A hearing on the proposed merger of UPMC and Washington Health System Thursday drew a standing-room only crowd and pushed the health care giant’s labor issues into the spotlight.

Representatives of six unions took turns during the two-hour hearing at Washington & Jefferson College both praising and criticizing a health care system merger that WHS President and CEO Brook Ward said was critical to keeping its flagship Washington Hospital from financial default in three years.

“They pay less and push employees to do more,” John Galuska, director of Council 84 of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, said about UPMC in opposing the merger. He said approval would mean WHS becoming the “latest victim of UPMC’s corporate greed.”

But four other unions — representing carpenters, electrical workers, painters and operating engineers — spoke in favor of the deal, saying it was vital to providing health care and economic growth.

Advertise with us

The hearing was conducted by the state Attorney General’s office, which is weighing the merger’s impact on health care competition and the public good.

UPMC and WHS announced tie-up plans in June that have been undergoing regulatory review by the attorney general and Federal Trade Commission.

Washington Hospital traces its roots back 127 years and employs some 2,700 people, making WHS among the county’s biggest employers.

Lance Huber, executive vice president of the United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1776KS, joined Mr. Galuska in criticizing the merger, saying the deal “does not appear to be in the public interest.”

“I have deep concerns about what this merger could mean,” he said.

Advertise with us

Other speakers, including many WHS employees who wore matching jerseys with messages supporting the merger, urged the Attorney General’s office to greenlight the deal.

Supporters included the Washington County Chamber of Commerce, board of commissioners and elected officials.

“The fact is the system is in trouble,” said state Rep. Tim O’Neal, a Republican from South Strabane, whose three children were born at Washington Hospital. “The only option at this point is an acquisition by UPMC.”

Missing from those testifying were representatives of SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania, an opponent of the deal and a union that UPMC has been battling for years over representation of hourly workers at its flagship Presbyterian Hospital in Oakland.

In a statement on its homepage, WHS said opposition to the merger was “coming from narrow outside groups who are not from Washington County. They’re only interested in opposing UPMC.”

Advertise with us

The UFCW’s Mr. Huber hinted at SEIU’s labor dispute with UPMC in Oakland by asking whether UPMC “respected an employee’s right to form and join a union.”

On its homepage, WHS said the health system has been operating at a budget deficit of $30 million since 2022. No documents are publicly available that show the losses.

“With all our competing time priorities, we are not going to share the financials with you currently,” Larry Pantuso, vice president of Strategy and Clinical Services, said in an email.

In cost reports submitted to the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services, WHS showed gains every year between 2016 and 2021, with a net income loss of $46.2 million in 2022, which included $25.1 million from providing patient services and an investment loss of $12.2 million.

WHS declined to discuss those losses.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ward, the WHS CEO, said losses of $34 million were forecast for the fiscal year ending June 30 and a $40 million loss was anticipated in 2025. Reimbursement for services had declined over the past decade, he said.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com