When Sony Ton-Aime first heard rumors circulating on social media that Haitian immigrants were abducting and eating pets in Springfield, Ohio, he was brought back to the dark time his parents had lived through.
To Mr. Ton-Aime, a native of Ouanaminthe, Haiti, and executive director of Pittsburgh Arts and Lectures, the since-debunked claims that former President Donald Trump echoed in Tuesday’s debate with Democratic candidate Kamala Harris represent a long history of persecution against Haitians in America.
While the rumors stirred up disappointment and sadness, Mr. Ton-Aime said the sensational accusations — which spread like wildfire online before landing on the presidential debate stage — didn’t surprise him.
“I’m not surprised because fear is irrational,” Mr. Ton-Aime said last week. “There is this fear that is real of ‘the other,’ and people are seeing a lot of immigrants coming in. They need a reason to explain away their fear.”
As of January, there were more than 24,000 Haitian immigrants in Pennsylvania, according to World Population Review.
According to the 2020 U.S. Census, Springfield, Ohio had 58,000 residents. City officials estimate an additional 20,000 Haitian immigrants have since poured into the city.
Mr. Ton-Aime said he is concerned for his fellow countrymen as the claims continue to spread online.
“The Haitian community right now is the most endangered community because of the stigma of eating people’s pets,” he said. “So every time I would tell someone that I am a Haitian, that image will come to their head. Even if they do not believe it, that image will come to their head.”
The origin of the claims coming out of Springfield remains unclear, although they appear to stem from a social media post on X last week that claimed, without evidence, that a person’s “neighbor’s daughter’s friend” saw a cat hanging from a tree to be butchered and eaten outside a house where the poster claimed Haitians lived in the Ohio city.
In a separate instance, a woman in Canton, Ohio, was arrested last month for allegedly eating a cat. That woman, identified as 27-year-old Allexis Ferrell, was reportedly born in Ohio and the incident occurred 170 miles from Springfield.
Officials in Springfield have tried to mitigate the misinformation by saying there had been no credible reports of pets being abducted or eaten by anyone.
On Monday, U.S. Sen. JD Vance, a Republican from Ohio, posted on X: “Reports now show that people have had their pets abducted and eaten by people who shouldn’t be in this country.” On Tuesday, he posted that his office had received inquiries from residents of Springfield who claimed “their neighbors’ pets or local wildlife were abducted by Haitian migrants.”
At Tuesday night’s debate, Trump repeated the claims, saying: “In Springfield, they’re eating dogs. They’re eating the cats. They’re eating … the pets of the people that live there. And this is what’s happening in our country, and it’s a shame.”
On Friday, Trump, who said he wanted to be known as “the border president,” continued to rail against the dangers of illegal immigration, claiming that the country has had “thousands of people being killed by illegal migrants,” according to the Associated Press, which noted there had been no spike in violent crime nationally or in the major cities where many migrants have settled. And national statistics show violent crime is declining.
The former president, speaking at a news conference in California, dismissed concerns about the impact of such allegations on Springfield. Bomb threats prompted the evacuation of schools and government buildings there for a second day Friday. Threats were directed at the homes of Springfield’s mayor and other city officials, as well as Springfield City Hall and schools.
“No, no, the real threat is what’s happening at our border," said Trump.
On Friday, during a White House brunch celebrating Black excellence, President Joe Biden condemned the former president's claims.
Noting that his press secretary, Karine Jean-Pierre, is a “proud Haitian American,” Mr. Biden said the Haitian-American community is “under attack in our country right now.”
"It's simply wrong. There’s no place in America. This has to stop, what he’s doing," Mr. Biden said, in what appeared to be a reference to Trump. "It has to stop."
Mr. Ton-Aime and other Haitian immigrants in the Pittsburgh area see connections to past issues with the treatment of Haitians, who were accused of spreading AIDS in the U.S. during the height of that epidemic and were federally banned from donating blood from 1983 to 1991.
“This is something that is not new, but it is very disheartening for me to see how easily those same racist and xenophobic ideas can be repackaged and then a vast number of Americans can fall for it, and really cannot see through this persecution that is being targeted toward people like me,” he said.
Other Haitians said they viewed the latest rhetoric as a continuance of the former president’s negative attitude toward their native country, which he reportedly referred to, along with El Salvador and some African nations, with an expletive in January 2018.
Leon Pamphile is executive director of FLM Haiti, a nonprofit based in Pittsburgh that provides education, literacy training, health care, and preparation in trade skills. The native of Laboule, Haiti, has lived in Pittsburgh for more than 50 years.
“I regret that former president Donald Trump has chosen to really put Haiti down,” Mr. Pamphile said. “That’s not the first time he did it … it’s a continuation of his attitude and policy towards Haitians which is really regrettable.”
Mr. Pamphile, who recently attended a picnic with about 50 other members of the Haitian community through the group Haitians in Pittsburgh United, urged those looking into the discourse around Springfield to do so with a critical eye.
“I would tell them it’s a scare tactic by the Republicans to put fear in people’s minds and hearts,” he said. “This is not true, this is not believable, and they should not bite. They should not accept it.”
Negative rhetoric surrounding immigration may have ripple effects, said Darlene Dubuisson, an assistant professor of cultural anthropology at the University of Pittsburgh. Her work has focused on migration, Black intellectual histories, and transnational studies with a geographic focus on the Caribbean and Latin America.
“The outcome has historically been death,” Ms. Dubuisson said. “The outcome has been beatings. It has been things, like with the HIV-AIDS situation, [that] meant that patients couldn’t donate or receive blood. It meant people were fired from jobs.”
Ms. Dubuisson, whose research also extends to Mexico — where she said migrant deaths and rapes are on the rise — said she sees much of the discourse around immigration as dehumanizing.
“Now, if you are not a citizen, if you are not here ‘legally,’ you are not as human, and ultimately all of this comes back to who gets to be human and who gets to count,” she said. “I think we should always keep that in mind, that this is about who’s human … and we’re taking this kind of really strange posture that some humans don’t matter as much as others.”
—Staff writer Jonathan D. Salant contributed to this report






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.