Pediatrician Joe Aracri remembers his one measles patient in March 2009.

The 10-year-old boy had deboarded a plane from India and come immediately to his office with a high fever, rash, cough, runny nose and fatigue. Because of the severity of the child’s illness, Dr. Aracri sent him to UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh.

In the emergency room at the Lawrenceville hospital, the child came in contact with a father and his two small, unvaccinated children, who spread measles to Westmoreland County, infecting a handful of others. Whereas in Dr. Aracri’s clinic earlier that day, vaccination rates were high, and contact tracing showed that no one in the waiting room who overlapped with the boy contracted measles.

Measles vaccination rates are a topic of conversation yet again as the virus spreads throughout Texas, with 124 cases as of Tuesday, and into New Mexico, and physicians brace for uncertain future for infectious disease.

Advertise with us

Though a “relatively large measles outbreak for the U.S.,” it’s not surprising to William Moss, a pediatrician and executive director of the International Vaccine Access Center at the Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health. “It’s not completely unexpected. We have communities here in the U.S. where measles vaccine coverage is lower than what it needs to be to prevent these outbreaks from happening,” he said.

In the Texas county where a majority of the current cases are located — Gaines County, on the New Mexico border — the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccination rate is 82%, far below the 95% threshold at which herd immunity protects communities from the virus.

The first death linked to the outbreak —  a “school-aged child who was not vaccinated” and had been hospitalized in the panhandle city of Lubbock — was announced by the Texas Department of State Health Services on Wednesday.

The outbreak comes as Robert F. Kennedy Jr., known widely for his skepticism of vaccines and, in particular, the MMR vaccine, settles into the role of Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Children’s Health Defense, a nonprofit founded by Mr. Kennedy and for which he has served as chairman, continues to post articles stating the MMR vaccine is unsafe and has been posting similar articles for more than 20 years, despite decades of evidence of its safety and efficacy.

With declining vaccination rates across the country and an increase in distrust of public health expertise, an outbreak like this was “inevitable,” said Michael Stevens, system health care epidemiologist and chief quality officer at West Virginia University Medicine.

Advertise with us

“We’re going to see these diseases without question,” said Dr. Stevens, also a physician and professor of internal medicine.

A recent Allegheny County School Immunization Report showed a decline in routine vaccinations from 96.7% to 94.6% over seven years, with potential hotspots in schools below the 95% threshold.

The countywide average for the MMR vaccine sits at 96.7%, according to the Allegheny County Health Department Immunization Dashboard. But while some schools have high rates of fully immunized students, other schools, including Pittsburgh Classical 6–8, sit at 93.6%, with a high percentage, 5.2%, of students with vaccine exemptions.

Pittsburgh Montessori PreK–5’s exemption rate is even higher, at 5.8%. Most other schools in the Pittsburgh Public system have a vaccine exception rate at around 2%.

A spokesperson for the Allegheny County Health Department said its immunization program is contacting schools with low vaccine coverage to offer immunization services on site.

Advertise with us

The general population, as a whole, isn’t at a huge risk for debilitating measles illness, because vaccination rates are still relatively high, said Dr. Moss. But coverage is lower than ideal, he said, and certain communities with low vaccine uptake — especially below that crucial 95% immunization threshold — are particularly vulnerable.

“What will happen is that the virus will continue to spread as long as it’s being brought into communities with low vaccine coverage,” he said. “These kinds of communities with susceptible children are typically kind of invisible, and measles is the disease that points out these weaknesses in the system.”

Pennsylvania is one of 15 states that allows personal exemptions for vaccines, per data collected by the National Conference on State Legislatures and LexisNexis StateNet Database. Only California, West Virginia, Connecticut, New York and Maine do not allow religious or personal exemptions for vaccines. Those five states do allow medical exemptions.

Officials at the county health department have said some Allegheny County schools with low percentages of fully immunized students may suffer from a lack of data or missing data, and that percentages may be higher than reflected on the dashboard. But the downward trend reflects a growing movement of vaccine skepticism, once niche, now entering more of a mainstream narrative.

“There is so much misinformation out there that vaccines are causing sickness,” said Joseph Robare, an associate professor and director of the masters of public health program at Slippery Rock University. “I don’t think vaccines have ever been safer.”

