It wasn’t a surprise when President-elect Donald Trump announced his plan to appoint Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as secretary to the Department of Health and Human Services, but the news put many in the medical community on alert — watching to see how the nominee’s rhetoric will affect his approach to leading the key federal agency.

The enormity of the new role — the HHS secretary oversees 13 federal agencies and their combined $1.7 trillion budget — will hand over a significant amount of responsibility for the nation’s health to Mr. Kennedy, who has limited applicable experience in the field and a history of promoting debunked health conspiracy theories as well as being a vaccine skeptic.

Concern over Mr. Kennedy’s statements about vaccines has already begun to stir opposition to the appointment. Nearly 14,000 physicians have signed a petition objecting to the nominee. The petition, led by a nonprofit, The Committee to Protect Health Care, has a goal of 15,000 signatures.

“Many physicians are looking at this and thinking, ‘We’re going to watch the destruction of the public health system,’” said Alice Rothchild, a Seattle-based retired OB-GYN who was one of those to sign.

Advertise with us

While public questioning of Western science, pharmaceutical industries and even vaccines is certainly not new, the spotlight placed on those who oppose vaccines has grown brighter in recent years — especially as the COVID-19 pandemic became politicized and public health measures, like social distancing and masking, received criticism among some groups.

And as trust in science declines, some are turning toward fringe beliefs, many that RFK Jr. himself has supported, such as trusting herd immunity over vaccination or experimental and debunked treatments like ivermectin.

Why was RFK Jr. chosen?

In a Nov. 14 emailed statement announcing the nomination, Trump said the Department of Health and Human Services plays an important role in ensuring the health of the nation, including “that everybody will be protected from harmful chemicals, pollutants, pesticides, pharmaceutical products, and food additives that have contributed to the overwhelming health crisis in this country.

“Mr. Kennedy will restore these agencies to the traditions of gold standard scientific research, and beacons of transparency, to end the chronic disease epidemic, and to Make America Great and Healthy Again!”

The statement seems to suggest that Trump chose Mr. Kennedy explicitly because of his nontraditional approaches.

Advertise with us

Is RFK Jr. equipped for the role of health secretary?

Georges Benjamin, a physician and the executive director of the American Public Health Association, responded with a Nov. 18 statement that Mr. Kennedy “fails on all fronts” to effectively lead HHS.

Certainly, it’s a big job.

The nation’s health secretary is in charge of preparing for and responding to medical and public health emergencies, such as circulating infectious diseases. The position also controls funding to agencies under the HHS umbrella, including Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Food and Drug Administration and the National Institutes of Health, the latter of which oversees thousands of clinical trials and the research and development of drug treatments.

The Senate will vote on many of Trump’s cabinet nominees once the new president is sworn in. Historically, it is rare for nominees to be rejected.

A half-dozen medical experts interviewed for this story pointed to Mr. Kennedy’s dogged criticism of vaccines throughout his career, including falsely stating that vaccines cause autism. The one paper that had linked MMR vaccines to autism was retracted by the journal that published it 12 years later, and the scientist was stripped of his medical license after results were found to be fraudulent and fabricated.

Advertise with us

Other debunked health claims made by Mr. Kennedy include that human immunodeficiency virus, or HIV, is not the cause for AIDS, and that raw milk is safe to drink. While it is sold in Pennsylvania, the FDA has stated that raw milk is not safe because it may contain dangerous bacteria that are typically killed during the pasteurization process.

Requests for comment on Mr. Kennedy’s nomination from members of the GOP Doctors Caucus, including to former co-chair house Rep. Andy Harris (R-Md.), Brian Babin (R-Tex.) and John Joyce (R-Pa.), were not returned.

In a Nov. 15 post on X, Mr. Harris congratulated Mr. Kennedy on the nomination and said he looked forward to working with him “in the fight to reform nutritious foods.”

Spokespeople for Mr. Kennedy did not respond to requests for comment.

But many of those with concerns aren’t shy about raising their issues.

Advertise with us

“This is a time when we need the highest level of competence possible at HHS,” said Peter Hotez, dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine and a professor of pediatrics and molecular biology, who has spent his career developing vaccines for tropical diseases.

Dr. Hotez has communicated with Mr. Kennedy directly over the years, he said, as the two have been embroiled in online debates.

“From my experience with him, he doesn’t have any interest in the science. He has trouble understanding the science, and he comes to the table with preconceived and dug-in notions,” Dr. Hotez said. “I don’t see him willing to adapt.”

Where does RFK Jr. stand on other key health issues?

Mr. Kennedy has spent his career as an environmental lawyer and has defended against large corporations including Monsanto, which seemed to have informed his promises to focus on environmental exposure to chemicals, food additives and chronic disease.

