Sara Innamorato got no honeymoon.
The day after she was sworn in as Allegheny County executive, Ms. Innamorato announced pay increases and more benefits for non-union county workers. Not long after, she announced increased funding for child care facilities in the county by $500,000, and shortly thereafter she made a wide range of appointments to diversify the county's leadership and staffing.
But now exactly 100 days into her tenure, the new Allegheny County Executive is staring down the barrel of a countywide reassessment. A property valuation crisis — most evident in downtown Pittsburgh — is stripping tens of millions from municipal, city and school budgets.
The crisis was not of her making, but she will have to be part of the solution — and all eyes will be on Ms. Innamorato to see what she does.
Reassessments are the proverbial third rail of local politics; those who initiate them very often get voted out of office, which is why counties across Pennsylvania are making do with assessments that in some places are more than 40 years out of date.
There has not been a countywide reassessment in Allegheny County since 2012.
Read More
Last month Ms. Innamorato sidestepped a call for a countywide reassessment, saying more research and conversation was needed.
She suggested in one recent interview that lawmakers in Harrisburg need to step in and address the issue by creating a law to require reassessments on a regular basis.
This week, Pittsburgh Public Schools filed suit to force Ms. Innamorato to do a countywide reassessment.
While it would certainly make property valuations of more than a decade ago more current, a countywide reassessment wouldn’t necessarily benefit every municipal budget.
Not all valuations go up.
The issue is particularly daunting for places such as Braddock, a borough in the Mon Valley where the local budget is largely dependent upon the property tax paid by U.S. Steel. The last reassessment in 2012 saw the property value for the major steel producer — which has part of Edgar Thomson Steel Works, a major plant, on the edge of the borough — decrease, which slashed the tax revenue that supports Braddock’s budget.
U.S. Steel filed appeals for its 2023 tax bills on all of its Mon Valley properties. If property values were to decrease again, it could have major implications for Braddock's economy, said Lou Ransom, the Braddock borough manager.
“Reassessments don't really help us because the property values in reassessments are going down, so it’s having a negative effect on our tax revenue, but we know that it’s not really something we can control,” Mr. Ransom said.
“I’m not sure exactly how much we stand to lose, but we’re hoping the county can help us with that,” he added.
Dan DeMarco, president of Ross Township’s board of commissioners, said property reassessments are likely to be the defining issue of Ms. Innamorato’s first term.
“I think that's going to be probably a measurement … of how she’s going to perform in the duties of county executive,” he said.
Facing the prospect of plummeting revenue for communities and school districts, he and other municipal leaders are waiting to see how she acts.
Thus far, Ms. Innamorato has said that she is still reviewing the issue and wants to bring together a variety of stakeholders to address it.
Innamorato’s bold first days
Every new county executive needs some time to become fully acclimated to the office and its responsibilities, say county council members Bob Macey and Nicholas Futules, who have served on council since 2006 and 2007, respectively. They both watched former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald grow into the job following Dan Onorato.
Mr. Fitzgerald did have one advantage over his successor, Mr. Futules said: Mr. Fitzgerald had served as a councilman for 12 years, since the county charter had been implemented, so he knew all the department heads, staffs, and how county government operated. Ms. Innamorato came to the position after two terms as a representative in the state House in Harrisburg.
“I think that was a big, big thing for Rich, walking across the hall. It was a much easier transition,” Mr. Futules said. Even then, he said, “it takes as long as a year to get acclimated.”
But a learning curve doesn’t prevent bold actions.
On her first day after being sworn in, Ms. Innamorato announced pay increases and more benefits for non-union county workers.
Not long after, she announced increased funding for child care facilities in the county by $500,000.
Rochelle Salih, assistant director of family services at the state’s Early Learning Resource Center, said the child care funding helped clear a waitlist of nearly 30 families. As of March, her agency is paying for 299 families, and 283 children, she said.
The funding is critical, Ms. Salih said, “because if there is no subsidy, a lot of families would be in dire straits.”
Ms. Innamorato also began to make good on her campaign promise to diversify county government. She appointed acting county solicitor Rosalyn Guy-McCorkle to fill the post full-term and appointed Lena Bryan-Henderson to serve as chief public defender. She also named Barbara Griffin and Muhammad Ali Nasir (also known as MAN-E) to the jail board, Monica Malik and Jamilah Ducar to the Allegheny Regional Asset District, and Diamonte Walker to the redevelopment authority.
Some missteps
Ms. Innamorato’s first 100 days have not been without conflict.
