WASHINGTON — When he launched his 2024 Senate campaign last month, Republican David McCormick accused U.S. Sen. Bob Casey of being a “rubber stamp” for President Joe Biden — leaving “the southern border open” and exposing “the people of our state to rising crime and the fentanyl crisis.”
Earlier this month, U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, said the president had put in “zero effort” on the border, citing “over 6 million illegal crossings” and “over 50,000 lbs of fentanyl trafficked.”
And U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said last year that Mr. Biden and House Democrats “choose to keep our borders open to fentanyl traffickers” while the drug accounts for 70% of Pennsylvania’s 5,000-plus annual overdose deaths.
These lines of attack as the 2024 campaign heats up are part of a wave of GOP messaging seeking to link the country’s intensifying fentanyl crisis to the spike of migrants at the border. But migrants account for only a tiny fraction of traffickers, and the influx of fentanyl began long before Mr. Biden took office in 2021, according to experts in law enforcement, immigration and harm reduction.
Patrick Trainor, a spokesman for the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration in Philadelphia, said that overdose death rates across Pennsylvania began “skyrocketing as we started to see fentanyl increase and heroin decrease” — a turning point that occurred about seven years ago.
“It’s been absolutely horrific,” he said.
The synthetic opioid killed more than 73,000 people in the U.S. last year, and more than 580 in Allegheny County from March 2022 through February 2023. The county’s overall fatal overdose rate during the period was 4.4 per 100,000 residents, slightly more than both the state and national rate, according to statistics from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention published by the San Francisco Chronicle.
In 2022, authorities increasingly found fentanyl, in combination with cocaine, making up more than half of fentanyl-related overdose deaths in Allegheny County, compared to 20% for fentanyl and heroin. Fentanyl also is commonly masquerading as prescription pills like Xanax and Percocet.
The crisis began to take hold almost a decade ago. The CDC describes fentanyl’s rise since 2013 as the “third wave” in an opioid epidemic that began in the late-1990s, after a surge in the deceptive marketing and aggressive prescribing of addictive painkillers. Overdose deaths linked to fentanyl nationwide and in Pennsylvania continued to rise during both the Obama, Trump and Biden administrations, and regardless of which party controlled Congress.
In 2013, only 3% of Allegheny County’s overdose deaths involved fentanyl, according to data tracked by the county and the DEA. But by 2016, fentanyl turned up in roughly two-thirds of county overdose deaths, and the following year it was found in 67% statewide.
Fentanyl accounted for 12% of Pennsylvania’s total drug seizures in 2019, compared to 5% in 2016. The year-to-year jumps in fentanyl-positive cases since 2016 marked the largest increases among the top-25 seized substances in two decades, according to a 2020 DEA report.
“Around 2015, we started to see fentanyl overtake heroin,” said Alice Bell, an overdose prevention coordinator for Prevention Point Pittsburgh. “It’s the same everywhere.”
‘Well-established trafficking patterns’
While the Mexican drug cartels that previously flooded the country with heroin and methamphetamines have evolved their operations, business still hinges on the same “well-established trafficking patterns,” said Mr. Trainor, of the DEA. That means most fentanyl is smuggled into the U.S. through standard points of entry by American citizens — not by migrants seeking asylum legally or crossing the border illegally.
Whether tucked deep into private or commercial vehicles, or in a shipping container that’s supposed to carry bananas or other produce, fentanyl often is challenging to detect. Mexico also has seen an uptick in illicit pharmacies in major tourist areas — openly advertising cheap antibiotics, anabolic steroids, or medications often laced with fentanyl.
“It’s a testament to the threat that these cartels pose to us: They are masking a lot of these shipments in what would otherwise appear to be legitimate goods,” Mr. Trainor said. “Most of the stuff we’re [seizing] is shipped up in legitimate loads.”
Almost 90% of the offenders sentenced in 2021 for trafficking fentanyl were American citizens, according to the U.S. Sentencing Commission, which tracks sentencing data and sets policies for federal courts.
“While any amount of fentanyl crossing the border is too much, what is missing from the policy conversation is that the vast majority of fentanyl trafficked across the U.S.-Mexico border is being done by U.S. citizens who are crossing through official ports of entry, not by migrants who are crossing the border illegally,” said Michelle Mittelstadt, a spokeswoman for the Migration Policy Institute, which supports immigration.
In addition, it’s wrong to claim that the southern border is “open,” Ms. Mittelstadt said. The Biden administration has deported 3 million migrants from March 2020 through May 2022, she said.
“The world is undergoing record humanitarian pressures, including in Latin America and the Caribbean, and in part as a result, claims for protection have surged in many countries, the U.S. included,” Ms. Mittelstadt said.
Meanwhile, most fentanyl seizures are made by the U.S. Customs and Border Protection’s Office of Field Operations, which staffs official ports of entry — not U.S. Border Patrol agents responsible for enforcing the regions between ports or in the interior border zone, Ms. Mittelstadt said.
Federal statistics show that for the first 11 months of fiscal year 2023, Field Operations officers intercepted 89% of the 25,600 pounds of fentanyl seized. Less than 3,000 pounds were found by Border Patrol agents outside ports of entry, and 976 pounds at Border Patrol checkpoints. Most of the traffickers were U.S. citizens. Only 4% were potentially in the U.S. illegally, according to a report by the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress.
In 2021, only 0.02% of those arrested by Border Patrol for crossing illegally possessed any fentanyl, according to a report last year by the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank.
Still, Paul Larkin, a research fellow at the conservative Heritage Foundation, said in June that Mr. Biden has “refused to take any serious steps to halt the Mexican cartels from smuggling fentanyl into this nation.”
