Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala, Jr. is looking to stand on his record as he faces Matt Dugan in the Nov. 7 general election, a rematch against the county’s former chief public defender who defeated him in the May Democratic primary.

Mr. Zappala, a lifelong Democrat who has been the county’s top prosecutor since 1998, got enough Republican write-in votes in the primary to become the GOP nominee. He’s running to keep a position he has held since a panel of local judges first picked him to replace his predecessor. After about a quarter-century in office, Mr. Zappala is campaigning more on his record than on particular policy proposals, saying public safety would suffer under Mr. Dugan.

The two will face off Thursday in their only scheduled debate of the general election so far, airing at 8 p.m. on KDKA+.

Here’s what to know about some of Mr. Zappala’s policy positions before the two take the debate stage. Click here to learn more about Mr. Dugan’s policies.

Advertise with us

Tweaking the use of cash bail

More defendants at Pittsburgh Municipal Court have had access to public defenders in recent years, in an attempt to reduce the number of low-level, nonviolent offenders in pretrial incarceration.

And the number of cases involving cash bail in Allegheny County has declined in recent years, according to studies by the ACLU and Rand Corporation. Some opponents of Mr. Zappala say that trend hasn’t gone far enough, and that racial disparities and inequities persist.

In 2018, Mr. Zappala sent a letter to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, asking that courts be permitted to use “unbiased and validated” software to assess the risk of granting pretrial release to people charged with lower-level offenses.

“Our experiences have shown that the setting of monetary bail for defendants who are charged with relatively minor crimes and who do not pose a danger to another person or to the community often results in unnecessary, unfair, and costly pretrial detention of indigent defendants,” Mr. Zappala wrote in the letter.

Mr. Zappala had also lobbied Supreme Court justices in 2004, asking them to change court procedures so that bail could be reduced.

Advertise with us

But the district attorney has also warned against creating a system that is too lenient. In September, he criticized a local magistrate judge who released a New York man found at Pittsburgh’s Greyhound Bus station with more than $1 million worth of fentanyl.

Mr. Zappala said in a statement that the man, “although presumed innocent, is accused of trafficking an extremely large quantity of drugs which are responsible for the deaths of almost two people per day in Allegheny County.”

Creating diversion courts

One achievement Mr. Zappala has often touted during his career is the creation of diversion courts for veterans, people struggling with substance abuse and mental health, and other lower-level offenders.

There is also the “Phoenix Court,” which allows nonviolent offenders to enter a plea deal much more quickly than through the typical judicial process. About 7,000 cases have gone through that process annually in recent years, Mr. Zappala has said. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, the Phoenix Court handled about 4,000 DUI cases annually, and allowed those with DUI charges to have their record cleared once they completed the conditions of their probation — a process known as Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition, or ARD.

Those numbers have dropped more recently because of the pandemic-driven shutdown of courts, a spokesperson for Mr. Zappala said. In 2022, there were about 4,700 cases handled in Phoenix Court, and about 1,500 cases that went through the ARD process — of which more than 1,400 were DUI cases, the spokesperson said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Zappala’s office said in September that hundreds of people have gone through the county’s Drug Court and Mental Health Court programs since he took office. His office says it provides “the means to help addicted individuals within the criminal justice system address their addictions.”

Although Mr. Zappala has championed these diversion programs, he has also said that different parts of government need to address the underlying causes of why people end up in them. Prosecutors have a limited role, he says.

“Crime has a direct correlation to poverty,” Mr. Zappala said in 2019. “I’m not in charge of transportation, safe and decent housing, or education. I’m on the back-end of government. I think our entire government needs to look at our successes and failures because the criminal justice system can’t fix this — not by ourselves.”

Addressing Downtown crime concerns

City leaders need to do more to allow police officers to do their jobs to address crime in Downtown Pittsburgh, Mr. Zappala said last month.

He has said multiple times in recent months that there needs to be more law enforcement emphasis on drug dealers, along with those who openly use illegal drugs. Mr. Zappala said he’s faced resistance from city leaders, including Mayor Ed Gainey.

Advertise with us

“We've offered to assist the city in expedited eviction of drug traffickers as well as drug nuisance people. The city has not taken up our offer,” Mr. Zappala said during a briefing in August. “It's been difficult … to work with the mayor's administration to find out how comprehensive the camera system is. We're trying to do that to help out the private sector.”

Following Mr. Zappala’s criticism of his office last month, Mr. Gainey responded, in part: “I’m not going to go back and forth with the [district attorney]. The DA’s been there for 20 years. It is what it is. The only time I’ve heard him speak is right now. … There are different issues that he could be attacking right now, to bring peace to this city instead of violence.”

Mr. Zappala believes many of the policies that Mr. Dugan supports are not in the district attorney’s jurisdiction.

“For many of the policies he proposes, he should consider running for an office that can actually do the things he proposes,” he said. “The district attorney’s office is a law enforcement office, not a social service agency.”