After being in the United States for just one week, a Syrian girl joined a fourth grade class at Pittsburgh’s Concord K-5 last year.

The girl’s teacher gave her an assignment matching blocks to rectangles — the same grade level content that other students would receive, only presented differently.

When the girl completed the lesson successfully, her teacher celebrated her, said Jamie Kinzel-Nath, Concord’s principal. That sort of lesson based on an individual child’s needs has become the standard at Concord, which has students from 22 countries who speak 11 languages.

“When kids feel welcomed, safe and seen, they engage and they learn,” Ms. Kinzel-Nath said Tuesday morning at A+ Schools release of its annual Report to the Community.

Advertise with us

The 2025 report from A+ Schools highlighted the growing number of English language learners in the city helping to slow enrollment decline in the Pittsburgh Public Schools. The report also identified other bright spots, such as the decreasing amount of chronic absenteeism and improvements in some reading and math scores. But it also found many areas in need of improvement, from achievement gaps across racial lines and the lack of opportunities at certain schools.

Some of the large-scale problems the report identified were among those that the district attempted to address in the facilities utilization plan voted down last week by the school board. The plan would have closed 12 schools, some of which would be reopened as other schools.

One major issue the report found was that resources are spread too thinly across the district.

James Fogarty, executive director of A+ Schools, said most city schools spend $32,500 to $33,500 on students regardless of the concentration of need in a building.

That’s true even among the buildings with the highest concentration of students with Individualized Education Programs. In the city, 75% of students with a gifted IEP attend eight schools.

Advertise with us

“The spending is more equal than equitable,” Mr. Fogarty said. “And that in large part is driven by the number of buildings we have. So, if you have a set of base costs you have to provide, that eats up what you’re able to do in terms of providing extras for schools with extra need.”

In 2025, for example, 23% of eighth graders took algebra I, but 10 schools with grades 6-8 did not offer an algebra I class.

The city schools have ample resources, Mr. Fogarty said. But the district needs to utilize those resources better by getting more students into buildings with more support staff and increased programming.

Pittsburgh Public Schools Superintendent Wayne Walters said the report showed the need for the district to make structural changes.

“The A+ Schools report shows that many of our schools are too small to offer the full range of academic opportunities — algebra, world languages, arts, enrichment — that our children deserve,” Mr. Walters said. “Twenty-one schools have fewer than 250 students. Fixed costs in an underenrolled system drive inequities in spending and access.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Walters said he understands the concerns that some have about the facilities utilization plan affecting a large number of Black students. He said, though, that the reorganization would have provided more opportunities to those students.

“As the largest population we serve, more African American students would have been directly affected by school closures,” the superintendent said. “But even more African American students would have gained access to the high-quality learning environments they deserve — environments that have often been denied. This plan expands opportunities; it does not eliminate them.”

The report also examined other causes of academic struggles, such as chronic absenteeism — when a student misses 10% or more days of the school year.

The report showed that attendance has improved in the Pittsburgh Public Schools faster than in peer cities since the onset of COVID-19. In the 2024-25 school year, 2,461 more students attended school regularly than in 2021-22.

Still, schools with the highest rates of economically disadvantaged students had a chronic absence rate 2.6 times greater compared to schools with the lowest rates. Schools where low-income students represented 50% to 75% of the population had a 29% chronic absenteeism rate. And schools where 75% or more students were considered low income had a 47% chronic absenteeism rate.

Advertise with us

Attendance at school correlates to academic performance, according to the report.

The report cited a study that showed 17% of third grade students who were chronically absent in kindergarten and first grade could read at grade level. Meanwhile, 64% of students with good attendance could read at their grade level.

In addition, a student who is chronically absent any year between eighth and 12th grade is seven times more likely to drop out of school.

“If you’re a high school student, the one thing I can tell you if you want to get your grades up – show up,” Mr. Fogarty said.

Mr. Fogarty, however, acknowledged the many barriers students and families can face when trying to get to school. They include everything from illness and poor transportation to an unwelcoming climate at school or a lack of relationships with adults at a student’s school.

Advertise with us

There are solutions to these problems, Mr. Fogarty said. He encouraged parents and caregivers to reach out to their child’s school, guidance counselors and A+ Schools to find ways to get students to class and engaged more regularly.

Enrollment in the district has steadily declined for years as the city’s population has shrunk. But the report found that the decline has started to level off, and enrollment has increased in some areas.

Enrollment in grades K-5 has risen by more than 100 students since 2022-23. The 2024-25 enrollment in K-5 was 8,633 students compared to 8,526 in 2022-23. There were more than 9,300 students enrolled in K-5 in 2020-21, however.

Enrollment in grades 6-8 and 9-12 has continued to decrease slowly.

In grades 6-8, enrollment was 4,116 in 2024-25, down from 4,852 in 2020-21. And in grades 9-12, enrollment was 5,563 in 2024-25, down from 6,245 in 2020-21.

Advertise with us

The enrollment numbers have been aided by the addition of English language learners entering the district. In 2024-25, English language learners represented 10% of the student population.

The district enrolls 64% of all families in Pittsburgh, according to the report.

“We have most of the market share of families in Pittsburgh in the Pittsburgh Public Schools, and we think that there are offerings on hand that families are excited about and want to be a part of,” Mr. Fogarty said.

But there is an issue deeper in those numbers, according to Mr. Fogarty.

Assigned neighborhood schools tend to have higher rates of student poverty and fewer offerings than other schools. This, too, points to the need for the district to update its footprint, he said.

“That creates a problem,” Mr. Fogarty said. “If kids are less engaged, not willing to be there, that can create a problem of chronic absence.”