Matt Dugan wants to explore greater reductions in cash bail, modernize diversion programs such as mental health and drug courts, and create a single court with a single judge to handle criminal cases for Pittsburgh’s Downtown.

Those are some of Mr. Dugan’s key policy priorities in his campaign for Allegheny County district attorney. Mr. Dugan, the county’s former chief public defender, is running as a progressive challenger to longtime incumbent DA Stephen A. Zappala. Mr. Dugan beat Mr. Zappala in the May Democratic primary, but they face a rematch in the Nov. 7 general election after Mr. Zappala garnered enough Republican write-in votes to win the GOP nomination.

The two will face off Thursday in their only scheduled debate of the general election so far, airing at 8 p.m. on KDKA+.

Here’s what to know about some of Mr. Dugan’s policy positions before the two take the debate stage. Click here to learn more about Mr. Zappala’s policies.

Advertise with us

Reforming bail to focus on the most serious crimes

Like other progressive candidates in races for prosecutor, Mr. Dugan — who worked in the county public defender’s office for several years and resigned as chief public defender in July — has long advocated for reforming the bail system. He says on his campaign website that cash bail both unfairly hurts low-income residents and allows violent criminals to walk free before trial.

“Studies have repeatedly shown there is no relationship between a person's ability to post a cash bail and the chances that person will either appear for court or commit a crime once released,” Mr. Dugan said in a statement.

The issue has been a flashpoint in other district attorney races, and after progressive candidates have taken office. In 2020, Philadelphia DA Larry Krasner criticized a state Supreme Court ruling that blocked his office from changing the system.

More defendants in Pittsburgh have been provided a public defender at bail hearings in recent years under Mr. Zappala’s tenure. Studies show that led to less use of cash bail for defendants accused of lower-level crimes.

Mr. Dugan has been supportive of those changes, but has gone further — saying that if he’s elected, he would never request cash bail.

Advertise with us

Supporters of Mr. Dugan’s view say that reforming the cash bail system prevents poor, marginalized people who are lower risk to society from being incarcerated. Opponents say it allows criminals back onto the streets, where they pose a risk to the community.

A RAND Corporation study in May found that providing a public defender at bail hearings reduces pretrial detention rates while increasing rearrests, particularly for third-degree felony theft charges. Mr. Dugan says he’s fine with the tradeoff, as long as there's no increase in violent crime.

“If a defendant has a history of violent behavior and poses a significant danger to the community, as District Attorney I will advocate for conditions of release (no contact orders, electronic monitoring) or the denial of bail,” he says on his website.

Building on diversion programs and violence prevention

One of Mr. Dugan’s central priorities is building diversion programs, along with violence prevention and intervention initiatives, to lighten the load on the judicial system.

He says that in Allegheny County’s current system, too many prosecutions focus on low-level, non-violent offenses involving substance abuse disorder, untreated or undiagnosed mental health issues, or a lack of stable housing or employment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dugan says having access to housing and other resources is important to preventing people from re-offending, and is more cost-effective in the long-term. He says on his website that prosecutors often stack up multiple charges against defendants to pressure them to accept plea deals, many of which include probation.

Mr. Dugan does not support prosecuting minor drug offenses, such as low-level marijuana possession. And he has said that diversion programs, like drug court and veterans court, need to be expanded so more people are eligible for them.

“It takes a certain level of offender, meaning you have to have gone through the system multiple times and failed multiple times before you're even eligible to be considered for these programs,” Mr. Dugan told City Paper in January. “We know treatment courts work. When people get these services, they are less likely to recidivate. We just need to do this sooner in the process.”

There needs to be more collaboration between prosecutors, public defenders, and social service providers to prevent low-level offenders from facing criminal convictions, Mr. Dugan said — something that can affect the rest of their lives.

A single court for Downtown crime

During a campaign speech last month, Mr. Dugan addressed simmering concerns about crime and homelessness Downtown — and said there needs to be a more centralized approach to the problem.

Advertise with us

He advocated for the creation of a single court, headed by a single Magisterial District Judge, to preside over all criminal cases Downtown. He said he would work with court officials and the president judge of Allegheny County’s Common Pleas Court to implement that change.

A county spokesperson said such a change would have to be implemented by the courts, and that no executive or legislative action would be required.

Mr. Dugan says he’d assign a team of assistant district attorneys to focus on the neighborhood, working with police to focus on open-air drug transactions, open-air drug use, threatening behavior, and violent crime.

“We need a system that provides consistency in decision-making and one that lends itself to a more intimate knowledge of the defendants in criminal cases, and more accountability to the residents and business owners of downtown Pittsburgh,” Mr. Dugan said in September.

Mr. Dugan said he would also tap a community liaison for Pittsburgh, who would connect with residents and business owners. Mr. Dugan said Mr. Zappala hasn’t adequately addressed Downtown crime.=

Advertise with us

“It's time the District Attorney’s Office assumes a leadership position in downtown Pittsburgh,” Mr. Dugan said. “It’s time we have a district attorney who accepts the responsibility of tackling public safety in downtown Pittsburgh.  Law enforcement begins with the DA’s office.”

Mr. Zappala responded, in part: “Matt Dugan clearly doesn’t understand the job of district attorney, which makes sense given Dugan has spent his entire career fighting to keep the people I prosecute out on the street.”