Student walkouts from schools in the Pittsburgh region and across the country in recent weeks over federal immigration enforcement have sparked strong public reactions and contrasting levels of discipline for participants.

Students who join demonstrations may risk punishment, but they don’t forfeit their rights just because they’re in school, according to legal experts. Schools also have legal considerations, and they are required to give students space to voice their opinions.

“Students don’t shed their constitutional right to freedom of speech when they enter school, but that right is balanced against the school’s responsibility to make sure that they’re offering a safe and orderly school environment for all students who are in attendance,” said Aimee Rankin, an attorney with an office in the South Hills who focuses on education law. “So, it’s a balancing act at the end of the day.”

The free speech rights that K-12 students have today trace back to the landmark 1969 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, a case involving students who were disciplined for wearing black armbands to protest the Vietnam War.

Advertise with us

In its decision, the Supreme Court acknowledged that the students had the right to express themselves and established what is known as the substantial disruption test, or the Tinker test.

“Schools do have the right to regulate speech if the speech disrupts the orderly operation of the school,” said Kathleen Mahoney, an attorney with Abdnour Weiker, a law firm with offices in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia that represents students and educators in Pennsylvania and other states.

“You do have some rights to protest as a K-12 student, but it really depends on how you’re choosing to protest. If you’re doing something that does not cause any substantial disruption to the school, then that is protected under the First Amendment.”

What could be construed as a substantial disruption, she said, includes actions such as blocking entrances and exits, destroying property, engaging in vandalism, harassing students who are not participating in the demonstration or yelling obscenities — as obscenities are not protected under the First Amendment.

Information about what to avoid is often included in student codes of conduct, which can usually be found in a student handbook or in school board policy.

Advertise with us

Students who participate in walkouts have considerations beyond free speech, however, as they are leaving their classrooms.

State law in Pennsylvania includes compulsory school attendance for students from the age of 3 to 18 or graduation, meaning students must be in school or have an excused absence.

A student with three or more unexcused absences is considered to be truant, and six or more unexcused absences is habitually truant, according to Ms. Mahoney. In habitually truant cases, the law sets out discipline including and up to criminal prosecution of the parents or of the student if the student is 15 or older.

“If the students are not actually sitting in the classroom, they can’t learn, so that’s a substantial disruption,” Ms. Mahoney said. “They can be punished for walking out, but it would typically be treated as an unexcused absence.”

Any discipline for a single unexcused absence would be outlined in the school district’s student code of conduct.

Advertise with us

But there are ways for students to avoid punishment.

Ms. Rankin said students can talk to school administrators and collaborate on protest plans.

At a Feb. 18 walkout at Allderdice High School in Squirrel Hill, students informed school administrators about their plans before taking action, according to Pittsburgh Public Schools spokeswoman Ebony Pugh.

Many of the students who participated in the demonstration received early dismissals from their parents so they would not have unexcused absences, but not all of them, Ms. Pugh said. Regardless, none of the 100 or so students who walked out faced discipline.

“Organizers worked proactively with school leaders to ensure the demonstration remained safe and orderly,” Ms. Pugh said in a statement. “The walkout ended without incident. Pittsburgh Public Schools respects students’ rights to engage in lawful, peaceful expression while prioritizing student safety and maintaining a secure learning environment.”

Advertise with us

Of course, not every school may be supportive of such actions.

“I think the Allderdice example is a good one of a way in which students can engage in peaceful protest and not be disciplined,” Ms. Rankin said. “But I think that’s not going to happen at every district because schools are a political subdivision, and they are directed and governed by a board of school directors who are all elected and who have political stances.”

Some schools have taken strong disciplinary actions against students who have walked out during the past few months.

According to news reports, students in Texas, Florida, Virginia and other states have received detentions, in- and out-of-school suspensions and other punishments for participating in walkouts.

Other legal issues can arise when students leave school grounds.

Advertise with us

Schools have jurisdiction over students when they are travelling to and from school, according to Ms. Rankin, but laws around walkouts can be murkier and may need to be judged on an individual basis.

And municipal police are more likely to be involved.

On Feb. 20 in Bucks County, students from Quakertown Community High School executed a walkout, resulting in a response from Quakertown police Chief Scott McElree and several plainclothes officers.

Video from the incident showed what the American Civil Liberties Union said was “McElree and his officers unnecessarily and aggressively escalating the tension with the students. A physical confrontation ensued that left McElree grappling on the ground with a student. Five students and one adult were arrested following the scuffle with officers.”

The confrontation remains under investigation.

Advertise with us

While protests can have unexpected outcomes, ensuring that students and schools know their rights and obligations before an action takes place can be helpful.

Ms. Rankin advises school districts to consult with their solicitors on how to respond to walkouts.

And Ms. Mahoney said parents should talk with their children about demonstrating and what could happen as a result.

“Make sure that you review your school district’s code of conduct so that you understand how your unexcused absence will be treated,” Ms. Mahoney said. “Just make sure that your child knows that they may face a consequence and make sure that they’re willing to accept that consequence for participating in the protest.”