Michelle Boyle didn’t waver as she spoke under the fluorescent lights of the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration building Monday: Stop evicting district children.

Schools, Ms. Boyle said, are often second homes for children who spend hours in the buildings interacting with teachers and other students. But those schools are at risk of being upended as directors prepare to vote Tuesday on a plan that would shutter nine school buildings.

“Public schools are the foundation of our society,” Ms. Boyle said. “Stop the dangerous anti-social behavior of closing our children’s schools. As a neighbor and parent of Pittsburgh Public graduates, this is the third round of school closures threatening the well-being of our children and the very fabric of our neighborhoods and communities.”

Ms. Boyle was one of nearly 80 speakers during Monday’s public hearing at the district’s Oakland administration building who called on directors to vote no on school closures.

Advertise with us

The board is scheduled to vote Tuesday on the plan that would permanently shutter nine school buildings, close several others and reopen them as different schools, and change grade structures at 10 others to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 model.

“Over 6,000 students are going to move to different schools with zero benefits if you vote yes,” parent Martha Riecks said. “Why vote yes? The research is clear that school closures like these are hurting our students and are not going to save the district money.”

She noted that she’s not against change. Grades should be reconfigured to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 model, she said. And schools do need to close.

“I am about change that is done right,” Ms. Riecks said. “It is not too late to say ‘no’ to this plan.”

The meeting at times drew angry parents about how the closures and reconfigurations will not only impact their day-to-day lives, but also the district as a whole. Many pointed to trust between the district and community that has been lost during the more than two-year process.

Advertise with us

That anger seemingly came to a point during a rally held by the advocacy group 412 Justice prior to the hearing.

The rally drew more than 30 people holding signs reading “Closing schools kills community culture” and “Over 6,000 students will be forced to change schools.” Chants and songs filled the air, community members calling on the board to vote no on school closures.

“We are not happy with this facilities utilization plan that has changed several times. … The timeline has to stop,” Paulette Foster, co-founder of the advocacy group Education Rights Network, said. “The process has to stop and begin again.”

Those at the rally cited a petition that has gathered more than 540 signatures urging the board to vote against the plan. It also asks officials to conduct an equity study before closing schools and to work with families, students, staff and the community to create a better plan.

City Councilwoman Barb Warwick said during the rally that she has heard from parents and educators about the school closure plan.

Advertise with us

“At best, there is skepticism and trepidation, and, at worst, some of the most engaged parents that I know are already making plans to leave the district,” Ms. Warwick said.

She raised questions about school transit, saying that the district needs a “crystal clear plan” backed by reassurances by Pittsburgh Regional Transit and bus companies.

Parent Jazlynn Worthy pointed to a lack of trust the community has in the district. She called on the board to take time to consider the plan before moving forward.

“It’s disheartening to be up here and to literally have to come and stand here and fight for what all of our children should already be guaranteed — a fully funded public education,” Ms. Worthy said.

At the hearing, Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers President Billy Hileman called on the board to move forward with school closures.

Advertise with us

“There is a time when you need to close schools,” Mr. Hileman said. “We are at that time.”

But others took a different stance.

Community member Allie Petonic called the plan “reckless.”

Families and students, she said, “deserve a plan that is built with them from the ground up.” And teachers, staff and unions should co-create a plan with the district.

“It’s a half-baked plan,” Ms. Petonic said. “There’s no equity button to save it, to press, that will make the plan equitable.”

Advertise with us

Parents and grandparents stressed how the plan could impact their families.

Kent Jackson, who has two incoming students at Spring Hill K-5, called the past few months “educational.” School closures, he said, were not on his radar until he realized the school down the street from his home and where his children would attend could close.

“I hope that we have some time to take a beat and go back to the drawing board on this and find a feasible way to move forward . … It just doesn’t seem like a lot of thought has been put into this and not a lot of information has been made available,” Mr. Jackson said.

Liz Dell, parent of a Liberty K-5 fourth grader, said she chose the school so her child could interact with kids from all over the city. But under the plan, Liberty, which has a Spanish-emphasis magnet, would convert to a neighborhood school.

“These kids will be scattered to the four winds and they will have to start from zero,” Ms. Dell said. “When you’re 10 and 11 your friends are your whole world. How do I explain to my child that she has to give up her friends because some number on a spreadsheet said it would be better that way? Maybe you’d like to do it instead.”

Advertise with us

Jaliyah Haden, a CAPA seventh grader, said she already has equitable opportunities and modern learning at her school. No changes are proposed for CAPA.

But her brothers attend Woolslair PreK-5, which would close.

“Right now, all we have are words, no facts,” Jaliyah said. “My brothers shouldn’t have to lose their school based on a plan that doesn’t show any evidence it will help them. They shouldn’t have to go through anxiety, fear, confusion because adults created a plan without thinking about its real impacts.”

Directors will vote on the school closure plan during its legislative session scheduled for 6:30 p.m. Tuesday.