In February, she announced five new mail and absentee ballot drop-off locations — but had failed to run the action through the elections board. County Councilman and GOP chair Sam DeMarco sued — and won. A judge ruled that the Board of Elections — consisting of Ms. Innamorato, Ms. Hallam and Mr. DeMarco — must vote on the locations, which it then did. The additional drop-off locations passed unanimously.
Mr. DeMarco’s point was procedural, not ideological. That’s the learning curve.
In an interview, Mr. DeMarco (no relation to Dan DeMarco) rattled off several other concerns about the new administration: How would they pay for the non-union county employee pay increases? Does Ms. Innamorato know the responsibilities of the executive and legislative branches? Does she understand the need to fill senior-level positions, especially county manager?
Mr. DeMarco also noted that when he first was elected, Mr. Fitzgerald contacted him and the two met for coffee. Mr. Fitzgerald, the county executive at the time, talked to Mr. DeMarco about why he ran, what issues were important to him, and his goals in office.
“I committed to him that as long as we were able to communicate, he didn't have to worry about waking up in the morning, looking at the newspaper, and seeing some sort of attack from me in there,” Mr. DeMarco said. “And we carried that through for eight years.”
Ms. Innamorato has made no such overture to Mr. DeMarco, he said.
But neither has she made such overtures to at least some of the Democrats on council.
Ms. Innamorato’s office declined to comment for this story.
Others are more willing than Mr. DeMarco, perhaps, to wait and see how she performs.
Jim Scalo, CEO of Burns Scalo Real Estate, said he and a handful of other business leaders recently met with Ms. Innamorato to discuss economic development and other issues.
Mr. Scalo said he was surprised at how focused on economic development she was. Perhaps more importantly, he said 100 days is likely not a fair barometer for truly assessing how she is doing.
“I don't think anybody's expected to see a lot of action in the first 100 days … 100 days is watch, listen and learn,” Mr. Scalo said. “But I would tell you [in the first] 12,18 months, you got to take action. And if there's massive changes, you have to make them then.”
Other big challenges ahead
But Ms. Innamorato may get less tolerance than her predecessors for taking some time to learn — because reassessment isn’t the only crisis at her door.
A related crisis is Pittsburgh’s struggling downtown, where business tenancy in many of the city’s high-rises has plummeted. Meanwhile, the city has struggled to accommodate the homeless. Pittsburgh’s problems are the county executive’s problems, too.
Allegheny County also has a demographics problem: Census data shows that for the second year in a row, the county had one of the sharpest population declines in the country.
All of that ties in with economic development, sustainable growth and maintaining budgets that can meet social services needs.
Looking forward
In the coming months, many municipal officials and political observers will remain attentive to Ms. Innamorato’s decision making.
Dan DeMarco and Denise Fitzgerald, manager of Scott Township, both said the future of fire and EMS service in small communities might have to be reimagined, as recruitment and retention continues to be a challenge.
There’s also the nuts and bolts of government — Ms. Fitzgerald said she would like to see partnerships on maintaining and improving sidewalks along county roads in the township. Projects like that can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, and grants from the county help make the work possible, she said.
Some, like Sam DeMarco, question why Ms. Innamorato hasn’t filled senior-level positions in her administration — such as county manager and jail warden — more quickly. She named people to lead economic development and the medical examiner’s office just this week. Mr. DeMarco suggested that she and her team should have been planning ahead on who might fill those roles since winning the primary last year, given her likely victory in the fall against a Republican in a county where Democrats heavily outnumber Republicans.
There are potentially bigger-picture discussions about the future of municipal governments in Allegheny County and how the county executive supports their shared goals.
An Lewis, Steel Rivers Council of Governments’ executive director who advocates on behalf of 19 municipalities in the Mon Valley, said she’s “very excited” to work with Ms. Innamorato in a more collaborative way.
“That's something … I have a bit of experience with, and I think it's a huge model of opportunity for the municipalities to work in cooperation with the county,” she said.
Still, big changes to governance models take time, Ms. Lewis and others said. And Ms. Innamorato is listening to various stakeholders, they said.
A number of political observers say the new county executive is being thoughtful as she handles the issues in front of her. She surrounded herself with an impressive array of advisors — including Carnegie Mellon University President Farnam Jahanian — from the moment she was elected in November.
Joseph Sabino Mistick, a law professor at Duquesne University and chief of staff to former Pittsburgh Mayor Sophie Masloff, said that it seems like Ms. Innamorato is relying on those with institutional knowledge to help her through her opening months leading the county.
“It appears that she's taking advice from some of the old hands,” Mr. Mistick said, “which is necessary because she obviously had no familiarity with county government when she won that office.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.