Robert F. Kennedy Jr. didn’t start the trend: School-age vaccinations have been decreasing in Allegheny County since the 2013 school year, leaving kids vulnerable to certain diseases. And a recent county-wide drop has surpassed a crucial threshold to keep highly infectious diseases like measles at bay.
During the 2023–2024 school year, the percentage of Allegheny County kids who were fully vaccinated was at 94.6%, per the most recent Health Department immunization report. The threshold for herd immunity for measles — when enough people have been immunized against a disease to protect the population — is 95%.
Religious exemptions for vaccines in Allegheny County have also doubled, per the report.
“We have been seeing a very slow but consistent decline in school-age vaccinations for at least a decade,” said Barbara Nightingale, Allegheny County Health Department’s (ACHD) deputy director for clinical services, in an email. “We know that residents are exposed to a lot of vaccine misinformation, particularly regarding vaccine safety.”
The county abides by the state regulations for immunizations in school kids, which are required — unless there are approved exceptions — for attendance and include coverage for numerous diseases, including measles and polio.
County officials note that a slight decrease between 2020 and 2022 was likely from a drop in preventive health care visits, and therefore fewer opportunities to immunize, because of the COVID-19 pandemic — but that the downward swing continued after the pandemic as well.
Read More

It’s a “very concerning” trend, said Mary Krauland, a research assistant professor and member of the Pitt Public Health Dynamics Laboratory, which uses data visualizations to help understand the potential spread of infectious diseases. “It increases the potential for really contagious diseases to take off,” she said.
The immunization report comes during a time of increasing vaccine hesitancy and conspiracy theories, and on the heels of a global pandemic. One February 2023 survey of nearly 25,000 Americans found that one in five believed at least one debunked COVID-19 vaccine myth. And data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention shows this vaccine hesitancy may have bled over to routine vaccinations in some areas, a trend that has been reflected across Pennsylvania.
Health and Human Services Secretary nominee Mr. Kennedy has long questioned the safety of vaccines and said they cause autism, a claim that has been widely disputed by the medical community. In 2019, he traveled to Samoa and urged residents of the island nation to seek “alternative methods” of measles vaccination. That led to a measles outbreak of 5,700 cases and 83 deaths.
If he’s appointed, such fringe beliefs have the potential to gain even more traction.
With Allegheny County’s child vaccination levels where they are, the threat is a lack of herd immunity to protect everyone, said Maureen Lichtveld, dean of the Pitt School of Public Health and a former CDC employee.
“The numbers concern me from a public health perspective,” she said. “There might be exemptions. I understand. It really is a personal responsibility toward your community. That’s not well enough emphasized. It’s not only a personal decision — you’re putting your community at risk.”
Certain schools within the Pittsburgh Public School District fared better than others. Some, like Pittsburgh Spring Hill K–5, Pittsburgh Philips K–5 and Pittsburgh Sunnyside PreK–8 hovered around 99% of students who were completely immunized, according to the Allegheny County School Immunization Dashboard.
On the low end of vaccine uptake are Pittsburgh Arsenal PreK–5, Arsenal 6–8 and Pittsburgh Banksville K–5, with 56.3%, 61.7% and 74.5% complete immunization, respectively, making them prime hotspots for outbreaks.
There could be many reasons for these low numbers, including incomplete reporting or an inability for school nurses to access student vaccine records. It’s also not clear when the data was gathered, and if provisional enrollment numbers, which occur when a student is partially vaccinated or the parent intends to get them vaccinated soon, have been updated to reflect complete vaccination.
“Kindergarteners may have gotten their vaccines and then the parents didn’t report it, or they’re going to get it,” said Ms. Krauland. “Maybe they don’t have insurance coverage or they don’t know where to go. Some of this will be socioeconomic, and … there may be ways to get the vaccine to them.”
ACHD has upped vaccine outreach efforts to combat this, including offering free vaccinations at the Immunization Clinic on First Avenue Downtown. To make an appointment, call 412-578-8062. You can also walk in.
The state Department of Health (DOH) said in an email statement that it funded a vaccine awareness campaign last year, using TV, radio, print and social media, to remind Pennsylvania parents of young kids to get vaccinated.
“It is critically important that children remain up to date with vaccinations and receive those vaccinations at the appropriate time,” said Neil Ruhland, DOH spokesperson, in the statement. “On-time vaccinations throughout childhood are essential because they help provide immunity before children are exposed to potentially life-threatening diseases. DOH encourages all parents of school-aged children to ensure their young learners are current on their required vaccinations before a given school year starts.”
DOH also said it actively encourages pediatricians to discuss vaccines with parents and help address concerns they may have.
“For children who are underinsured or uninsured, vaccines are available through local state health centers, federally qualified health centers, and the Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s Vaccines for Children Program,” said Mr. Ruhland. “The program provides all recommended vaccinations against 19 different diseases at no cost to eligible children and helps ensure all U.S. children are protected from life-threatening diseases.”
Dr. Nightingale said that since August, the county health department has been evaluating different approaches to address vaccine hesitancy and misinformation. “We are currently completing that formal evaluation and hope to use the information gathered to implement strategies that will amplify vaccine information and combat misinformation.”
A few of the numbers from the Allegheny County report stuck out to Ms. Krauland: For one, that just 89.5% of kids at parochial and religious schools were immunized against measles, 90% against polio.
“That’s very concerning,” she said. “School is a great place to pick up diseases like this, and we have seen this.”
The U.S. saw 16 distinct outbreaks and nearly 300 cases of measles in 2024, a disease that was considered to be eradicated from the nation in 2000. A handful of those cases were in Pennsylvania.
“I highly encourage parents and caregivers to have their child vaccinated” against measles, said Dr. Nightingale. “The MMR vaccine is very safe and highly effective at preventing measles.”
The measles virus is about 15 times more contagious than the flu, based on infectious disease estimates of transmissibility, and can lead to ear infections, diarrhea, pneumonia, brain swelling and death. In 2024, 40% of those with measles were hospitalized.
“For the last several years now, we are seeing pockets of measles occurring in college-age kids nationally,” said Lichtveld. “That means there is a lack of coverage much earlier on” in the child’s life.
Additionally, kids born in 2021, who are not yet in kindergarten but may not be vaccinated, are not reflected in the school-age county data — but can still spread measles to other kids who are in school. This makes those lower coverage areas ideal pockets for the virus to implant. Measles experts have compared it to throwing a lit match in a dry field versus a wet one — a school with just 89.5% of kids immunized against measles is the dry field.
“You’re waiting for that spark that will catch fire,” Ms. Krauland said. “But if there’s a spark, there will be fire.”
Part of the work to increase vaccine uptake is helping parents understand the turmoil these diseases once brought to communities, she said.
“I remember the polio vaccine on a sugar cube,” said Ms. Krauland. “People in their 30s and 40s don’t have that same experience. They tend to think they are not serious diseases. That is wrong.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.