When David Abt moved his family to Pittsburgh several years ago, he didn’t realize how quickly he would find community in the Manchester neighborhood.
But that sense of community, he said, is at risk of being lost as Pittsburgh Public Schools works through a facilities utilization plan that could close dozens of schools across the district including Manchester K-8, drastically changing the footprint of the 54-school district.
“It’s not just a school to us,” Mr. Abt said during Monday’s public hearing. “It’s a really really big deal and I know that is to the rest of the communities across Pittsburgh as well. So I ask you, I plead with you, please make these decisions wisely when it comes to community cause numbers don’t always equate when you have community on the line.”
Mr. Abt was one of dozens of community members who trekked to the Oakland administration building on the district’s first day of school to speak out against the proposal that suggests closing 16 schools, reconfiguring grade structures at 14 others and phasing out six magnet programs. It’s part of ongoing work to right-size the district as it struggles with declining enrollments — PPS has room for 40,000 students but educates 18,380 — and a budget deficit.
But on Monday, the first time families had a chance to speak on the recommendations, concerns centered around equity issues, not enough data being presented along with the scenarios and magnet programs that show positive student outcomes being phased out.
“In your words ‘There comes a time when courageous leadership is necessary,’ ” Kara Birtanik said, speaking to Superintendent Wayne Walters. “And I urge you to be courageous in this moment and reject the plan that was presented to you as is. Don’t waste any more of our money on a consultant that doesn’t care about us and let’s work together to create a plan that truly puts our students first and reflects the values we all share for our district’s future.”
Read More
As the proposal currently stands, Arsenal PreK-5, Fulton PreK-5, Lincoln PreK-5, Linden PreK-5, Roosevelt PreK-5, Spring Hill K-5, Weil PreK-5, Whittier PreK-5, Woolslair PreK-5, Manchester K-8, Allegheny 6-8, Schiller 6-8, South Brook 6-8, South Hills 6-8, Milliones 6-12 and Carrick High School would close. Some of the buildings would also shutter; others would be repurposed.
Several other schools across the district would see grade reconfigures to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 structure. The plan also suggests phasing out magnet programs at several schools including Carmalt, Liberty, Linden and Dilworth. Others, including CAPA 6-12, a performing arts school, would be split to follow traditional middle and high school structures.
But to do that, officials with the Massachusetts-based education consulting firm Education Resource Strategies proposed redesigning Manchester K-8, where nearly 80% of students are Black, to house a new CAPA 6-8 neighborhood magnet school, a new model that would run like full magnets but would guarantee seats for neighborhood students. CAPA currently operates as a 6-12 school. The Downtown building would become a 9-12 facility.
“I’m deeply worried about the plan to change Manchester from a preK-8 neighborhood school to a CAPA magnet middle school,” parent Lauren Abt said. “Not only will this absolutely cause students to leave the district for one of the charters in and next to our neighborhood, it also speaks to students that their building is only worth improvement to those talented students bused in from all over the city.”
The proposal was also rejected by Katy Rank Lev, who said she would not want her seventh grader attending CAPA “to be put in a plan that pulls Manchester children from their neighborhood school and has them walking past and busing past their former school, to which would then be filled with magnet students.”
Other parents raised equity concerns around the proposal to move Montessori K-5 from its Friendship building to Linden in Point Breeze.
“When I brought to your attention racial disparities at Friendship, I wasn’t expecting a proposal, which I know isn’t final, but a proposal nonetheless, to move a school from Friendship that had started in Homewood to Squirrel Hill/Point Breeze or drawing school feeder patterns along redline maps,” Rita Porterfield, a Montessori parent, said. “Please fix this.”
Other concerns centered around a lack of data included in the consultant’s presentation earlier this month including how decisions on which schools to close were made and how closures and consolidations can help with declining enrollments and the budget deficit.
“There is so much rich and robust data that could be considered as this plan is developed,” parent Martha Riecks said. “Instead of seeing the district create a strong system of schools known for award-winning magnet and strong community school programs, we’re being handed a plan that has little if any basis in facts and figures. Why are we rushing into this hasty closure plan?”
Steven Winslow agreed, adding that the plan could actually cost the district more to put into effect while potentially leading to additional students choosing charter schools.
In addition to those worries, several parents also pushed back against the district potentially phasing out several elementary magnet programs, something Dilworth parent Chela Sanchez said would impact a child’s sense of belonging.
“Schools like Dilworth provide a unique environment that fosters diversity, creativity and excellence, qualities that are essential for cultivating well-rounded individuals ready to thrive in our society,” Ms. Sanchez said.
The district is now conducting another round of community engagement, with sessions scheduled for Tuesday and Sept. 3-5.
A final recommendation will be provided to the board in September.
“Scrap what you have been given by the consultants,” Montessori parent Kari Thompson said, “and let’s make a plan that actually addresses all these amazing ideas that exist in our community, from people here in Pittsburgh, not Boston.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.