Mr. Larkin called on Congress to approve measures to improve intelligence on the shipping of fentanyl precursors into Mexico, and to bolster counternarcotics investigations and enforcement with help from the Defense Intelligence Agency, U.S. Navy and U.S. Special Operations Forces.
And Mr. McCormick’s spokeswoman, Elizabeth Gregory, tied Mr. Biden and Mr. Casey together and said the two Democrats can’t escape responsibility for the influx of fentanyl.
“Joe Biden and Bob Casey's border policies are a complete joke, and that's why drug cartels have the freedom to traffic fentanyl into the United States,” Ms. Gregory said. “Dangerous drugs like fentanyl killed five thousand Pennsylvanians last year alone -- five thousand -- and for years, as the problem got worse under their failed leadership, Joe Biden and Bob Casey failed to act. It is absolutely indefensible and Pennsylvanians deserve better."
‘There’s a demand’
The drive for profits by drug cartels and their networks, along with continued demand, have helped lead the shift to fentanyl, experts said.
Mr. Trainor said heroin is dependent on growth cycles and the skills of a farmer, with poppy fields subject to the whims of various governments or military entities.
“None of that is present when dealing with a purely synthetic drug, produced with a very clearly identified set of precursor chemicals that’s watched closely here in the U.S. but in abundant supply in other parts of the world,” he said. “And there’s a demand for them.
Mass-produced cheaply in controlled environments in Mexico — often with ingredients from China and India — the fentanyl shipped by cartels is now up to 50 times stronger than heroin and 100 times stronger than morphine.
“That leads to the overdose deaths we’ve seen,” Mr. Trainor said. “These guys are masters of logistics. Their ability to effectively ship these things… has allowed them, for some drugs like methamphetamine that were really expensive, to sell at a fraction of the cost it was 10 or 20 years ago. Fentanyl is no exception.”
Ms. Mittelstadt said policymakers would have a better shot at succeeding if they focused on improving detection at the border.
While experts say there’s little correlation between the surge of migrants and the rise in fentanyl deaths, addressing immigration still could help blunt the overdose crisis.
Vanda Felbab-Brown, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, a research group, told the House Homeland Security Committee this summer that the Trump and Biden administrations’ persistent leaning on Mexico to help stop the flow of undocumented migrants has left the U.S. with little leverage in the drug crisis.
“This prioritization — and the dependence on Mexico’s cooperation on that issue — has left the Mexican government feeling emboldened to disregard other U.S. interests and Mexico’s commitments, such as on counternarcotics and law enforcement cooperation,” she said.
‘We need to crack down’
Mr. Biden in February announced a slew of anti-fentanyl actions, including boosting CBP’s inspection capacity with plans to send more than 100 new large-scale scanners to the southern border by 2026. The White House said the move will enable CBP to inspect 40% of passenger vehicles and 70% of cargo vehicles — up from the current 2% and 17%, respectively
The administration is aiming to disrupt the supply chain by working with Congress to stiffen penalties on suppliers, and by urging commercial delivery companies to share data and help law enforcement identify and inspect more suspicious packages.
The president also backs a GOP-led bill that permanently would put all fentanyl-related substances in the same classification as heroin. The House passed the bill in May — with support from Mr. Reschenthaler, Mr. Kelly, and Reps. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, and Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall — but the Senate has not yet voted on it.
In 2018, Mr. Kelly co-sponsored a pair of bills signed by Mr. Trump meant to address the opioid crisis, including new U.S. Postal Service requirements to provide more data to CBP and enabling seniors on Medicare to qualify for medication therapy management programs.
Mr. Casey, who has supported bills that would expand treatment options, says the opioid epidemic is “ravaging Pennsylvania communities,” with accidental drug overdoses now the top cause of death for Pennsylvanians under 40.
“We need to crack down on the Chinese producers of synthetic fentanyl and the Mexican cartels that bring it across the border by hitting them where it hurts — their bottom line,” he said last month in support of the bipartisan FEND Off Fentanyl Act, which would declare a national emergency and ramp up sanctions on cartels and linked traffickers or money launderers in Mexico or China.
But Ms. Bell, of Prevention Point Pittsburgh, said trying to reduce supply has been an unsuccessful strategy for decades.
Many who flouted the law during the Prohibition era made grain alcohol “that was very strong, could be diluted, and was easier to smuggle and cheaper to make” than beer, she said. Cartels are deploying the same strategy with fentanyl, she said.
More funding is needed in evidence-based treatment, not law enforcement, Ms. Bell said. She said several other countries “treat it as a health issue,” enabling much broader access to methadone treatment. Methadone has successfully treated opioid addiction for half-a-century, according to the National Institutes of Health.
Mr. Trump in 2018 signed a bipartisan bill supported by Mr. Casey that made methadone a covered Medicare benefit and expanded the ability to prescribe buprenorphine, which helps reduce opioid cravings and decreases illegal use and overdose deaths.
But methadone remains available only through federal- and state-regulated treatment programs. Researchers at the National Institute on Drug Abuse said in 2021 that there’s a shortage of such programs, and that “racial and geographic inequities exist in access.”
Last December, the Biden administration — through the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration — proposed allowing Americans to receive opioid treatment through take-home doses of methadone and to use telehealth to obtain buprenorphine at opioid treatment programs.
“Awareness is through the roof,” Mr. Trainor said when asked what has improved during his 25 years with the DEA. “It’s viewed with the same level of importance by the criminal justice system, the public health system, and the treatment and harm reduction communities. They all may have extremely different viewpoints on how to address this, but we’re all in agreement that anything we can do to stem fatal overdoses is good.”
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.