Pittsburgh Public Schools directors are not moving forward with a plan to close schools.

Directors during Tuesday’s legislative session at the Oakland administration building voted against a plan two years in the making that would have shuttered nine school buildings, closed several others and opened them as new schools and changed grade structures districtwide.

The motion failed in a 3-6 vote. Directors Gene Walker, Yael Silk, Devon Taliaferro, Sala Udin, Emma Yourd and Jamie Piotrowski voted against school closures. Sylvia Wilson, Tracey Reed and Dwayne Barker voted for the plan.

The vote followed an hourslong discussion where directors failed to table the plan and where they chose not to move forward with drastic amendments to the closure resolution.

Advertise with us

“A no vote would have been rough on itself but not as devastating as what we did tonight,” board President Gene Walker said after the meeting. “I think tonight was very harmful for the work that we have ahead of us and [Superintendent Wayne] Walters and his team just have a steeper climb because it looks like we didn’t know what we were doing tonight.”

Tuesday’s vote followed nearly two years of work that started as the district grappled with declining enrollments — PPS has the capacity for 40,000 students but currently educates 18,380 — and a growing budget deficit.

After several changes to the plan, directors were set to vote on a motion that would have permanently shuttered Baxter (Student Achievement Center), Friendship (Montessori), Fulton PreK-5, McKelvy (Miller PreK-5), Morrow Primary, Schiller 6-8, Spring Hill K-5, Woolslair PreK-5 and Manchester PreK-8. Several schools would have also shifted to different buildings while others would have seen grade reconfigurations to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 model.

But the process over the past few years was marred by intense community pushback, which continued this week. On Monday, close to 80 parents, students and community members attended a public hearing, calling on the board to vote against the plan.

And some directors have questioned the implementation timeline and what benchmarks will be in place so the board can hold administrators accountable as the plan goes into effect.

Advertise with us

On Tuesday, Ms. Silk attempted to contend with those board concerns by proposing drastic changes to the closure resolution that would have changed implementation timelines while pulling items from the plan the board wanted to move forward with now.

That motion failed.

Directors also voted against tabling the plan as presented by Mr. Walker who wanted to give directors an opportunity to provide clarity “and get ourselves to a resolution sooner rather than later,” he said.

Mr. Walker added that several factors went into his decision to make a motion to table the plan but noted that the board has heard over the course of several months that more work needs to be done.

Failure to pass the motion comes as three new board members will be seated next month.

Advertise with us

Now, Mr. Walters said there needs to be a conversation between the board and administration on where officials go from here. That process, he said, starts with reflection.

“The board has made a decision, I accept that decision, I received that decision and we move forward from there,” Mr. Walters said after the meeting.

Mr. Walker noted that he’s hopeful directors will not want to start from scratch. The current plan, he said, is “almost there.” Now, the board has to come together to work with the superintendent to ensure the board as a whole is confident to move rather than squeaking a vote through.

“It’s really hard to do this kind of work when you know that there are folks who didn’t support you along the way,” Mr. Walker said.

Still, Mr. Walters has been an advocate for the plan, stressing over recent months that it will help provide opportunities for students in all school buildings and secure critical savings for the district currently considering a 4% tax hike.

Advertise with us

“The biggest piece is, of course, we know that the educational value will not be equalized for a lot of students,” Mr. Walters said. “It will still have a system of haves and have nots in certain spaces but we will continue to work our best to serve our students and families the best that we can.”

Ms. Wilson, who also highlighted those benefits, said after the meeting that she is “extremely disappointed, frustrated” that the plan failed. She pointed to areas such as ensuring all students have access to curriculum such as STEAM — science, technology, engineering, arts and math — and integrating the gifted program into schools rather than sending kids to the Gifted Center.

“This is about our children,” Ms. Wilson said. “Yes, change is very hard but there are so many positive parts of the plan that directly impact students’ education as we move forward that has now gone down.”

The problem, she said, is that many community members and directors looked at individual schools that would be impacted rather than the district as a whole. Tuesday was Ms. Wilson’s last day on the board. She did not seek reelection.

Now, Mr. Walker said, the board is “in a worse place today than where we started.”