Advertise with us

Two doses of the MMR vaccine have been shown through decades of clinical trials to be safe and 97% effective at preventing severe illness from measles, per the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Andrew Wakefield, the U.K. scientist who falsely raised alarm about the MMR vaccine with a 1998 paper linking it to autism, was stripped of his medical license because of manipulated data and fabricated results. In 2004, 10 of the paper’s 12 authors issued retractions, and the editor of the Lancet, where the study was published, said in hindsight it never should have been.

Part of the issue, too, is that vaccines suffer from their own success. Measles was considered eradicated in the U.S. in 2000 after widespread vaccination efforts, so many parents today haven’t seen how severe the illness can be, with the risk of pneumonia, brain swelling and death.

“All parents want to do what’s best for their children,” said Dr. Moss. “Because of the success of the immunization program, they underestimate the risk of measles, and then because of mis- and disinformation, they overestimate the risk of the vaccine. They make this calculus, that what they think is in the best interest of their child, not to vaccinate against measles.

“What these outbreaks show,” he went on, “is that this is the wrong risk benefit analysis to make.”

Advertise with us

The measles virus is spread through airborne droplets, similar to coronaviruses, and it can stay in the air after an infected person leaves a room for up to two hours.

A calculation called the R-0 (pronounced R-naught) dictates how many people are likely to get infected from one infected person and helps infectious disease researchers understand how transmissible a disease is. The R-0 of the seasonal influenza virus is between one and two, meaning one person with the flu is likely to infect one or two other people.

The R-0 for measles? Between 12 and 18.

“This is the most contagious childhood disease known to man,” said Dr. Stevens.

Once contracted, it can be very severe. In 2024, 40% of people who were infected with measles in the U.S. were hospitalized, either because of complications from the disease or for isolation purposes, according to the CDC.

Advertise with us

“No one would wish having this disease on anyone else,” said Dr. Stevens.

The Texas outbreak began in Harris County, which encompasses Houston among other communities, in late January when two unvaccinated individuals returned from international travel. It’s the worst outbreak in Texas in 30 years and the first set of cases in two years, according to the Texas Department of Health and Human Services.

In less than one month, those cases ballooned to 124 across seven counties. Per Feb. 25 data from the Texas Health Department website, about a third of those infections are in children ages 0 to 4, and half are ages 5 to 17.

In 2024, 52% of all measles cases in the U.S. were in kids ages 0 to 4.

At Gaines County’s Loop Independent School District, the vaccine exemption rate is 48%, according to state data.

Advertise with us

New Mexico’s Lea County, which touches Texas’ Gaines County, reported its first case on Feb. 11, with the New Mexico Department of Health’s chief officer Miranda Durham issuing a statement and urging parents to keep their kids up to date on vaccines. The state had nine cases as of Feb. 25.

Parents who are feeling skeptical or who have questions about the MMR vaccine should contact their health care provider.

“It’s critical that folks have good relationships with health care providers that they trust and have a frank and open discussion about the risk and benefit of vaccines,” said Dr. Stevens.

Joseph Robare has four children and said he and his wife discussed vaccine scheduling and safety with their pediatrician before getting them vaccinated. “We followed the vaccine schedule because my wife and I feel you’re setting them up for success with health when you do that,” he said. “We’ve talked about vaccines and discussed it with our pediatrician. Those are going to be the ones to guide you through this process.”

He hopes Mr. Kennedy won’t change the vaccine schedule, which is set by the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (APIC) and confirmed by multiple agencies such as the American Academy of Pediatrics before being recommended.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kennedy had vowed not to change the schedule but reversed course quickly after being confirmed, saying “nothing is going to be off limits” in terms of widespread federal changes to a crowd of Health and Human Service employees last week.

Politico reported on Feb. 20 the Health secretary has plans to fire most APIC staffers, according to two sources familiar with the plans.

“Under this current administration, I do fear that this trust will be further eroded,” said Dr. Moss.

“We have the perfect storm” for future outbreaks, he added. “This is a harbinger of the future in terms of increased frequency and size of measles outbreaks in the U.S.”

Parents who have not yet gotten an MMR vaccine for their children can do so at:

Advertise with us
  • Allegheny County’s Immunization Clinic on First Avenue Downtown by calling 412-578-8062 or walking in
  • Pitt Vaccination and Health Connection Hub in Oakland by calling 412-383-4372, emailing thehub@pitt.edu or walking in
  • Their pediatrician’s office.

The CDC’s website has ample information on vaccine safety, including a breakdown on one webpage called “Reasons to Follow CDC’s Recommended Immunization Schedule,” which outlines why the schedule is laid out how it is for those with questions.