Allegheny County’s longtime district attorney and his progressive challenger brought their increasingly bitter disagreements to a debate stage Thursday, clashing on campaign tactics, the role of the top prosecutor in preliminary court hearings, and other public safety issues.

Incumbent Stephen A. Zappala Jr., who has been DA since 1998 and is seeking a seventh term, lost the May Democratic primary to Matt Dugan, the county’s former chief public defender. But Mr. Zappala is running in the Nov. 7 general election after winning the Republican nomination as a write-in candidate, and faces Mr. Dugan again in a rematch.

Mr. Dugan and Mr. Zappala have traded several barbs on the campaign trail in recent months, in TV ads and public statements. Mr. Zappala has said Mr. Dugan doesn’t have the experience or knowledge to be the county’s top prosecutor. Mr. Dugan has said Mr. Zappala hasn’t done enough in 25 years as DA to address crime in Downtown Pittsburgh and elsewhere in the county, and that it’s time for new leadership.

That continued Thursday, especially toward the end of the debate hosted by KDKA. In one particularly heated exchange, the candidates were asked about the influence of people outside Allegheny County on the election.

Advertise with us

The New York-based billionaire liberal philanthropist and mega donor George Soros entirely funded a group that paid for almost all of Mr. Dugan’s primary campaign. The group has continued to underwrite Mr. Dugan’s general election TV ads, though it won’t be clear until financial filings later this month whether or not Mr. Soros remains its sole funder. Meanwhile, TV ads from Mr. Zappala, a lifelong Democrat whose campaign is now being run by Republicans,  have taken a tone on crime more typical to GOP campaigns across the country. And the Forward Party, a centrist political group founded by the former Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang, has endorsed Mr. Zappala.

Mr. Zappala said Mr. Soros’ heavy spending has led to a situation in which he hasn’t been able to combat misinformation about his campaign. He noted that Mr. Soros has supported progressive candidates in other races for district attorney across the country, including Larry Krasner in Philadelphia.

Mr. Dugan countered that Mr. Zappala’s campaign tactics — such as television ads labeling the challenger a friend of criminals and soft on crime, are straight out of a GOP playbook.

“My message has been homegrown, since the first day we stepped on the campaign [trail],” Mr. Dugan said. “What are lies, what is repulsive is the right-wing GOP attack ads Zappala are airing right now. And he’s doing that because he’s a desperate man.”

The two candidates also sparred multiple times about the role of the DA’s office in preliminary arraignment hearings, and specifically about a recent case in which a man was found allegedly carrying well over $1 million worth of fentanyl at a Pittsburgh bus station. He was released by a judge without cash bail, pending an appearance at a future court hearing. He did not show up for it.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dugan said he would make sure the DA’s office has a presence at those hearings so that such a situation doesn’t happen again. If a judge is about to issue a bad decision, he said, prosecutors would be there to immediately appeal.

But Mr. Zappala said the case reflected a breakdown of the entire judicial system, not incompetence in the DA’s office. And he called it “naive” to think prosecutors should be adversarial at that stage of proceedings.

“The courts are an independent branch of government, and so the whole process is based upon a judge hearing from another branch of the judiciary and making a decision about whether or not somebody is a danger to the community… every first-year law student understands that,” Mr. Zappala said. “We’ve been electing political, activist judges, and they’re politicking from the bench.”

Both men did agree on some issues — including on the need for significant juvenile justice reform. They did not offer detailed positions on the future of the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center, which was closed in 2021 and is set to reopen under a contract with an outside social services provider.

The decision to reopen the center with an outside provider without more input from the DA or law enforcement was a mistake, Mr. Zappala and Mr. Dugan said.

Advertise with us

And both candidates supported diversion courts for lower-level offenders like mental health and drug courts. But Mr. Dugan said those courts need to be modernized and expanded, and need to be more accessible to people who don’t have experience navigating the criminal justice system. Mr. Zappala, however, touted his success with those diversion programs, saying his office has handled thousands of cases annually.

The incumbent has continued to criticize city officials, including Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, for what he calls a lack of cooperation in handling Downtown crime. He said Thursday that prior mayors like Luke Ravenstahl and Bob O’Connor had been more collaborative. (Mr. Gainey has dismissed Mr. Zappala’s criticisms as election season posturing.)

Mr. Zappala also lauded former New York City Mayor Rudy Guliani’s support of what’s known as the Broken Windows Theory of policing. Broadly speaking, the theory holds that when property crimes like vandalism are not addressed, they lead to more serious crimes.

“You have to listen to the business community,” Mr. Zappala said. “When property crimes stopped being enforced, and the business community did not have a voice on the impact that had on Downtown, then everything goes bad.”

Mr. Dugan said he’s offered a better plan to address Downtown crime, including a single court and judge to handle Downtown cases, a team of assistant district attorneys for such cases, and a liaison to respond quickly to residents and business owners’ complaints. He said Thursday that the business community had input into his plan.

“We will prosecute low-level crimes, but we will offer off-ramps for folks… when it’s appropriate, to divert them out of the criminal justice system,” Mr. Dugan said. “We will have accountability, but we’ll also have common sense.”