Frustration at times filled the Pittsburgh Public administration building Monday when a group of parents and teachers called on directors to save Student Achievement Center programming during the first of several public hearings as the district considers a controversial school closure plan.

The hearing — the first of nine — came as directors are considering a plan that would permanently shutter nine school buildings, including the Homewood-based Baxter school, which houses the Student Achievement Center.

During the 30-minute public hearing, seven speakers called on school directors to keep the Student Achievement Center open, citing success stories from the school’s 9-12 credit recovery program while questioning the logistics of how students will succeed if the program is instead moved to feeder schools.

“Please do not give up on some of our most vulnerable students like so many others have not only in this district but in their lives in general,” SAC teacher Donnese Tyler said. “They deserve to be believed in and they deserve to have the tools necessary to enable them to succeed.”

Advertise with us

The beginning of the hearings marks a crucial step in potentially implementing the plan school directors have been considering since January 2024, when officials began searching for options in response to declining enrollments and a growing budget deficit.

Now, nine school buildings are proposed to permanently close: Baxter; Friendship (Montessori PreK-5); Fulton PreK-5; McKelvey (Miller PreK-5); Morrow PreK-8; Schiller 6-8; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; and Manchester PreK-8.

Two schools could open — Northview PreK-5 and Sci-Tech 6-8 — while several others would undergo grade reconfigurations to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 model.

Here are key takeaways from the first public hearing:

What’s being proposed for the Student Achievement Center?

SAC currently serves three groups of students: those enrolled in the 9-12 credit recovery program, which allows students to regain course credits; Special12, for students needing additional support to complete graduation requirements; and an overage middle school students program, which helps students who are older than the typical age for their grade level.

Advertise with us

The school in the 2024-25 school year had 116 students.

But under the proposal, the Baxter building would close and the credit recovery program offered at SAC would move to feeder schools.

The idea is to keep students connected to their home schools with the goal of creating stronger school connections, offer flexible credit recovery options and expanded alternative education pathways, and improve student retention.

What are parents and teachers saying?

But during Monday’s public hearing, many in the community called on directors to keep the school in its current form rather than spread students across the city.

The problem, parent Anne Farris said, boils down to resources.

Advertise with us

She questioned what staffing would look like in individual schools, how the program would fluctuate based on the number of qualifying students and how all students would have access to adequate classroom facilities and technology along with social-emotional supports.

“I believe the stark reality that lack of planning for support staff and classroom space moves our students with exceptionalities back into the proverbial basement where I remember the special ed classrooms were during my PPS elementary school years,” Ms. Farris said.

Parent and PPS bus driver April Clisura agreed.

“Embedding these services in the home schools … does not necessarily make them more equitable or better quality,” Ms. Clisura said. “I’m afraid the only thing it will necessarily do is force us to spread out the resources among all the buildings, likely making service delivery uneven and potentially lower quality across the schools.”

Ms. Tyler, the SAC teacher, added that “the students who attend SAC do not stand a chance of graduating in four years or at all in four years and credit recovery moves to afterschool hours at their home school.”

Advertise with us

There, students “will be faced with many distractions” that required them to attend the center in the first place, Ms. Tyler said.

“Students do not want to fail,” Ms. Tyler said. “They are faced with many outside factors that can and do affect their academics” such as an unsafe home environment, responsibility for younger siblings, mental health issues and homelessness.

Math teacher Julie Stewart similarly questioned what the plan is moving forward for credit recovery while raising concerns about how students will react to staying in their feeder schools.

Ms. Stewart, who previously taught at Brashear, suggested that for some students their feeder schools are too big, they know too many people or they feel like they’re lost in the mix.

“Help those students who think they are not worthy or capable of a high school diploma,” Ms. Stewart said. “At SAC, we don’t just teach, we encourage, support, include … and instill values of self-worth. Please give these kids what they need and deserve.”

The next public hearings will take place Tuesday at the district administration building. The first will take place at 5 p.m., focused on the Friendship building, which houses Montessori PreK-8. The second, focused on Morrow PreK-8, is scheduled for 7 p.m.