Pittsburgh City Controller Rachael Heisler sounded the alarm over the city's projected revenues in a letter sent this week to Mayor Ed Gainey and City Council members.

In the letter, the controller urged council and Mr. Gainey to reopen the 2024 budget and amend the revenue expectations that the spending plan is built on based on concerns about two major factors: property taxes and facility usage fees. 

“The City could see as much as a 20% reduction in the value of this building stock in 2024, which could cost the City $5.32 million in property tax revenue,” Ms. Heisler wrote in her letter on Wednesday.

She encouraged council members and the mayor to recalculate the projected real estate taxes that can be expected. The current budget does not account for any money that will have to be refunded, nor for a decrease in property tax rates.

Advertise with us

Already this year, a wave of property assessment appeals has raised concerns.

Major buildings in Downtown Pittsburgh continue to see their property values slashed, driven in part by lower demand for offices since the pandemic and in part by a change in the rate used to calculate the tax. Not only will they be paying less in property taxes for future years, the city, county and school district are all on the hook to refund taxes paid at the improper rate.

Assessments on 10 buildings Downtown, including the U.S. Steel Tower and PPG Place, could cost the city, county and Pittsburgh Public School district about $8.4 million combined in refunds for 2023.

As it stands, the city’s 2024 budget calls for bringing in nearly $150 million in real estate taxes. The projections increase over the next four years, reaching nearly $156 million by 2028.

City property owners have until the end of March to appeal their current assessed value. It could be months before the city knows the new value of those properties.

Advertise with us

Because of that, City Council Budget Director Peter McDevitt said in response to the letter he didn’t think the city was “in a position now to realistically change” the property tax revenue projections, but the “real estate tax revenue is a concern.” 

Additionally, Ms. Heisler raised concerns about projected revenue coming from what is often called the “jock tax.”

Pittsburgh charges professional athletes and performing artists a 3% fee for using the city’s publicly funded venues like Acrisure Stadium and PPG Paints Arena. Earlier this year, a Commonwealth Court judge upheld a ruling from 2022 that deemed the tax unconstitutional.

The city has appealed the ruling, and so far this year has put a pause on collecting that fee, even though the 2024 budget projects about $4.36 million in revenue from it.

“I believe $0 is a more reasonable expectation,” Ms. Heisler wrote in her letter.

Advertise with us

Mr. McDevitt said that Ms. Heisler “makes an excellent point about the facility usage fee.”

“It was left in the budget because there’s ongoing appeals, so it’s not entirely dead yet, but we’re not collecting it,” he said. “The controller makes a very good point that it shouldn’t be reflected in the budget.”

Ms. Heisler said that revenue loss from these two sources will “have significant impact on the City’s ability to provide essential services and programs to its residents.”

“I hope that you will take action to address this downward pressure threatening the fiscal health of our city,” the controller wrote at the end of her letter.

In budget discussions last fall, members of the mayor’s administration had acknowledged that there would have to be a tightening of the belt in the coming years, as federal pandemic relief funds expire and debt payments increase.

Advertise with us

In 2025 and 2026, the city is projected to bring in just $3 million more than it spends. In 2023, the city’s revenues were about $40.2 million more than expenses.

But Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office of Management Budget, reiterated multiple times during budget season that the administration has “adequately prepared” for any upcoming financial shortfalls.

“We know that we don’t have a structural challenge,” he said. “We know we’re confronting what is a temporary fiscal challenge … We know that the operating result for a few years will be narrow, but we also can see the light at the end of that tunnel.”

To reopen the budget, council members and Mr. Gainey have to agree on the move. The budget was recently reopened to adjust for the new contract awarded to the firefighters union, which includes pay raises not previously accounted for in the budget.

Council members are aware of the potential problems, according to Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith, who has been vocal about her concern for the city’s finances on multiple occasions.

Advertise with us

“The writing has been on the wall that we’re spending more money than we’re bringing in in the 2024 budget,” Mr. McDevitt said Thursday afternoon. “We’re OK for 2024 because we have American Rescue Plan money to buoy the operating budget, but we don’t have that in 2025.”

He said that it was “the outer years that have always been the concern” and that the changes with the jock tax and property taxes “escalates that a bit.”

During budget discussions in November, Mr. McDevitt suggested that city officials might “have to take a hard look at raising taxes” to bolster the revenue.

“Running a city is expensive,” he said at the time. “We need to make sure we have enough money to pay for that.”

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com