Pittsburgh Public School police could begin reissuing summary citations as early as next week under a newly revised policy introduced to the school board Wednesday.
The policy regarding student conduct has been at the center of discussions for months after the board in July placed a moratorium on the use of summary citations, sometimes called non-traffic citations, after advocates and parents raised concerns that the offense unfairly targets Black students.
Now, the board is considering a slew of changes to the policy that would permit the use of summary citations when the law is violated, but allows for more administrator and board oversight in the process. A vote on the policy could take place next week.
“What we have is a much stronger policy that gives our schools and administrators the ability to provide safe learning environments for their kids,” board president Gene Walker said. “But I also want to recognize … I don’t think we’re itching to issue summary citations to folks. I think the administration should feel free to not issue them if they choose to. Even though this policy would allow for it, I don’t think there’s any requirement that that happens.”
Summary citations are the most minor type of criminal offense in the state and are issued for nonviolent crimes such as disorderly conduct and harassment. Those issued a citation are required to appear before a judge and it usually results in a fine, which at most can cost $250.
The updated policy works to guide school police and administrators through steps that need to be taken when a citation is issued, and states that “summary citations are not issued as a disciplinary measure in response to a Code of Conduct violations; instead, may be issued by police officers when violations of the law are implicated.”
Read More
Changes also state that before school police can file a summary citation, the student’s building principal or designee shall be notified and will consult with school police to provide a “comprehensive explanation of the incident” along with other information to determine if a citation is appropriate. During the meeting officials will also consider a student’s specific circumstances, which could include things such as an individualized education program, or IEP, and if they’re involved in the student assistant program or the multi-tiered system of supports.
Still, under the Safe Schools Code, school police officers will have the final determination on whether a law has been broken and if a citation is warranted.
Once a citation is issued, the building principal will be notified. They will then contact the student’s parents or guardians to inform them their child has been charged with summary offenses and to provide all relevant citation documents and resources. The family will be provided with the name and address of the local magistrate.
Under the policy the district will also prepare a monthly data report detailing referrals to law enforcement, summary citations and arrests.
The use of summary citations has been a focus of school directors for months after the board first voted to temporarily suspend the practice in July. At the time, directors honed in on three paragraphs around the issuance of summary citations by school police officers in the district’s 2023-24 student code of conduct, raising concerns over what they said was vague language used in the section.
They pointed to lines stating an officer will consult with the school principal “to ensure there is agreement based on the evidence provided and the recommended school action.” Other concerns focused on students with disabilities and whether officers are trained to know if a behavior is a manifestation of the disability.
And at the July meeting former school director Pam Harbin said that 44% of citations were issued to Black students for disorderly conduct and 33% for harassment. Only 7% of citations were given to white students. She added that Black girls are also 24 times more likely to receive citations as white girls.
Those concerns were echoed in a January letter written by the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania and the University of Pennsylvania Law School’s Advocacy for Racial and Civil Justice Clinic on behalf of local advocacy groups 412 Justice and the NAACP Pittsburgh. It detailed “stark racial disparities” in how summary citations are issued, and alleged that the practice violates federal civil rights law.
After the initial pause on summary citations, the moratorium was extended twice, the latest of which lengthened the pause through the end of February.
During Wednesday’s meeting, little discussion took place aside from board members raising a handful of questions regarding language reading, “The Board shall aim for the inclusion of restorative and trauma-informed practices in the Code of Student Conduct to address violations where applicable.”
School director Emma Yourd suggested that the line “shall aim” be strengthened to “something more concrete that we will include restorative and trauma informed practices.”
That was echoed by director Yael Silk.
“I agree that I think the language could be stronger and I’m also interested in there being language in there reflecting the conversation in committee around wanting to make sure that this isn’t a policy in language only knowing that we currently don’t have the systems and structures, the staffing, the training, the physical space in some schools to fully implement these practices,” Ms. Silk said. “I want to make sure we’re putting policies in place that school adults can successfully implement and not have it be in name only.”
The board will vote on the proposed changes during their Wednesday meeting.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.