Pittsburgh officials will be challenging the tax-exempt status of over 100 properties, many of which are owned by UPMC.

This round of challenges is focusing directly on properties that are not being used for their charitable purposes, or are owned by an organization that does not qualify as a purely public charity or owned by an organization that has lost its nonprofit status, according to city Solicitor Krysia Kubiak.

“This is just a basic, good government clean-up operation,” Ms. Kubiak said during a news conference Wednesday afternoon. “Those parcels should be returned to the taxpayer rolls. ...This is a process that should have been done in previous years.”

Many of the properties being challenged are parking lots, parking garages, vacant lots and empty buildings, she said.

Advertise with us

In total the 104 properties could bring about $6.5 million back to the city’s property tax revenue. Total potential revenue, when combining the taxes from the city, Pittsburgh Public School district and the local parks and library taxes, would be about $15.3 million.

If there is a countywide reassessment, those numbers would likely go up. Some of the properties listed were sold decades ago and haven’t been assessed since, according to Ms. Kubiak.

City officials didn’t have exact projections on how much, but the county would also benefit financially if these properties were added back onto the tax roll.

Of the 104 properties, UPMC said it owns 58.

The parcels owned by UPMC that are being challenged on the campuses of five hospitals “clearly support the charitable mission of those hospitals,” spokesperson Paul Wood said in a statement.

Advertise with us

“The mayor knows he has UPMC’s commitment to participate in a program that’s fair and equitable and includes the other ‘Big 5’ nonprofits,” Mr. Wood said.

Additionally, seven of the properties are owned by the University of Pittsburgh, eight are owned by Allegheny Health Network, five are owned by Duquesne University and seven are owned by Carnegie Mellon University — along with UPMC, known as the big five local nonprofits.

This is Mr. Gainey’s second round of challenges to tax-exempt properties. Last year, the city filed challenges against nearly 30 properties. 

“If you do not meet the standard [of a purely public charity] as defined by the Supreme Court, you should pay your fair share for the paving of the roads in front of your hospitals … for the fire teams that help keep you and your students safe,” Mr. Gainey said during the news conference, in what appeared to be a direct call out to the nonprofit health systems and universities. 

Other properties being challenged include the Irish Centre of Pittsburgh and a vacant Downtown building owned by the Heinz History Center.

Advertise with us

There are 940 parcels of land within city limits that have a charitable tax-exempt status. The city has completed a review of 62% of those properties.

In deciding which properties to challenge, the city has considered things such as executives’ salaries, how much of the revenue is based on fees versus donations, and if a for-profit company provides a similar service, Ms. Kubiak said.

“We acknowledge that with some of these organizations, we might be wrong,” she said. “My door is open to people who want to discuss a challenge to their property and want to establish for us, outside of court, that they are using their property for a charitable purpose.”

This is Mr. Gainey’s latest effort in getting large local nonprofits to “pay their fair share,” one of his main campaign promises when he was running for office.

“The purpose of these challenges first and foremost is fairness,” Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office of Management and Budget, said Wednesday.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kubiak said the city plans to file challenges “regularly” moving forward, though it won’t make the process faster. The deadline for challenges for the county is March 31. Anything filed after that won’t be heard until the beginning of 2025.

“We don’t do this work for this year alone,” she said. “We do this work, like we do all of our work here, for the good of the city of Pittsburgh.”

Of the 27 properties challenged last year, 12 were put back on the city’s tax roll, and 12 were not. The city has appealed that decision. Three of last year’s challenges were withdrawn after communication with the owners.

“They sent us the proper paperwork and we were satisfied,” Ms. Kubiak said.

A number of the 12 properties that were put back on the tax roll last year were appealed by the property owners, but city officials did not have an exact number on how many were appealed during Wednesday’s news conference.

Advertise with us

From last year’s challenges, the city made about $100,000 in property taxes, Ms. Kubiak said Wednesday.

Despite the millions of dollars the city could potentially bring in this year, Mr. Pawlak said, these challenges were not being pursued to fill a gap in the budget.

“But rather to ensure the long term success of the city of Pittsburgh,” he said.

The city’s revenue projections have been called into question, most recently by city Controller Rachael Heisler, who advised the city to reopen the budget and make adjustments. Ongoing property tax assessment appeals have resulted in lower property tax values for a number of high-value buildings in Downtown, resulting in lower property tax revenue for the city.

“While we are certainly keeping a watchful eye on trends as property tax appeals come in ... I still think that some of those concerns have been overstated,” Mr. Pawlak said Wednesday. “We have ample tools to adjust spending during the current budget to prevent any of those changes from having a significant impact on services.”

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com