There’s been several weeks of debate between Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato and the County Council over the budget plan and corresponding property tax rate.

Now, with a council committee passing its own budget plan last week in a 4-3 vote, there are two competing proposals for how much money will be spent, and how high of a property tax rate will be needed to fund them. Broadly speaking, the committee made cuts across various departments and divisions to reduce the property tax increase sought by Ms. Innamorato.

Here’s a broad look at how the two proposals compare — with the possibility that council could make further changes at its meeting Tuesday, or between then and the county charter deadline of Dec. 6.

Overall revenue

In 2024, the county projects it will collect $1.05 billion in operating revenue. Ms. Innamorato’s proposed budget, with a higher property tax rate, would collect just over $1.2 billion, officials estimate.

Advertise with us

Council’s budget and finance committee cut Ms. Innamorato’s increase in the property tax rate, dropping its real estate revenue from $558.1 billion to $504.7 billion. They also would lose $17 million in state funds — matching funds to $4 million in local funding for the Department of Human Services. That means overall revenue would drop just over $70 million in the council proposal, to about $1.13 billion.

Property tax rate

In Allegheny County, the millage rate is what determines how much property tax a homeowner pays. Ms. Innamorato’s proposal called for a 2.2 mill increase, from 4.73 to 6.93 mills. It also increases the homestead exemption from $18,000 to $21,000 — the amount of reductions in taxable value on an owner-occupied home in the county.

County officials have said it equates to about $15 a month for the homeowner with a median home value of $110,400. Opponents of that note that many properties in the county are worth a lot more, and thus would result in much higher increases for some taxpayers.

A council committee decided on a budget plan that includes a 1.35 mill increase, which would increase the rate to 6.08 mills. But council members would keep the homestead exemption at $18,000, so the average monthly increase to homeowners of a property assessed at $100,000 would be about $11 to $12.

Department of Human Services

Department of Human Services provides various social services to families, the elderly, the homeless, and other people in need in Allegheny County. It’s also, perhaps, where most of the disagreement on the budgets have been.

Advertise with us

Ms. Innamorato proposed about $286.9 million in her 2025 budget plan, almost a 20% increase over the 2024 adopted budget of $240.5 million.

The council, through its budget and finance committee, has proposed a $263.7 million budget. Committee members decided to cut $4 million in local funding, which means $17 million in matching state funds would be forfeited — a point of contention between those who support council’s proposal, and those that don’t.

Supporters of Ms. Innamorato’s proposal, like At-large Councilwoman Bethany Hallam, say it’s needed for increased demand for services for families, the homeless, and those in need. But those against, like Council President Patrick Catena, said the increase was far too large and believe an audit should be done of DHS to figure out how money is being spent within the department.

Personnel and fringe benefits

It’s tricky to compare side-by-side because of all the various departments, but the council committee says its proposal is to allow a 3% increase in pay across the board, unless departments and divisions requested a lower amount. They say that saves $10 million from Ms. Innamorato’s proposal.

In fringe benefits, they say their changes to the budget result in $4 million in savings.

Advertise with us

Children Initiatives

The county’s Department of Children Initiatives provides programming for youth through early care and education, and out-of-school programming. Ms. Innamorato’s proposal for the department in 2025 is $6.1 million. In 2024, the adopted budget plan included $1.5 million, meaning this proposal is about a 430% increase year-over-year.

Ms. Innamorato and other backers of her budget say it’s needed for critical programming in the county, while opponents say the jump is way too much. Council’s current proposal is $3.7 million for the department, which would save $1.6 million in local funding.

Kane Community Living Centers

The county operates four facilities for elderly residents and their families, offering health care and socialization for the county’s aging population. The locations are in Glen Hazel, McKeesport, Ross and Scott.

Ms. Innamorato’s budget proposal allocated about $114 million for the centers, up from $103.1 million in 2024 — about a 10.6% increase. Council’s proposal has largely kept that intact, except for cutting $100,000 in supplies from the facilities.

Jail

The county operates its own jail in Pittsburgh. Ms. Innamorato’s proposal calls for $114.8 million in 2025, up roughly 10.2% from $104.1 million in 2024.

Advertise with us

Critics like Ms. Hallam say the jail has historically been over-funded, but supporters say money is needed to order to run a facility and keep inmates, correctional officers, and staff safe.

Council kept the proposal mostly intact, allocating about $114.1 million.

Courts

The county’s president judge warned in a council budget hearing that a 10% cut to its operating budget would be catastrophic to its services. Ms. Innamorato’s budget for 2025 would spend about $97.4 million. In 2024, $93.3 million was budgeted.

Council’s proposal would allocate about $96.9 million to the courts, which handles criminal, civil and family cases in the county.

District Attorney and Public Defender

District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala, Jr.’s office was perhaps one of the most vocal in opposition to Ms. Innamorato’s proposal, arguing that it favored increases to other departments and offices over their own.

Advertise with us

The district attorney is the top prosecutor in Allegheny County, and elected by voters. In 2024, $24.1 million was allocated to the office. In Ms. Innamorato’s budget, $25.5 million would be spent — a roughly 5.9% increase.

Council’s proposal puts the funding at about $24.7 million.

The public defender’s office is charged with providing residents a legal defense, in the case that they can’t afford an attorney. That office was given about $13.5 million in 2024, and Ms. Innamorato’s proposal would give them roughly $14.8 million, a roughly 9.8% bump.

Council’s proposal has the office budgeted for $14.4 million.

Controller

The controller, another elected official, is responsible for overseeing the county’s finances and running audits of various departments of divisions. It’s often called a fiscal watchdog. Corey O’Connor, a Democrat, is the county’s current controller.

Advertise with us

In 2024, the controller’s office is budgeted for $8.4 million. Ms. Innamorato’s proposal allocates about $8.8 million, a roughly 4% increase.

Council’s proposal budgets the same amount.