A group of Pittsburgh Public parents submitted their own school reconfiguration plan to district leaders last week following months of community pushback to a district-led proposal that could cause schools to close and others to see grade reconfigurations.
The plan, crafted by nearly 20 parents with the input of over 100 others, calls for the closure of 10 schools and the implementation of a model that splits the city and its schools into regions.
The goal isn’t to have district leaders choose their plan; rather, the parents are hopeful their proposal will show school directors other options are available, causing the leaders to slow down the already months-long process and to start collecting authentic community input.
“We just want them to take a breath, take a step back,” Sarah Zangle, who led the creation of the proposal, said. “Don't close any schools right now and just figure out how to go forward. We need things to change. The vast majority of people have been like, ‘Yes, kids need to be educated in an equitable manner.’ We want everybody to move forward together.”
The proposal will be officially released at 6:30 p.m. Oct. 22 at the Smithfield United Church of Christ in Downtown.
The parents’ proposal will come days after Pittsburgh Public and its education consultant Massachusetts-based Education Resource Strategies on Tuesday released final recommendations that would close 14 schools across the district and streamline the grade structures at 12 others. And it would phase out five full magnet schools and two partial magnets.
Read More
The recommendations were a culmination of months of work by the consulting group to collect public input from across the city.
But despite several town hall meetings, parent and community frustrations have continued to grow, with many attending public hearings in hopes of persuading board members to save their child’s school while others heavily questioned data used to create the recommendations.
Now, parents have their own proposal.
The proposal, created over the past month, considered things such as the district’s five-year strategic plan and Pittsburgh Public’s desire to streamline grade structures into PreK-5 and 6-8 rather than having PreK-8 and 6-12 schools.
The parent’ plan calls for the closure of Banksville K-5, Fulton PreK-5, Grandview K-5, Liberty K-5, Manchester PreK-8, Roosevelt PreK-5, Schiller 6-8, Spring Hill K-5, West Liberty PreK-5 and Woolslair PreK-5. Five of those would be turned into community centers.
That’s compared to the district’s plan, which would close 14 schools, some of which would be repurposed for other schools or school-based initiatives, including Allegheny 6-8, Arsenal PreK-5, Fulton PreK-5, King PreK-8, Linden PreK-5, Manchester PreK-8, Miller PreK-5, Milliones 6-12, Roosevelt K-5, Schiller 6-8, South Brook 6-8, South Hills 6-8, Spring Hill K-5, and Woolslair PreK-5.
From there, the parents’ plan would split schools into regions.
For the elementary, where schools would follow a PreK-5 structure, there would be five regions: north, which would include King, Northview Heights and Morrow; south, Arlington, Concord, Greenfield, Mifflin and Phillips; east, Faison, Friendship, Lincoln and Linden; west, Beechwood, Brookline, Carmalt, Langley, Westwood and Whittier; and central, Arsenal, Dilworth, Sunnyside and Weil.
Parents would then rank the elementary school within their region they would want their child to attend.
“It preserves parents’ choice and the truest form,” Ms. Zangle, a Woolslair parent, said. “It will hopefully provide equity in that parents are truly choosing what's best for their child and whatever's best for their family and their education.”
Elementary magnet programs would also be phased out; however, each school would have its own focus on things such as Montessori, STEM — science, technology, engineering and math — or arts and humanities. A base curriculum would be required for each school.
One English language development center would also be located in each region.
Middle schoolers would also follow a two-region model.
Under that plan, several schools would be converted to house students in 6-8 grades including Minadeo PreK-5 located in the south region. In the east, Colfax K-8 would be converted. Sterrett would remain a middle school, as well as South Brook and Classical in the west.
In the central region, Sci-Tech would be split into a 6-8 school and a 9-12 school. Students in grades 6-8 would move into the current Miller PreK-5 building. CAPA would also be split into a 6-8, 9-12 structure with middle schoolers using the Arsenal 6-8 building.
Similar to the elementary plan, parents would be able to rank middle schools based on preference. But they would also be able to choose schools outside of their immediate region.
Those in the north or east would rank schools in the north, central and east regions. Similarly, those in the south and west would rank schools in the south, west and central regions. In the central region, where there is only one middle school, students and parents would rank middle schools across the district.
And like the elementaries, an English language development center would be available within each middle school region.
Once students reach the high school level they would rank schools throughout the district, including Allderdice, Brashear, Carrick and Perry. Westinghouse, Milliones, Sci-Tech, Obama and CAPA, which currently follow a 6-12 structure, would change to 9-12 and would be included in the rankings.
Ms. Zangle noted high schoolers would be able to use PRT buses for transportation and could consider career and technical programs offered at each high school in their rankings.
At the middle and high school levels preferences would be weighted by ZIP code to ensure historically underserved or marginalized neighborhoods have equitable opportunities.
Several other pieces are also included in the plan such as a Newcomer Academy, which would be located in Oakland or Downtown. The academy would serve 6-12 graders with the highest English language needs. And the plan calls for one paraprofessional — an aide that helps teachers in the classroom — for every four students with individualized education plans to ensure children’s needs are met. It also calls for teacher training centers.
As for schools that would close under the plan, Fulton, Grandview, Liberty, Manchester and West Liberty would become district-run community centers where Pittsburgh-based entities could conduct afterschool programs.
“We've got so many amazing spaces and amazing people doing great things in Pittsburgh between robotics and health and science and maker spaces and all these things,” Ms. Zangle said.
The plan was submitted to the school board last week.
Board president Gene Walker on Tuesday told the Post-Gazette he was not sure what the board planned to do with the proposal. They are currently deciding if they will hold a meeting with school directors to hear the presentation or if the parent group will conduct their own meeting.
“We took community input very seriously in this process, and so I don't know if I expected them to kind of put together the presentation that they did, but just personally I think it's a good exercise for the community to be a part of this,” Mr. Walker said. “We continue to seek out more input as we go through this process.”
As things currently stand, the board will meet with the superintendent before holding a vote to open the public process on the proposal, starting another round of public input sessions. Another board vote on the actual recommendations will follow.
But for parents such as Ms. Zangle, the process so far has not done enough to collect genuine input from the community.
“We are just a reactionary plan,” Ms. Zangle said. “And so really what we want to see is stop, figure out what your goals are and figure out how we can achieve that with true community engagement and true authentic input.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.