The Franklin Institute violated the Americans with Disabilities Act when it charged a severely disabled man’s caregiver admission to the museum in addition to charging the man, a federal judge has ruled.

U.S. District Judge Gerald A. McHugh of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania held that the ADA requires personal care attendants to be given free admission when accompanying their clients to public accommodations.

Plaintiff Michael Anderson argued that he needs a personal assistant to perform virtually every task during day-to-day life on a 24/​7 basis. Without the caregiver, he further argued, he would not be able to visit the Franklin Institute, navigate the museum, or view its exhibits.

Judge McHugh wrote in his opinion that Mr. Anderson “is effectively denied meaningful admission unless he pays for the admission of his employed PCAs. Nondisabled persons enter [Franklin Institute] and participate after paying only for themselves. Anderson and other similarly situated disabled persons do not have that luxury.”

Advertise with us

Stephen Gold of the Public Interest Law Center in Philadelphia represented Mr. Anderson and the nonprofit organization Vision for Equality in the case.

“We hope that museums and other institutions throughout the country will modify their policies to conform to the ADA,” Mr. Gold said in a statement. “Without a PCA, many severely disabled people cannot visit and enjoy these facilities.”

Anne Marie Estevez of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius represented the Franklin Institute and did not return a call seeking comment.

“The Franklin Institute is proud of its long history of serving the disabled community, and we have done so with respect through access programs, and far-reaching education and outreach initiatives,” an institute spokesperson said in an email.

“We strongly disagree with the decision of the district court, and will explore all of our options. Since the start of this unprecedented case, the Institute made numerous attempts to resolve this matter with the plaintiffs. We are committed to continuing to serve the disabled community as we always have.”

Advertise with us

The institute argued that disabled people in Mr. Anderson’s class are treated equally to all other patrons who are required to pay an additional fee when entering with a guest. According to Judge McHugh, the defendant compared Mr. Anderson’s situation to an able-bodied patron who requires assistance, such as child with a chaperone or nanny.

Mr. Anderson countered that under federal law, “a nanny is to a PCA what a pet is to a service animal.” Judge McHugh agreed with the analogy.

“Defendant’s insistence on equating disabled individuals to children not only misstates plaintiffs’ legal position, it runs counter to one of the goals of the ADA,” Judge McHugh said, citing that the ADA seeks to diminish stereotypical thought processes.

Judge McHugh continued that the point of the ADA is to level the playing field for disabled people, who are already at a disadvantage.

The Franklin Institute argued that case law upholds the notion that disabled people are not entitled to opportunities that exceed those available to the general public.

Advertise with us

Judge McHugh agreed with the principle, but said that it was not an issue in the case: “Accommodating plaintiffs does not come at the expense of nondisabled patrons in any way.”

Judge McHugh also granted several of Mr. Anderson’s proposed modifications to the Franklin Institute to provide greater access to handicapped patrons, including a waiver of admission fees and providing folding chairs for personal care assistants accompanying their clients in the Franklin Institute’s IMAX theater.

The defendant argued that waiving the fees would have serious financial consequences for the organization, which could lead to budget cuts, layoffs, and the elimination of services.

P.J. D’Annunzio: 215-557-2315 or pdannunzio@alm.com. On Twitter @PJDannunzioTLI. To read more articles like this, visit www.thelegalintelligencer.com.