For many Pittsburgh Public parents, the release of a controversial plan aiming to shrink the district has done little to alleviate their concerns.
The recommendations were publicly presented Tuesday, and, if enacted, would ultimately close 14 schools and streamline the grade structures at 12 others. It would also phase out five full magnet schools and two partial magnets.
While the recommendations represent what could be a drastic change for many families, some parents said the plan did nothing to address one of the root causes of the district’s need to downsize — falling enrollment numbers.
“It really makes it hard to continue to believe in the district because we’re seeing this massive overhaul because of declining enrollment, and there’s no analysis of the cause for it,” said Laura Mullen, whose 9-year-old son is in third grade at Fulton K-5 in Highland Park, one of the schools on the chopping block.
“There’s no plan to entice families to come back to the schools … so I think it just feels like they are doing this now, then we’ll do it again in five more years if we lose another percentage of students, which we will because I can’t see anything that’s being done to stop the losses.”
Total enrollment at PPS has fallen from 22,895 in the 2016-17 school year to 18,380 this year, despite the district’s capacity to educate up to 40,000 students.
Read More
Ms. Mullen said her son’s school is one of a handful the district has discussed shuttering in recent years, so she considers its closure inevitable.
Nonetheless, the latest recommendations, which call for Fulton’s closure in the fall of 2025, were difficult to hear.
“I think I’m kind of resigned to it,” she said. “It makes me sad, obviously, because I think it’s been a treasure of a school and it has served a lot of students, particularly those with disabilities.”
More transition
The staggering of the proposed closures, which would occur throughout 2025 and 2026, means Ms. Mullen’s son could end up attending fourth-grade at his current school, fifth-grade at Dilworth PreK-5 in Highland Park and then have to transition to another for middle school.
The proposed changes also represent continued transition for many students who have had an atypical education experience since city schools were forced to pivot to virtual learning amid the COVID-19 pandemic
“It’s just another situation where all of these parents who are trying to just keep things moving in their lives have to figure out this whole new system and deal with a new transition for their kids,” Ms. Mullen said. “That really does give me a lot of concern that this is a huge deal.
“For some families, this is going to be fine. They’re going to be bouncy and adjust. For other families, I think this has a huge impact whenever this foundation is ripped away.”
Other parents said they aren’t thrilled with the recommendations but appreciate the data analyzed by consulting firm Education Resource Strategies that includes building capacity, where students live and the needs of historically marginalized communities, and special education needs.
“I don’t think anyone entirely loves the plan, but I am confident that ERS has put in the work to support their recommendations with data,” parent Nathan VanHoudnos said. “I might not like the data and I might not like their conclusions, but I don’t see anything wrong with what they’re doing.”
Mr. VanHoudnos has a ninth-grader at The Science and Technology Academy, a sixth-grader at CAPA and a fourth-grader at Colfax K-8.
He said his sixth-grader was relieved that CAPA 6-12 would remain a full magnet under the recommendations, although his fourth-grader remains a bit “freaked out” at the prospect of Colfax’s conversion from a K-8 school to one for grades 6-8.
“I think that is a thing that can be managed because all of her peers are also going to be going to the same set of schools, all the kids she currently walks to school with,” Mr. VanHoudnos said.
He said he and other parents are also skeptical about whether the district will be able to manage such a significant change to its footprint.
“Parents that I have talked to are concerned about the leadership capacity of [Pittsburgh Public] to implement such a drastic plan, so we need good leaders in our school to make them good,” he said.
Next steps
Other parents said they believe the plan should be scrapped and started from scratch, especially after other scenarios the district has presented recently were not well received.
“I think the obvious thing to do is just drop this whole proposal,” said Martha Riecks. “What we saw is really is not substantially different from what we’ve seen before. We know that what we’ve already seen is overwhelmingly not supported by parents.”
Ms. Riecks, who has a child in 10th grade at The Science and Technology Academy and a child attending kindergarten at Montessori PreK-5, said she was fed up with the proposals.
And although her children’s schooling would not significantly change under the recommended plan, she said she would consider taking them out of the district if it weren’t for other factors.
“If it wasn’t for the fact that our district has amazing teachers, and I love my home and my neighborhood, I might be looking at different options,” she said. “We deserve to live in the city neighborhoods we want to live in, and send our kids to the amazing public schools with these great teachers, without the chaos being created by the district.”
Ms. Riecks and others said they were more partial to an alternative plan created by a group of parents that was submitted to district leaders last week and calls for the closure of 10 schools while splitting the city and schools into regions.
“Is [the alternative plan] perfect? No,” Ms. Riecks said. “Is it a much better starting point for transforming our footprint than the ERS plan? It is, amazingly, so much of a better starting point.”
As things currently stand, the board will meet with Superintendent Wayne Walters before holding a vote to open the public process on the ERS proposal, starting another round of public input sessions. Another board vote on the actual recommendations will follow.
“While change can be challenging, this proposal offers a strategic vision for the future of Pittsburgh Public Schools,” Mr. Walters said in a press release presenting the recommendations.
“It aligns our facilities with the evolving needs of our students and communities, equity, excellence, and efficiency. My team and I will carefully review the feasibility of these recommendations as we continue to engage with our community to build a stronger, more sustainable future for PPS.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.