WASHINGTON – Lacking a ninth justice to break a tie, the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday dodged deciding an important contraception case that pitted religious freedom against the government’s interest in public health.

Instead, justices vacated and remanded the case to four federal appellate courts and directed them to give both sides a chance to arrive at an approach that protects religious freedom while ensuring women’s access to contraceptive coverage under the Affordable Care Act.

For now, religious nonprofits can exclude contraceptive coverage from health plans without paying fines prescribed in the Affordable Care Act, and employees can still obtain coverage from the same insurer.​

During arguments in March, the eight justices seemed equally divided, but on Monday they were unanimous about two things: A compromise is possible, and district courts should find it.

Advertise with us

“While I would have liked to have seen the Supreme Court settle the issue, I’m happy it’s moved in this direction,” said lead plaintiff David A. Zubik, the Roman Catholic bishop of Pittsburgh, who challenged the contraception mandate on behalf of his diocese and Erie’s.

“I truly believe [the justices] really do want to see this resolved. I don’t think they want this engaged in politics, and I don’t think they want to see this go on for an extended period of time,” the bishop said in a telephone interview.

At issue in the case is an accommodation in the Affordable Care Act so that religious non-profits that object to contraception don’t have to pay for it for employees and students under their health insurance plans. Instead, they must notify the government or insurance carrier, which then provides prescribed birth control at no cost.

But Bishop Zubik and other plaintiffs say the notification itself triggers coverage. They say it forces them to violate their religious beliefs in violation of the 1993 Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which prohibits the government from substantially burdening the exercise of religious convictions except by the least restrictive means to achieve a compelling government interest.

The decision to vacate and remand came after the high court learned that a compromise might be possible. In separate post-hearing briefs, petitioners for both sides indicated that there is a way for insurance companies to provide birth control to covered employees even without opt-out notifications.

Advertise with us

In an unusual court order, the justices had asked for the post-hearing briefs and directed attorneys to address whether insurance companies could provide birth control without requiring “any involvement of petitioners beyond their own decision to provide health insurance without contraceptive coverage to their employees.”

Liberal groups like the American Civil Liberties Union and the American Humanist Association were disheartened Monday.

“The Supreme Court had the opportunity to stand up for the separation of church and state by giving women’s access to contraception priority over their employers’ religious believes,” said Roy Speckhardt, executive director of the American Humanist Association. “Instead, the court has delayed the decision, giving religious groups the opportunity to unjustly meddle with women’s right to health care.”

The ACLU is disappointed that Monday’s opinion provided no conclusive resoltuion, said deputy legal director Louise Melling.

“We are, however, optimistic that the courts below will rule in favor of women’s access to the care they’re entitled to,” she said. “Religious freedom does not include the right to disciminate against women.”

Advertise with us

The affected courts of appeal include the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which has jurisdiction over Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and the Virgin Islands.

"The Court expresses no view on the merits of the cases," Monday’s Supreme Court's opinion said. "In particular, the Court does not decide whether petitioners' religious exercise has been substantially burdened, whether the Government has a compelling interest, or whether the current regulations are the least restrictive means of serving that interest."

Justice Sonia Sotomayor issued a concurring opinion, which was joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Justice Sotomayor stated that she joined the court's decision "because it expresses no view on 'the merits of the cases,' 'whether petitioners' religious exercise has been substantially burdened,' or 'whether the current regulations are the least restrictive means of serving' a compelling governmental interest."

The justices warned that no one should read into the fact that the decision was unanimous.

Justice Sotomayor wrote that the court's opinion allows lower courts "to consider only whether existing or modified regulations could provide seamless contraceptive coverage" to petitioners' employees through their insurance companies without any notice.

Advertise with us

"The opinion does not, by contrast, endorse the petitioners’ position that the existing regulations substantially burden their religious exercise or that contraceptive coverage must be provided through a 'separate policy with a separate enrollment process,' " the concurring opinion said.

"Such separate contraceptive-only policies do not currently exist,and the Government has laid out a number of legal and practical obstacles to their creation," according to Justice Sotomayor. "Requiring standalone contraceptive-only coverage would leave in limbo all of the women now guaranteed seamless preventive-care coverage under the Affordable Care Act. And requiring that women affirmatively opt into such coverage would 'impose precisely the kind of barrier to the delivery of preventive services that Congress sought to eliminate.' "

Monday’s opinion was the latest example of the Supreme Court’s difficulty resolving cases since the death of Antonin Scalia in February left the bench with four liberals and four conservatives.

Legal scholars like Professor Aaron Caplan of Loyola Law School Los Angeles weren’t sure whether Monday’s outcome was a result of an unresolvable tie or justices’ earnest belief that a compromise could be reached that not require their intervention.

Either way, if Justice Scalia were on the bench the outcome likelywould have been different, Mr. Caplan said. Either he would have broken the tie by siding with the religious nonprofits or he would have objected to the decision to vacate and remand, Mr. Caplan speculated.

Advertise with us

“He usually didn’t like these kind of face-saving gestures by the court. Ic an think of decisions where the court did something face-saving and he would file some blistering dissent, saying we should just decide the question here and now,” Mr. Caplan said.

In 2015, a federal appellate court reversed injunctions by Pittsburgh judges that prevented the government from forcing Catholic nonprofit groups and Geneva College to provide insurance coverage for contraceptives in student and employee health care plans or certify that they object to the services on moral grounds, allowing third-party insurers to provide coverage.

In 2013, U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti granted Geneva’s motion for an injunction with respect to its student plan and blocking the government from forcing Geneva to provide contraceptives and week-after anti-pregnancy medications contrary to the school’s religious beliefs.

She granted a second injunction later involving Geneva’s employee health plan.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab made a similar ruling in 2013 involving entities affiliated with the Pittsburgh, Erie and Greensburg Catholic dioceses, which objected to providing contraceptives required under the Affordable Care Act.

Advertise with us

Nonprofit organizations connected to the church also said that because the church is exempt from providing contraceptives, enforcing the mandate on its affiliates would have the effect of “dividing the church.”

A three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said that once the religious organizations claim that they won't pay for contraceptive coverage, they face “no substantial burden” on their religious freedom, allowing a third-party insurer to provide the coverage.

The case named for Bishop Zubik began as seven separate cases filed by 43 plaintiffs in four judicial districts. Several other plaintiffs also have local ties. They include Geneva College in Beaver Falls, which is affiliated with the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America; Cardinal Donald Weurl, the former Pittsburgh bishop who now is archbishop of Washington, D.C.; and the Little Sisters of the Poor, an order of nuns that serve the disadvantaged elderly in communities across the country including Pittsburgh.

Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com, 703-996-9292, or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets. Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.