Gillian McTiernan doesn’t have a child at Pittsburgh Montessori. But the school has already benefitted her 3-month-old daughter.
Each day the young family walks past the school anchoring the Friendship neighborhood, watching as children laugh on the playground, neighbors shoot basketball and Shakespeare in the Parks rehearses on the PreK-5 school’s lawn.
But that close neighborhood environment, Ms. McTiernan said during a special public hearing Tuesday at the Pittsburgh Public Schools Oakland administration building, is at risk of ending under a proposed plan that would shutter the building and move the school 10 minutes down the road to the current Linden PreK-5 building.
“That kind of simple human connection is irreplaceable,” Ms. McTiernan said. “It starts with the presence of a neighborhood school.”
Her testimony — one of nearly 20 — was given during the district’s second public hearing required by the state as PPS leaders consider a controversial plan that would permanently shutter nine school buildings.
The hearings are the next step for the district in potentially implementing the plan it has been working on since January 2024 when officials began searching for options in response to declining enrollments and a growing budget deficit.
Read More
Now, nine schools are up for possible closure: Baxter (Student Achievement Center); Friendship (Montessori PreK-5); Fulton PreK-5; McKelvey (Miller PreK-5); Morrow PreK-8; Schiller 6-8; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; and Manchester PreK-8.
The district held its first special public hearing Monday for the Baxter building, which houses the Student Achievement Center. Several others are planned over the next two weeks.
Here’s the plan and response to proposed changes at Montessori:
What’s being proposed for the Montessori building?
Pittsburgh Montessori is an elementary magnet school that follows the Montessori philosophy that emphasizes a child-centered approach to education.
The PreK-5 school in 2024-25 had 236 students.
But under the proposed plan, the Friendship building would shutter and students would move to the Linden facility where it would remain a full PreK-5 magnet program. The plan to close the Friendship building would save the district $16.6 million.
To execute the proposal, the current Linden school, a whole-school language elementary magnet, would also shutter. Linden students would be given an option to attend Montessori.
Under the plan in its current form, Montessori would open at Linden in fall 2026.
What are parents saying?
Karen Cornell, in speaking to a small group of school directors, expressed a lack of understanding over why the Friendship building needs to close at all.
Students, she said, deserve buildings with adequate space.
Frustration over why the closure is happening was a key point throughout the hourlong hearing, with many questioning why Montessori would move from a flat parcel of land to a school that many said is built into the hillside.
“Why move a thriving, high-demand program out of a building that works into one that simply doesn’t work as well,” parent Sara Leitera said, pointing to Friendship’s outdoor classrooms and garden.
The school, Ms. Leitera said, is currently set at the center of five neighborhoods while serving students from many more and is accessible by walking, biking and public transportation.
A move to Point Breeze, she said, will mean longer commutes for families, less walkability, less diversity and fewer connections to already established community partners.
“Both buildings need updates, but only one supports growth, Ms. Leitera said. “Moving this program doesn’t make financial sense, it doesn’t make logistical sense and certainly doesn’t serve the best interest of our students or the city.”
Six-year-old Lucy Thompson, an incoming Montessori second grader, agreed. During her testimony Lucy pointed to the school’s outdoor space and described an end-of-the-year kickball game held on green space that allows “every single student” to be outside.
But her love lies elsewhere in the school.
“I like the garden that we have,” Lucy said. “It’s a nice garden. I love it.”
While most speakers pushed for the board to reconsider the plan to move Montessori, James Fogarty, executive director of A+ Schools and a Montessori parent, said he supports the move as a way to help improve equity within the school. Right now, Montessori is a majority white school. In 2024-25, there were 154 white students and 50 Black students.
“A move to Linden, especially for the less than 100 students that are there who are given the opportunity to join the Montessori community, would in fact increase the school’s reach across racial and socio-economic divides,” Mr. Fogarty said.
But like Ms. McTiernan, who has the 3-month-old daughter, Raeed Chowdhury said the school is a key part of the Friendship neighborhood.
“My main concern is the Friendship neighborhood will suffer and I’m afraid that it won’t recover,” Mr. Chowdhury said. “Just really simply, I’m urging you to slow down the process.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.