PHILADELPHIA — Vice President Kamala Harris in an often feisty debate in Philadelphia Tuesday made many appeals to voters, often looking directly into the camera and asking even Republicans dissatisfied with former President Donald Trump to consider a new way forward in American politics, versus “the same old tired playbook” of “lies, grievances and name-calling.” 

Trump for almost 90 minutes tried to fend off pointed attacks on his policies, rhetoric and temperament by sticking to the themes and bombastic tone that animate his rallies and social media posts. He claimed that he’d overseen the greatest economy in our history only to have it destroyed by Ms. Harris and President Joe Biden; that millions of criminals were flooding across the border and destroying our towns; and that “everyone knows” Ms. Harris is “a Marxist” who would ban fracking for natural gas in the critical battleground of Pennsylvania and confiscate Americans’ guns “on day one” if elected.

Trump and Ms. Harris tussled over the economy, energy, immigration, abortion, foreign policy and the former president’s false claims of widespread election fraud. Here are five takeaways from the debate.

Power handshake?

The debate kicked off with a handshake that may have caught Trump off guard and set the tone of what would follow. Ms. Harris walked fully across the stage into Trump’s space with her hand outstretched. The pair shook hands behind Trump’s podium, where she introduced herself and said “Let’s have a good debate.”

Advertise with us

Trump, who accepted her hand and appeared to lift it upward a bit but without deploying his infamous power handshake, responded with, “Nice to see you, have fun.”

It was the moment the candidates first met, after months of back-and-forth attacks by the pair and surrogates in speeches and countless ads.

They did not shake hands after closing statements.

Appeal to undecided voters

Ms. Harris, who prepared for the night with several mock sessions during a weekend stay in downtown Pittsburgh, made a play for unity, calm and undecided voters.

“Vice President Harris was more prepared and polished,” Vince Galko, a Republican strategist based in northeastern Pennsylvania, told the Post-Gazette. “The opinions will differ on if it came across as too polished.”

Advertise with us

Trump, meanwhile, was Trump. 

“He spoke in a simple and relatable manner,” Mr. Galko said. “It was clear that Trump’s strategy was to galvanize his base support while Harris attempted to appeal to undecideds, while risking the alienation of some in her base.” 

Discussing the Jan. 6, 2021 assault on the U.S. Capitol by Trump supporters, Trump seemed angry as he claimed to have had “nothing to do with that” and defended the rioters as “being treated very badly” by the courts; Ms. Harris said the former president was “clearly ... having a very difficult time processing” his election loss. 

“But we cannot afford to have a president of the United States who attempts as he did in the past to upend the will of the voters in a free and fair election,” she said.

The vice president said there are concerns globally that when Trump continues election denialism, “perhaps we don’t have [in Trump] the temperament or ability to not be confused about facts. That’s deeply troubling and the American people deserve better.”

Advertise with us

At one point Ms. Harris invited viewers to check out a Trump rally. “You will see ... he will talk about fictional characters like Hannibal Lecter, he will talk about windmills cause cancer, and what you will also notice is people start leaving his rallies early out of exhaustion and boredom. The one thing you will not hear him talk about: you ... your needs, your dreams and your desires. You deserve a president who actually puts you first.”

The claim about rallies seemed to set Trump off. An angry response that began with “there’s no reason to go” to a Harris rally and a defense of his own “biggest rallies,” morphed into claims that “our country is lost” and “we’re a failing nation,” that World War III could be imminent and that the Biden-Harris administration had destroyed the country through immigration policy.

Moderators fact-checked Trump

Both candidates dodged direct questions, including Ms. Harris on the very first question whether she thought people were better off now than four years ago. Trump dismissed the question when asked whether he’d veto a national abortion ban. In several instances the moderators repeated the unanswered question, but gave up when it again was ignored to pursue some other point.

Trump was fact-checked multiple times on the spot by the moderators, most notoriously when Trump claimed that immigrants were eating people’s pets in Ohio: “In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs, the [immigrants] that came in, they’re eating the cats, they’re eating the pets of the people that live there,” he said, referencing to a baseless story about Haitian immigrants in Ohio.

ABC’s David Muir noted that the network investigated the claim, and the city manager said there were no credible reports of any pets being harmed by the immigrant community.

Trump argued that he’d seen it on TV.

Advertise with us

Harris used the moment to appeal to Republicans, saying the display people had just witnessed was why more than 200 Republicans — including former Vice President Dick Cheney and his daughter former Rep. Liz Cheney — have endorsed her. If you want to understand Trump, “if he didn’t make it clear already,” she said, “ask people who worked for him.” She invited disaffected Republican voters to join her, saying “There is a place for you” in the Harris campaign.

