Pittsburgh Public school directors this week temporarily suspended the use of summary citations at district schools, days after advocates and parents raised concerns that the offense unfairly targets Black students.
School directors on Wednesday voted to place a moratorium on the issuance of summary citations, sometimes called non-traffic citations, by school police until Nov. 30. During that time the policy and safety committees will create a policy and guidelines around their use.
Seven school directors voted in favor of the measure, with one abstention from William Gallagher. School director Sylvia Wilson opposed the moratorium.
“I feel very strongly that we continue to do a disservice to our students when we don’t stop and address our functionality and how that impacts our students at the end of the day,” school director Devon Taliaferro said Wednesday.
A summary offense is the most minor type of criminal offense in the state and is issued for nonviolent crimes such as disorderly conduct and harassment. Those issued a citation are required to appear before a judge and it usually results in a fine, which at most can cost $250.
But according to school director Pam Harbin, 44% of citations were issued to Black students for disorderly conduct and 33% for harassment. Only 7% of citations were given to white students. She added that Black girls are also 24 times more likely to receive citations as white girls.
Read More
Pittsburgh Public, the state’s second largest school district, has 20,112 students spread across 54 schools. Of students enrolled in the district, almost 52% are Black and roughly 31% are white, state data show. Almost 21% of students are enrolled in special education classes.
PPS, school solicitor Ira Weiss said, has used summary citations at higher rates than other districts. Ms. Harbin noted that citations issued during the 2021-22 school year were for nonviolent offenses.
“I would say [there’s] a pretty good possibility that there might be some discrimination happening within our process,” Ms. Harbin said.
The discussion around summary citations came as the board reviewed the district’s 2023-24 student code of conduct. The document contained three paragraphs around the issuance of summary citations by school police officers.
School directors, however, raised concerns over what they said was vague language used in the section. They pointed to lines stating an officer will consult with the school principal “to ensure there is agreement based on the evidence provided and the recommended school action.” Other concerns centered around students with disabilities and whether officers are trained to know if a behavior is a manifestation of the disability.
“To me [not having a formal process] that’s very frightening for something that is so serious of an issue. … A summary citation could effectively, potentially, ruin a student’s life,” school director Jamie Piotrowski said.
But Ms. Wilson was concerned how a pause of summary citations might impact staff.
“It’s not going to change behavior,” Ms. Wilson said. “It also keeps our employees that have this as their role, keeping them from doing their part of their job especially when there are instances where something serious has to be taken care of.”
But Ms. Taliaferro said, “It’s alarming to me … that we’re OK with the level of discrimination that happens in our school district, in the city of Pittsburgh.”
She added that a moratorium may not change the behavior of children. But, she said, it’s the district’s job “to put the right programs and practices in place that support our students and have conversations with our students and understand what is going on that makes them respond the way that they respond.”
The committees will now work to create a formal process for summary citations that sets expectations for families, students, principals and police.
Superintendent Wayne Walters said the district is also undergoing an independent equity audit that will look into racial disparities. The report will be finished by the end of the summer.
“When we look at the percentage, the disproportionate percentage, of citations being issued to Black students and especially Black girls I think some of us ask ourselves why is this? And I think the answer that we come up with is to blame the students, to blame them for the behavior,” board president Sala Udin said. “We don’t blame ourselves.
“We don’t point the finger at ourselves and that’s where the finger needs to be pointed.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.