Among the positions that he has advocated for are removing artificial dye from foods and to stop adding fluoride to water supplies. The European Union bans some food additives that are allowed in the U.S. and requires warning labels on many artificial dyes — although research indicates that fluoride doesn’t fall in that category. In cities where water is fluoridated, it has been shown to protect against dental decay.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kennedy has also criticized ultraprocessed foods, and chemicals such as high-fructose corn syrup, calling them culprits for record-high obesity rates and chronic disease, stances many physicians believe he is right to criticize.

Is a medical background needed for the job?

Many past HHS secretaries have not had medical backgrounds, although they often had experience overseeing large organizations and hefty budgets.

Tommy Thompson, HHS secretary between 2001 and 2005, was governor of Wisconsin for nearly two decades and chair of the National Governors Association. Alex Azar, in the role from 2018 to 2021, had been president of the U.S. division of global pharmaceutical company Eli Lilly, as well as general counsel and deputy secretary to the health secretary over many years.

What’s unprecedented about Mr. Kennedy’s nomination is that he is “a person who avowedly wants to destroy one of humans’ greatest inventions: vaccines,” said Amesh Adalja, a Pittsburgh-based physician and senior scholar with Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

Epidemiologists are especially worried about Mr. Kennedy’s penchant for sowing distrust in vaccine research.

Advertise with us

“His role there is not going to be to promote health, but to destroy health,” said Dr. Adalja. “We have the exact opposite of what you would want in a health secretary in RFK Jr.”

Mr. Kennedy has stated in the past that, if he was in this role, he would fire hundreds of scientists, remove entire departments and divert attention and resources away from infectious disease research. “We’re going to take a break from infectious disease for about eight years,” he said at an anti-vaccine conference in Georgia in 2023, NBC reported.

A member of the famed Kennedy family that includes a former president, a U.S. attorney general, a U.S. senator and a U.S. ambassador among its ranks, Mr. Kennedy’s name brought him recognition early.

“Just because of his last name, people have been giving [Mr. Kennedy] a platform that he doesn’t deserve,” said Dr. Adalja. “His ideas are from the Dark Ages. They’re ridiculous.”

Mr. Kennedy started the foundation Children’s Health Defense in 2018, a nonprofit that states, according to its website, to “restore and protect the health of children by eliminating environmental exposures, holding responsible parties accountable, and establishing safeguards to prevent future harm of children’s health.”

Advertise with us

The Instagram and Facebook accounts of the nonprofit were temporarily banned in August 2022 for posting misinformation about vaccines.

What’s at stake?

Nationally, the fight to reassure people about the effectiveness of vaccines has escalated in recent years, even as numerous studies have found significant health impacts of decreasing vaccination rates for diseases like measles, flu and COVID-19.

For example, although polio had been previously eradicated in the U.S., it emerged in New York in 2022 in an unvaccinated individual. Measles is also surging, often in unvaccinated communities. The country has seen 16 measles outbreaks — and 280 cases — this year alone, per the CDC, most of them in children under the age of five.

“It is important to remember that measles is not simply a rash: One to three out of approximately every thousand children who develop measles will die, and about the same will have significant long-term side effects,” Mark Roberts, distinguished professor of health policy and management at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health, said in an email. “As much as 20% of persons (who are not vaccinated) and contract measles are hospitalized.”

There are other threats that infectious disease experts have their eyes on, including H5N1, a highly transmissible bird flu that has infected livestock and dairy farm workers, and a separate strain that has left a Canadian teen in critical condition.

Advertise with us

Scientists are also on the lookout for upcoming variants of SARS viruses — like the SARS-CoV-2 that causes the COVID-19 pandemic and that has killed 1.2 million people in the U.S. and seven million worldwide.

“Vaccines have saved literally hundreds of millions of lives over the past several decades and will continue to do so if they are used properly,” said Dr. Roberts.

It wouldn’t be an overstatement to say vaccines have been one of the most important successes of public health in human history, said Lee Harrison, associate chief of epidemiology, director of the University of Pittsburgh Center for Genomic Epidemiology and a professor of Medicine and Epidemiology at the School of Medicine.

Dr. Harrison, who started his career at the CDC, believes the scientists there are “really top-notch” and “extremely well-trained” — but said they require support from the top in order for the agency to function. “There is a lot of potential for disruption,” he said.

It’s not that the public should panic about impending viruses or a future pandemic, said Dr. Hotez — but that the HHS secretary should know how to monitor threats. “These pandemic threats are a new normal,” he said. “They’re as conventional a threat as traditional warfare.”

Advertise with us

The nation’s health bureaucracy’s job is to identify problems and to defend the population. If Mr. Kennedy’s nomination goes through, the medical industry will be watching to see how he handles those responsibilities.

“There’s not much in his career background that would have it make sense that he would be the head of such a large and massive entity,” said Mark Kamlet, a professor of economics and public policy at Carnegie Mellon University specializing in health economics, and a longtime Highmark Health board member.

“If you tear down an important institution that many people have dedicated their lives to, you can do great harm easily and quickly,” he said. “It will take decades to build it back up.”

Correction, posted Nov. 24, 2024: The spelling of Georges Benjamin’s name has been corrected.