager John Fournier deemed unreasonable, saying it would amount to about $95 million less in revenue, necessitating about $250 million in cuts because of the loss of matching funds from state and federal sources.
There hasn’t been any public movement since, but county sources insist that an agreement will be reached by the deadline in early December.
“I’m confident that council will have something,” said one high-ranking source who works closely with the legislative body. Other sources in Ms. Innamorato’s administration have said the same. They were granted anonymity to speak candidly about sensitive budget negotiations.
The county charter says council must pass its operating, capital, and special accounts and grants budgets “no later than 25 days before the end of the current fiscal year.” That deadline is also in Chapter 5, Article 801 of the county code.
The fiscal year runs with the calendar year, so that places this year’s deadline on Dec. 6.
Council has a scheduled meeting on Dec. 3.
What happens if the deadline isn’t met?
It’s not entirely clear what the consequences of missing the charter deadline might be. Council has never missed the deadline since it approved its first budget under the new charter in December 2000.
There are no penalties listed in either the charter or the county code.
George Dougherty, a professor at the University of Pittsburgh and director of the master of public policy and management degree there, said that the charter might serve as our own constitution of sorts — but that there is no higher agency or governing body to enforce missing a budget deadline in it.
“There's not a regulatory agency out there that is … just waiting to pounce and fine the county if they don't meet that deadline,” he said. “It's basically just not playing by the rules that we all set for ourselves.”
While officials say they remain optimistic that a deal will be struck before the deadline, the county solicitor’s office is reviewing options if council members and the executive can’t reach an agreement, officials said.
Will county employees get paid?
It’s also uncertain if county employees will continue to be paid if there is no budget — but there may be enough available money to backstop payroll and continue at least some services into the beginning of 2025.
Some senior county officials have speculated that if there are unspent funds from the 2024 budget in certain departments, those funds could be allocated to backfill pay.
But other observers have said there may be legal hurdles to backstopping — especially if officials attempt to dip into millions of dollars in reserves, called the “unassigned fund balance.”
“I don’t think they could take money out of the fund balance and move it over … I think that would require an ordinance by council,” a former high-ranking county official said.
How much money does a tax increase generate?
According to county budget officials, each mill raises about $75 million in revenue from residential and commercial properties, assuming a 95% collection rate.
So a 2.2 mill increase — Ms. Innamorato’s proposal — would generate about $165 million for the county.
Ms. Innamorato has held multiple press conferences since she introduced her budget, defending money for economic development, the Department of Human Services, and public safety.
Hundreds spoke in support of her increase at a recent council public hearing, particularly for DHS-related programming.
There also is a need to address a structural deficit in the operating budget, county budget officials have said. In 2024, that stands at $81 million, and in 2025 it will increase to $148 million if no tax increase is approved.
Where has opposition come from?
So far, the only council members who appear to support a 46.5% increase are Bethany Hallam, Dan Grzybek and Anita Prizio. Ms. Hallam has been the most vocal.
At least 10 members — including Council President Mr. Catena and Budget and Finance committee chair Robert Palmosina — have publicly opposed it.
Mr. Catena said in a recent interview that he still questions the numbers in the letter sent to council by John Fournier, the county manager. It’s not going to be a “sky is falling” situation if a 2.2-mill increase isn’t adopted, he said.
Which council members are up for reelection?
Perhaps one of the toughest political challenges is facing voters shortly after having voted for a property tax increase.
Six council members are up for reelection in 2025. They are:
- Council President Patrick Catena
- Budget and Finance Committee Chair Robert Palmosina
- Jack Betkowski
- Anita Prizio
- Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis
- Bob Macey
The 15 members are elected in staggered years for four-year terms.
What’s next?
If history is a guide, the council will strike a deal of some sort by Dec. 3.
But property owners might have to wait a while longer for certainty on how much in taxes they will actually pay each year.
When council last passed a tax increase — back in 2011 — a countywide property reassessment followed shortly after, changing the valuation on many properties.
Ms. Innamorato is in a similar position. Pittsburgh Public Schools has sued the county, arguing that a countywide reassessment is needed in part because of inequities in the system. If the courts rule that one is needed, property valuations are almost certain to change.
Many supporters of a tax increase say it’s long overdue, with the increased cost of services during the last 10-plus years. Mr. Dougherty, the Pitt professor, said it’s not popular, but many academics and political scientists agree it’s the right thing to do.
“Going long periods without raising additional revenue is actually pretty bad policy,” he said. “It's good politics and it's bad policy.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.