The moderators also fact-checked Trump after he suggested that Ms. Harris’ running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, had approved of “execution after birth,” which Mr. Walz did not do and which is not legal in any state.

Ms. Harris hammered Trump on abortion, saying states have enacted “Trump abortion bans” and restrictions that have directly hurt pregnant women including those who want to have families but miscarry and find themselves “bleeding out in the car” because medical professionals are afraid they could be prosecuted if they provide care. She said Trump would certainly sign a national ban into law.

Trump suggested that his running mate, Sen. JD Vance of Ohio, was talking out of turn when he recently told reporters Trump would veto a nationwide abortion ban.

“Well, I didn’t discuss it with JD, in all fairness,” he said. “And I don’t mind if he has a certain view, but I don’t think he was speaking for me.”

Advertise with us

Trump supporters were critical of the fact-checking, claiming it was one-sided.

Body language

Throughout the debate, Ms. Harris often used the camera to her advantage, often looking directly into the camera, addressing those watching on TV and online directly.

As Trump spoke, Ms. Harris also watched him steadily — often with a mix of furrowed disgust or eye-rolling, head-shaking, and mocking befuddlement when the former president veered off topic or into hyperbole. It created an effective split-screen show. At least twice, Ms. Harris pulled her head back and raised her hand to her chin: when Trump called her father a “Marxist” and when he appeared riled up after she suggested his ramblings often lead to empty seats at his rallies.

Trump, who historically has been very media savvy, rarely looked into the camera. Nor did he offer the kind of animated reaction that set him apart during the 2016 primary debates. Instead, he directed his focus, often scowling, at the moderators. He did look in Ms. Harris’ direction a few times, particularly when she tried to speak over him despite her microphone being muted, and he told her to stop at least twice. 

"Wait a minute, I'm talking now, if you don't mind, please. Does that sound familiar?" Trump said, referencing Ms. Harris’ “I’m speaking” exchanges with former Vice President Mike Pence in the 2020 debate.

Advertise with us

At times Trump leaned a bit forward while furrowing his brow, nodded as Ms. Harris attacked him, or looked up with his signature smirk or raised eyebrows before blasting her arguments as “lies.” 

Fracking fight

Trump continued his assertion — often loudly — that Ms. Harris would ban fracking in Pennsylvania, a state with 19 Electoral College votes that both candidates likely must earn if they hope to win the presidency. 

“She’s been against [fracking] for 12 years,” Trump said, before claiming that Ms. Harris is a “radical left liberal” who also wants to defund police, “do transgender operations on illegal aliens in prison” and “confiscate your guns.” He later said electing Ms. Harris would likely lead to World War III, suggesting even that nuclear war was possible. 

“I got the oil business going like nobody else before,” he said. “If she wins, oil will be dead, fossil fuel will be dead, we’ll go back to windmills or solar, where you need a whole desert.” 

He immediately added, however, that he was a “big fan of solar.” 

Advertise with us

Ms. Harris reiterated what she told CNN last month, that her “values have not changed” even if she has shifted on several specific positions. 

“I made that very clear in 2020, I will not ban fracking, I have not banned fracking,” she said.

She added that she cast the tie-breaking Senate vote on a climate bill that opened new leases for fracking. 

On Trump’s claim that she would take gun owners’ weapons, Ms. Harris pointed out that she and Mr. Walz were both gun owners. The issue of gun violence was not discussed, but Ms. Harris called on Trump to dispense with “lies” about any plans to confiscate guns across the country. 

“The most important moment of the debate was President Trump’s asking where she has been for the last three-and-a-half years,” Charlie Gerow, a Harrisburg-based GOP strategist, told the Post-Gazette. “Kamala Harris spent most of the night running away from her own positions. Sadly the moderators didn’t try to catch her. But voters will.” 

Quotes to note

  • “Donald Trump was fired by 81 million people,” said Ms. Harris, during discussion about the peaceful transfer of power and Trump’s false claims of election fraud.
  • "People can't go out and buy cereal or bacon or eggs or anything else. The people of our country are absolutely dying with what they've done. They've destroyed the economy," said Trump.
  • "I believe in the ambition, the aspirations, the dreams of the American people, and that is why I imagine and have actually a plan to build what I call an opportunity economy," said Ms. Harris.
  • “I have concepts of a plan,” Trump said when discussing healthcare after years of attacking the Affordable Care Act but failing to replace it.
  • “You deserve a president who actually puts you first,” Ms. Harris said.
  • "This is a corrupt administration, and they’re selling our country down the tubes,” Trump said. 

NOTE: This post has been updated from the original to correct Moderator David Muir’s name and to correct the date.