When the Pittsburgh Public Schools needed a new agreement with a contractor to manage copy machines, printers and scanners in 2021, a local company contacted the district and said that if was hired it could save PPS 30% per month or about $2 million over contract it had.
That company did not initially hear back from the PPS, but it reached out again when it heard the district was close to renewing a deal with the same contractor it had been using for the previous five years.
After some back-and-forth between the company, some board members and administrators — as well as the district solicitor — PPS examined the company’s proposal and that of another vendor alongside the offer it had from its current contractor. Still, the district reached a deal with its previous vendor, albeit at a reduced rate that saved the city schools about $1 million over the life of the contract.
This was one example of issues with procurement procedures that the Pittsburgh Public Schools has in place, according to City Controller Rachael Heisler, who released a detailed account of the scenario in a special report on Monday. The report — a follow up to an October report on the district’s RFP procedures — suggested changes to how the school district accepts and reviews requests for proposals that she said could save millions of dollars as PPS continues to face financial struggles and work under a budget deficit.
“The story of this one contract shows that procurement practices within PPS, to the extent that they exist, are vague and confusing,” Ms. Heisler said. “It shows that as soon as a second vendor became involved, the price came down by $1 million. Furthermore, PPS still may have lost out on another million in savings. There is just no reason we should be leaving so much money on the table.”
The Pittsburgh Public Schools are not required to have an RFP for every contract bid, but it is board policy to “obtain competitive bids and price quotations ... where such bids or quotations may result in a cost savings to the school district,” the controller’s special report said.
Read More
The report suggests that PPS should establish clear protocols for entities that want to submit bids to the district. While the district does not have to bid out every contract it signs, the report said, a responsible practice would be to bid out larger deals.
In the case study cited in the report, the vendor that said it could save the district 30% over what it was paying first contacted the district’s chief technology officer, Mark Stuckey, and chief financial officer, Ron Joseph, to request a meeting. When the vendor did not hear back from them, it followed up with another email.
The vendor then reached out to several school board members and got a terse response from one, who said it was in “poor taste” for the company to approach board members and directed the vendor to contact the CFO.
The report said the board member’s response “showcases the lack of procurement processes in the district to handle situations where an organization presents a cost saving opportunity.”
The report does not put blame on the CFO. It suggests that the district should hire a few workers who can manage RFIs and report to the CFO, similar to the practice in the Philadelphia school system.
“By adding only a few people to the payroll, the district would be able to save millions of dollars every year by running more RFPs and soliciting more bids,” the report said, noting that, “a simple solicitation of bids could save the district an average of 30% on contracts. There are millions of dollars in contracts given out every year, and by adding in more RFPs and more bids, millions more can be saved.”
Ms. Heisler introduced the idea for the district to hire staffers to help with RFPs at a school board meeting in January. District administrators said they were open to the suggestion, but they added that they would evaluate how to best move forward.
A district spokesperson could not be reached Tuesday.
In response to the case study in the report, the district said that while a formal RFP was not conducted, it obtained proposals from three vendors. It also noted a couple of other factors in its decision-making process.
Two of the proposals, it said, included the option to reduce the total equipment fleet by up to 10% after 12 months, which was factored into the evaluation.
In addition, the district said the agreement it reached included a maintenance escalator clause that the vendor had the option to activate. The vendor did not notify the district of its intent to exercise this clause in its proposal, so the associated cost increases were not considered during the evaluation process.
The activation of the clause resulted in higher monthly payments, the district said. The district acknowledged that if it had been aware of the provision, it would have likely selected another vendor.
“The district fully intends to issue a formal request for proposals for the upcoming copier and printer lease expiration,” the district said. “The RFP will require vendors to fully disclose all costs and any potential escalator clauses to ensure an accurate and transparent evaluation of all proposals.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.