When Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey recently announced the city would challenge the tax exempt status of more than 100 parcels of land, it was branded as a way to get the largest local nonprofit organizations to “pay their fair share.”
But actually getting those properties back on the city tax rolls will likely be an uphill battle.
Last month, Mr. Gainey’s administration submitted 104 parcels of land to Allegheny County to challenge their tax exempt status — focusing on properties that the city believes are owned by companies that aren’t purely public charities, or are being used in a way that isn’t in line with the charitable goals of the organization.
“It’s like David and Goliath to some extent,” said Jack Owen, a Pittsburgh-based attorney who specializes in business and tax law. “They’re really going up against UPMC and [Allegheny Health Network] and these people will have teams of lawyers that know what they’re doing.”
To be considered a purely public charity, an organization has to meet certain criteria set by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.
The organization must advance a charitable purpose, donate or render gratuitously a substantial portion of its services, benefit a substantial and indefinite group of people who are “legitimate subjects of charity, relieve the government of some burden and operate entirely free from private profit motivations.”
Read More
It’s a lot more difficult to qualify as a purely public charity than it is to receive a 5013(c) nonprofit designation, Mr. Owen said.
Allegheny Health Network, UPMC, the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and Duquesne University — known as the big five local nonprofits — all have properties being challenged by the mayor.
“It’s a fool's errand to try to prevail upon the region’s nonprofit’s tax exempt status,” said Joseph Sabino Mistick, who worked as former Mayor Sophie Masloff’s chief of staff.
Their prominence in the city when it comes to employing a large number of people and the work that they do, is one aspect that makes these challenges so difficult.
But vacant lots and properties being used differently from the charitable reasoning, “should have been changed from exempt status to taxable status,” Mr. Owen said.
Last year the city filed challenges to 27 properties, 12 of which were returned to the tax rolls. Two properties that were successful in last year’s challenges were parking garages owned by the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University.

But hospitals, “where they’re treating people,” could be a lot harder to argue, according to Tim Zieziula, an Erie-based real estate lawyer.
UPMC Children’s Hospital in Oakland and Allegheny General Hospital on the North Side are both on the list of the city’s challenges.
“Everybody takes their kid to Children’s Hospital,” Mr. Owen said. “And it’s the same thing with Highmark.”
If everything goes the city’s way, city officials expect to bring back about $6.5 million to the city’s property tax revenue. However, the two hospitals being challenged would make up the bulk of that revenue.
Children’s Hospital alone would return nearly $3.5 million to the city’s revenue, while Allegheny General Hospital would be about $1.3, according to information provided by the city.
If those two properties continue to be tax-exempt, the city would be missing out on about $4.8 million of the total $6.5 million they estimated.
“I don’t think that this is going to be real successful for the city,” Mr. Owen said. “But I could be wrong.”
Even if the city is successful, according to Mr. Mistick, the money they recoup likely won’t combat the money spent pursuing the legal challenges.
Of the 12 properties returned to the city’s tax roll after the 2023 challenges, the city has gotten back about $100,000, according to City Solicitor Krysia Kubiak.
In the meantime, the city also extended a contract with Loeb & Loeb, a local law firm, for $400,000 to help with the work of combing through nearly 1,000 properties that have a charitable tax exempt status and deciding which ones the city thought no longer qualified.
Ms. Kubiak said that these challenges are only “one part of an overall strategy to put the city on stronger financial ground.”
“I am confident that the city has an extremely strong case to make in court,” she said at a news conference a few weeks ago.
The mayor’s office declined to comment.
This battle with the nonprofits, particularly with UPMC, has plagued Pittsburgh mayors for years. And with more than half the 104 properties belonging to the medical center, the fight will continue.
“We know every administration at least since the Caliguiri days has dealt with the same issue,” Mr. Mistick said, referencing former Mayor Richard Caliguiri who was in office from 1977 to 1988.
More recently, in 2013, then-Mayor Luke Ravenstahl filed a lawsuit against UPMC, demanding six years’ worth of back payroll taxes and the removal of the health system’s tax-exempt status. At the time, he also compared the situation to a David vs. Goliath scenario.
UPMC countersued, claiming the city violated the organization’s constitutional rights. After a year of legal battles and under new mayoral leadership, the city dropped the lawsuit.
Former Mayor Bill Peduto initially pursued a payment in lieu of taxes – often called a PILOT program.
“It’s almost like a settlement,” Mr. Zieziula said. “Parties decide to hedge their bets.”
For the taxing bodies, PILOT programs are sometimes preferred because they are then guaranteed at least some money for a period of time, rather than running the risk of lengthy legal battles that may amount to nothing, he said.
Hospitals in Erie owned by UPMC and Allegheny Health Network have PILOT agreements where they pay half of what they would pay in property taxes were they not exempt to the city of Erie. However, both of those agreements were in place before the healthcare giants bought the hospitals.
Pittsburgh, under Ms. Masloff, had negotiated a few PILOT programs with nonprofits, Mr. Mistick said, but also focused on having the organizations give in-kind donations to help support programs.
“There are other ways they can give back,” he said. “The mayor’s efforts are better spent on strategies that have a chance of meaningful success.”
When Mr. Peduto axed the lawsuit, he said that discussions with UPMC would include a possible PILOT, but ultimately one never materialized.
Mr. Peduto instead created OnePGH, which was intended to be an agreement between the city, local nonprofits and foundations where they would pay into a fund that was separate from the city’s finances, but would be used for various initiatives to better the city, like affordable housing or social and health services.
Early on in his term, Mr. Gainey got rid of OnePGH. At a recent news conference, the mayor’s spokesperson said that because the money from the fund wasn’t going into the city’s operating budget “there was no real money there to help us do the things like pave the roads and open the pools.”
Instead, the mayor has focused his efforts on the challenges to tax exempt properties, though at that same news conference, the mayor said his administration “is still talking to nonprofits.”
It’s currently unclear when the city will know how much money they’ll get back from this round of challenges. Even if the county determines that a property should be put back on the tax rolls, the property owners can appeal that decision.
Part of Mr. Gainey’s mayoral campaign focused on the local nonprofits to “pay their fair share.” With his re-election looming, the challenges may be part of a renewed effort to keep his voter base intact.
“It might be good PR,” Mr. Mistick said. “It might satisfy part of the mayor’s constituency, make it look like he’s being tough on UPMC in particular, but the truth is, it’s not in the best interest of the taxpayers.”
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.