A class action antitrust lawsuit filed against UPMC this week accuses the healthcare giant of using its sweeping reach to keep wages low, workloads high and “lock employees into sub-competitive pay and working conditions.”

The lawsuit, filed by an employee at UPMC-Hamot in Erie, accuses the healthcare system of violating antitrust laws by having both a monopoly on hospital services and a monopsony on the employment of hospital workers. The claims mirror those laid out in another antitrust lawsuit filed against the healthcare system last year by SEIU and other unions.

UPMC representatives could not be reached for comment.

The healthcare system is the largest private-sector employer in Pennsylvania and operates around 40 hospitals in Pennsylvania, New York and Maryland.

Advertise with us

That expansion, the lawsuit alleged, was done not in the name of providing service, but rather to expand its market power. In the midst of its expansion, according to the lawsuit, UPMC closed four hospitals, downsized three others, and eliminated hundreds of beds and thousands of employees.

The federal filing also accuses UPMC of employing noncompete clauses and do-not-hire blacklists to keep employees from seeking other employment. Other allegations include suppression of wages and suppression of workers’ labor rights “to keep them from improving working conditions or forming unions.”

“Each of these restraints alone is anticompetitive, but combined, their effect is magnified,” according to the lawsuit.

According to the filing, UPMC’s alleged anticompetitive behavior is directly linked to what the lawsuit calls low wages and benefits and poor working conditions.

“Had UPMC been subject to competitive market forces,” according to the lawsuit, “it would have had to raise wages to attract more workers and provide higher staffing levels in order to avoid degrading the care it provided to its patients and in order to prevent losing patients to competitors who could provide better quality care.”

Advertise with us

By eliminating competition through mergers and acquisitions, the lawsuit alleged, UPMC did not have to overextend itself to court and keep potential employees and patients.

The lawsuit seeks to represent all skilled healthcare workers employed by UPMC from Feb. 14, 1996 “until UPMC’s anticompetitive conduct ceases.” Plaintiffs are seeking damages and restitution.