After debating dueling priorities last week, Pittsburgh City Council members have come to an agreement on how a Downtown tax abatement program should be shaped, but final approval could still be weeks away.
The legislation was introduced in mid-March as a way to help kick-start development Downtown, particularly in converting empty office space to affordable residential units.
Members approved new amendments to Councilman Bobby Wilson’s tax abatement legislation that, among other things, created a tiered system for what developments will receive what percentage of abatement.
For a residential project, if at least 10% of the units are for people earning at or below 50% of the area median income, the developer will receive 100% abatement. For other developments targeting residents who make an AMI higher than 50%, the abatement relief decreases: at 60% area median income, the developer will receive 95% abatement. For a family of four, Pittsburgh’s AMI is $101,200, according to 2024 calculations made by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
After the announcement of the legislation, originally only written for development with housing for 80% AMI, critics said there was an abundance of housing for people who make that level of income, but not enough for people who make less than that. This portion of the amendment attempts to tackle that critique, by incentivizing developments at lower AMI for higher abatements.
“In order to get the tax abatement for a housing project, that project has to include the affordability criteria,” Councilwoman Barb Warwick said Wednesday.
Read More
For a commercial project to receive the full abatement, it must create 50 full-time jobs. A development that creates between 40 and 49 jobs will receive 95% and from 30 to 39 jobs will receive 90%, based on the new amendment.
Projects that qualify for the abatement will receive the benefit for 10 years.
The new iteration of the legislation also explicitly bans new parking development from receiving any tax abatement and creates a monitoring committee that will issue annual reports to council of the efficacy of the program.
These amendments come after council members could not agree on two different sets of amendments last week, and multiple members noted that the new amendment was a compromise.
“We want to see hundreds of both market rate and affordable apartments built Downtown, so that we’re repopulating Downtown,” Councilwoman Deb Gross said. “I fear that we haven’t really put in as much guarantee as we might have for that public policy outcome.
“But ... this is a start,” she said.
Currently about 30% of the office space in the Golden Triangle is vacant.
“If we did nothing, it would virtually guarantee that our buildings Downtown are going to foreclose and be sold for pennies on the dollar in bankruptcy sales and undermine the real estate market and the taxable value for all Downtown properties, even the healthy ones,” Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said Wednesday.
Council President Daniel Lavelle pointed to the city of St. Louis, where the AT&T Tower used to be worth about $205 million and recently sold for about $3.5 million.
“This will avoid a scenario like that,” he said Wednesday.
Democratic state Sen. Wayne Fontana, whose district includes Downtown, voiced his support for the tax abatement program in a statement released Tuesday.
He also said he would introduce legislation to increase any future cap for the tax credit from the current state limit of 10 years to 20 years.
“The councilman’s proposal enjoys widespread support from property owners, developers, organized labor, and elected officials — for good reason,” Mr. Fontana’s statement said.
A program like this can “supercharge redevelopment while maintaining a strong tax base,” he said.
Council members approved the amendment Wednesday, but held the legislation for a public hearing, so that members of the community have an opportunity to speak on the legislation. The public hearing has not yet been scheduled.
Mr. Lavelle also called for a public meeting convening council members, Downtown stakeholders and union leaders to discuss the future of Downtown.
At Thursday’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, URA members will introduce a new “Downtown working group” that will bring together developers and other stakeholders who are interested in converting Downtown office buildings into housing, said Mr. Lavelle, who also sits on the URA board.
Many developers, Mr. Lavelle said, aren't aware of the tools available — such as housing vouchers — that can be used to help fund such projects.
"This is an opportunity to sit down with them and educate them on the various tools available to help them with the financing of conversion projects," he said.
Groups such as the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership and the Allegheny Conference on Community Development sent representatives to Wednesday’s city council meeting to speak in support of the legislation.
“We have a unique opportunity to work together to create a Downtown Pittsburgh that we all know is possible,” said Kat Weiser from the Allegheny Conference. “Without tools to attract and retain investment and redevelopment Downtown we will continue to lose business revenue.”
This story was updated on April 11 to correct a mischaracterization of the length of time a project can receive the tax abatement.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com
Staff writer Mark Belko contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.