Despite noting the urgency of the situation, Pittsburgh City Council members still aren’t in agreement over the details of a tax abatement program that could be “one tool to save Downtown.”
Three weeks ago, Councilman Bobby Wilson introduced legislation that would allow property owners or developers to have half of their city real estate taxes abated for the next 10 years for construction, improvements or conversions — if the projects created at least 50 full-time jobs or provided some affordable housing.
“This is not going to be the magic cushion that makes it all work,” Mr. Wilson said during Wednesday’s meeting, but this could be “one tool to save Downtown.”
The Downtown vacancy rate was at 27% last month, and could reach nearly 50% by 2028.
Coupled with growing vacancy rates and impending foreclosures of major Downtown properties, the city is also grappling with shrinking property tax revenues, as multiple high-rises in the Golden Triangle have had their assessment values slashed.
The goal is to help aid development, namely the conversion of empty office buildings to residential spaces, with the hope of stabilizing the city’s tax base. Nearly 25% of Pittsburgh’s property tax revenue comes from Downtown.
Mr. Wilson’s office estimated that the assessed value of Golden Triangle buildings could be cut in half over the next few years as a result of appeals. That could cost the city $17.5 million a year in tax revenue.
Mr. Wilson introduced some amendments Wednesday, which altered the specifications for the affordable housing component, but during council’s first public discussion of the legislation multiple members took issue with various aspects of Mr. Wilson’s plan.
“I am such a hard no on this, I cannot underscore it enough,” Councilwoman Barb Warwick said during Wednesday’s meeting. “As this bill is written now, including the amendments, there is no requirement to build any housing Downtown — affordable or otherwise.”
She said her concern was that developers would rehabilitate the properties for commercial use, and by creating 50 jobs, would still receive the full tax relief.
“Now there’s an option to do affordable housing. ... But you don’t have to. It’s just an option,” she said. “We are offering to give away millions of tax dollars with zero requirement that they produce any housing at all.”
Other council members also took issue with the proposal.
Councilwoman Deb Gross voiced concerns that some of the language would incentivize more parking garages and hotels to be built.
Councilman Anthony Coghill said he was concerned that the legislation didn’t include a requirement for the developers to use union laborers.
Together Ms. Warwick, Ms. Gross and Mr. Coghill presented their own amendments that would decrease the length of time developers would receive the abatement from 10 years to three years, would eliminate the 50-employee eligibility requirement and alter the affordable housing components.
“Some of these concerns need to be ironed out,” Mr. Coghill said, adding that he wasn’t prepared to vote on any of the amendments Wednesday.
Ultimately, none of the amendments were voted on. Council members agreed to hold the legislation until next week in an effort to work out a compromise.
“This is not fly-by-night legislation,” Council President Dan Lavelle said, noting that conversations with stakeholders started even last year. “This has been done with intentionality.”
Mr. Lavelle cautioned members that he didn’t think they would be able to “come up with a perfect bill.”
“I don’t believe we’re going to come up with a bill that makes everyone 100% happy,” he said.
The city already has an existing tax abatement program, which has also been adopted by the county and Pittsburgh Public School District. That program has a tax relief limit of $250,000. Mr. Wilson’s legislation, as it stands, would remove that cap.
The city is currently limited by state law to only offer abatements for 10 years, but state Sen. Wayne Fontana, whose district includes Downtown, is looking into introducing legislation that would extend the allowance to 20 years.
“We really need to look more carefully at what it is that we’re trying to accomplish,” Ms. Gross said.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.