The Elizabeth Forward School District is suing its insurance provider over alleged issues with a claim the district filed after a 2023 fire heavily damaged the high school auditorium.

The lawsuit, filed in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court last week, states the CM Regent Insurance Company failed “to adequately address damages and fund the rebuild of the high school,” a news release reads. The district, the release continues, “has been unable to secure a fair and timely resolution for the insurance claim.”

A spokesperson for CM Regent in an email said the company does not comment on active litigation.

Elizabeth Forward is seeking more than $50,000 plus punitive damages.

Advertise with us

The February 2023 fire heavily damaged the high school auditorium and stage. The lobby, music wing and several hallways had water damage. Smoke impacted the entire building.

The district did receive insurance money to help with cleanup following the fire, district Solicitor John Rushford said Wednesday. But issues arose with other parts of the claim.

According to the lawsuit, an architect for Elizabeth Forward sent record drawings for the high school and auditorium to those working for CM Regent in the months following the fire. The drawings showed the old auditorium had a 798-seat capacity.

Despite that, an architect investigating the claim said the old auditorium sat 530 people, a number he reached by counting charred seating bolts, according to the suit.

The architect submitted a report stating the space had 530 seats and that the auditorium “can go back to its pre-loss location/configuration,” the suit reads. That comes after the district said the auditorium would need to be bigger when rebuilt to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (the original auditorium was constructed before the ADA’s passage).

Advertise with us

Increasing the auditorium’s size in its former location would have encroached on existing gym and classroom space. District officials instead chose to rebuild the auditorium on the west side of the high school. Work is currently underway on the project. A gymnasium built where the old auditorium was will open at the end of January. The new auditorium will open in October.

But according to the suit, CM used the architect’s report detailing 530 seats “as a basis to deny coverage under the Policy" despite the company knowing "seating capacity numbers in the report were inaccurate,” the suit reads.

The district questioned the seating capacity, but no changes were made.

Afterward, a supplemental report was released suggesting the auditor and architect investigating the claim were not provided with drawings of the high school.

That report, the suit reads, was "intentionally misleading” because the architect "concealed his knowledge that CM possessed the original auditorium drawings.”

Advertise with us

The suit called the supplemental report conclusions “wrong, pretextual, and contrary to the terms of the Policy and the law.”

Still, CM adopted the supplement report as the findings, the suit reads.

Additionally, the suit claims the insurance company declined to pay for several damaged items including caissons, which stabilized a concrete slab under the original auditorium. The caissons, the suit states, were damaged by excessive heat, water and smoke from the fire. But a letter from CM claimed the caissons and foundation were structurally sound even if damaged.

The company allegedly made similar claims about the boiler and mechanical room that was located under the auditorium and was damaged by heat and smoke. CM in a letter said the systems were functioning properly following the fire. Because of that the company did not pay for a temporary physical plant mechanical room the district built while repairs were made to the original room, the suit reads.

And CM did not pay for the gym floor, which the district said was damaged by the fire, according to the lawsuit. The company instead said events unrelated to the fire damaged the floor.

The district is now claiming CM breached its contractual duties causing Elizabeth Forward to suffer financial injury. The suit also claims CM’s conduct was “extreme, outrageous, intentional, reckless and deserving of punishment.”