More than 50 people filled the Allegheny K-5 auditorium Tuesday night, armed with questions and concerns about how a proposed plan that could drastically change the Pittsburgh Public Schools footprint would impact North Side students and families.
Questions came during the district’s first regional community input session since scenarios were released proposing the closure of 16 schools districtwide, reconfiguring grade structures at 14 others and phasing out six magnet programs. Tuesday’s session at the Allegheny Commons school focused specifically on buildings located in the Perry High School feeder zone.
“The idea of looking at our facilities was not trying to figure out how we can close or move schools around but how we can deliver education better. … And that process isn’t easy,” school board President Gene Walker said. “It isn’t clean, it sometimes hurts, it’s sometimes kind of dirty. But sometimes you have to break that thing down and put it back together so that it works the way that it’s supposed to.”
Under the proposal, several North Side schools would be impacted.
King PreK-8 would turn into a 6-8 building. Allegheny 6-8 would become a K-5 building. Morrow PreK-8 would turn into a K-5 building and would be expanded to house more K-5 students living on the North Side.
Schiller 6-8, Spring Hill K-5 and Manchester K-8 would close. Schiller students would go to King and Spring Hill students would go to Allegheny K-5. Manchester students would be split between King 6-8 and Morrow K-5.
Read More
CAPA 6-12, a creative and performing arts magnet in Downtown, would be split into two schools, one for sixth through eighth graders and a high school. Sixth through eighth grade students would move into the Manchester building, which would be renovated to include creative and performing arts spaces such as dance studios, music labs, specialized art studios, a renovated auditorium and performance spaces.
And under that scenario, King 6-8 and Perry 9-12 would become STEM — science, technology, engineering and math — programs, which would include rigorous, STEM-focused curriculum and access to lab spaces.
The proposals quickly garnered pushback from the community, many of whom questioned how the changes will impact equity across the district. Others raised concerns about the majority of elementary magnet programs being phased out.
“Right now in this neighborhood, unfortunately, a lot of the conversations about this change is centered on people’s Plan B,” said Sarah Lay, whose daughter is in preschool. “As in if this goes through we’re not staying in this neighborhood or we are moving and putting our kid in a private school. And unfortunately, let’s face it, the people having these conversations have the privilege and means to do that.”
According to consultants with the Massachusetts-based education consulting firm Education Resource Strategies and district administrators, the goal of the proposal is to create equitable learning environments for all students regardless of their neighborhood or socioeconomic status.
Consolidating students, officials said, will allow the district to more equitably distribute resources across the district.
“We are trying to work together as one district, not as separate schools,” Superintendent Wayne Walters said. “We know that in our district we’ve seen tremendous pockets of success, but we need to think about how we can transform education for our entire district.”
But families quickly countered, suggesting that closures and phasing out of magnet programs will force people out of the city and district.
“One of the reasons why I still live in Spring Hill and I still own a house in Pittsburgh is because of that school, because of our neighborhood schools,” said Sherry Dumrauf, who has a child attending Spring Hill K-5. “If you want to change that — I know not only myself but there are several parents that feel the same as me — we will be pulling out of our houses, selling them and moving to the suburbs.”
Other concerns centered around transportation and grade reconfigurations.
Nathan VanHoundnos suggested that it currently takes his child up to 40 minutes on a Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus to get to Downtown from Squirrel Hill. If CAPA is split and 6-8 graders move to the North Side, that ride will be extended to 75 minutes, he said.
“That is a grave concern for the equity of getting to CAPA throughout the the city,” Mr. VanHoundnos said.
For Sara Custigan, concerns centered around grade reconfigurations. She questioned why schools such as CAPA and the Science and Technology Academy needed to be split to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 structure other schools throughout the city would follow under the plan.
But a major issue for parents Tuesday night centered on magnet schools. Under the proposal, most elementary magnets would be phased out aside from Montessori. The idea is to even the playing field for all elementary students so they are each given a base education that will allow them to apply to magnet schools on the middle and high school level.
But several parents questioned the equity behind that decision, suggesting that more diverse elementary magnets are being phased out while Montessori, where nearly 64% of students are white, would remain. Others added that phasing out the programs takes away parent choice.
For Darlene Yonakos, whose child attends Montessori, the focus needs to be on all children.
“We are not pleased to be the least diverse school in the Pittsburgh Public School system,” Ms. Yonakos said. “But let me say with my deep privilege, both with the color of my skin and my socioeconomic class, that it is deeply important that we focus on all of the students in PPS.”
In addition to hearing public input, consultants and district leaders conducted surveys that allowed families to virtually address concerns they had with any of the impacted schools. That data, along with other input collected at other input sessions next week, will be used to tweak the scenarios before a final recommendation is presented to the board next month.
Despite that, Angela King-Smith, an Education Resource Strategies partner, stressed that whatever plan the district moves forward with will be done in multiple phases that will take several years to complete.
For Mr. Walker, a full understanding of the proposal now requires thinking creatively.
“Part of this process needs to have imagination,” Mr. Walker said. “So we need to imagine what a school could be with some of these changes, not what it is today.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.