Pennsylvania school districts could soon save millions under new cyber charter school reforms, but many Pittsburgh-area leaders say the changes fall short.

The reforms, included in the state’s $50.1 billion budget passed last week, are expected to save districts $178 million by limiting the amount of money cyber charters get per student. Pennsylvania advocates caution that number could be lower in the first year as the new reforms go into effect, while cyber school leaders feel it will be significantly higher.

“It's nice to get somewhere but … this isn't the answer,” Hempfield Area School District Superintendent Mark Holtzman said.

Currently, Pennsylvania school districts pay tuition for students living within its borders who attend charter schools. A formula determines tuition rates for brick-and-mortar charters and cybers despite the online classes not having the same level of expenses as physical schools.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania has 14 cyber charter schools.

Under the new law, districts will be able to lower payments to account for things cybers don’t need. It’s in addition to dedications already made for things such as transportation and building costs.

It was seemingly a compromise between lawmakers who were previously considering an $8,000 cap on cyber charter tuition. The new reforms replace a $100 million cyber charter transition line item, through which the state helped districts absorb those costs.

Because the $100 million transition line will phase out this year, experts believe the $178 million in cyber charter savings will total $78 million the first year. That means several districts could see a net loss during the first year, Kevin Busher, chief advocacy officer at the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, said, based on various factors.

But in future years districts will see the full $178 million, “which will result in some savings for school districts,” Mr. Busher said.

Advertise with us

“We are incredibly thankful that both Democrats and Republicans in both chambers came together to find a solution to what we have all known is a problem, and that is overpayments to cyber charter schools,” Mr. Busher said.

Cyber charters took a different stance, suggesting the $178 million is an undercount and that it will total $300 million.

Marcus Hite, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of Public Cyber Charter Schools, said the reforms could force some cyber charters to close, which is “very concerning” for families who chose to attend cybers for bullying or a lack of services, he said.

“Now the rug is going to be pulled out from underneath them, and they're going to have less options,” Mr. Hite said.

State lawmakers also passed accountability reforms through which there will be residency checks to ensure districts are not paying tuition for students who moved out of the district. Students with high truancy rates will also be prevented from enrolling in cyber charters unless a judge decides it’s in their best interest. And the law calls for student wellness checks.

Advertise with us

Mr. Hite called the changes “unfunded mandates.”

Susan Spicka, executive director of Education Voters PA, a nonprofit policy and advocacy organization that focuses on cyber charter transparency, said it is “really good, solid reform.”

“We definitely need more work in the future,” Ms. Spicka said. “But this was an enormous step in the right direction, and something that we should really thank all of our lawmakers for and really celebrate in Pennsylvania that we are finally getting some first steps toward real accountability in the cyber charter industry.”

Cyber charter reaction

Several cyber charter leaders had negative reactions to the reform, including Mr. Hite who said the goal of cyber schools is not to stop students from going to brick-and-mortar public schools, but to provide a good education to those in struggling districts.

If state leaders wanted to reform Pennsylvania’s education system, Mr. Hite said, “we need to bring all the stakeholders to the table … and frankly, get it back to what the real subject should be, and that's about the families and the opportunities for these families when, unfortunately, they come across a situation where the public brick-and-mortar is failing them.”

Advertise with us

In a joint statement many charter school CEOs also questioned the reform.

Beth Jones, interim CEO of Insight PA Cyber Charter School, which has close to 3,400 students, said the reforms “will result in the closure of public schools, and thousands of valuable teachers and school staff losing their jobs.”

Jane Swan, CEO at Reach Cyber Charter School, which has 5,700 students, said that within the current school year two cyber charters will close and within two years, another five will shutter.

“This is disgraceful and a direct attack on students who depend on public cyber charter schools as a lifeline,” Ms. Swan said. “Public cyber charter schools, on average, educate a higher percentage of economically disadvantaged students, students experiencing homelessness, and students with special education needs than school districts. These are the students who need more support but decision-makers in Harrisburg are failing these vulnerable children.”

Traditional school districts respond

For area superintendents, questions remain over how the financial piece will impact cyber charter payments. Both David McDonald, South Allegheny’s superintendent, and Mr. Holtzman of Hempfield, celebrated the reform but suggested the $8,000 cap would have been more beneficial.

Advertise with us

Mr. Holtzman, whose Westmoreland County district has 5,000 students, pointed to reports highlighting how cyber charters allegedly spent millions on advertising and marketing, gift cards, cash payments and parties — “hundreds of thousands and millions of dollars on just unnecessary expenses,” he said.

“It's very disappointing and challenging because public schools are held to a higher standard, are more accountable for the spending because we have an elected school board, which charters do not have,” Mr. Holtzman added. “So the accountability level’s different.”

Mr. McDonald, whose Allegheny County district has 1,500 students, had similar concerns around the accountability reforms.

He pointed to residency challenges where students never seen by school leaders move into the district and “the bill just gets passed around.” South Allegheny does reach out to those families to offer them a seat in the district’s cyber program or to have their physical schools.

“The Pennsylvania Department of Education holds public ed to a really high standard and it’s not from a cyber charter standpoint and that’s not fair,” Mr. McDonald said. “We’re not playing with the same rules.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Holtzman called the accountability piece “great,” but it’s a “small expectation.”

“That should be your responsibility, in my opinion, is to manage those pieces because our school districts have to do it on a regular basis for the protection of taxpayer dollars,” Mr. Holtzman said.

The reforms go into effect this school year.