Pittsburgh Public School directors on Tuesday questioned potential changes to the framework of a new five-year strategic plan, raising concerns over how historically marginalized students are represented and challenging whether there is enough community input to proceed.
Questions were raised during the board’s education committee meeting where Martha Greenway, a consultant hired by the district to complete the plan, presented potential changes to the framework based on community input gathered over the past month.
Tweaks to the plan, which came more than a month after Ms. Greenway gave board members their first look at major themes that could be represented in the strategic plan, includes things such as clarifying language and adding in objectives officials said will help create equitable outcomes for all students.
“Student outcomes that the strategic plan will achieve over the next five years, this is sort of a north star or the directional element of the plan,” Ms. Greenway said.
The strategic plan was first presented to school directors in December. At the time, four main themes were highlighted: improve quality and relevance of academic experiences; create safe, engaging and inclusive school environments; transform the district’s facility footprint; and prioritize community outreach and access.
Several objectives were then built out from those themes, many of which focused on creating student-centered options and opportunities, creating inclusionary practices, optimizing resources and strengthening community partnerships.
Read More
From there, district officials, in conjunction with Ms. Greenway, hosted community input sessions and partnered with local advocacy groups such as 412 Justice and the Peal Center to collect feedback. In all, 258 residents participated in stakeholder input sessions, including students representative of each of the district’s high schools. Another 261 community members responded to an online survey, including five students.
The sessions focused on two major questions: What works well? What do you disagree with?
In the first question, many people said that the plan was organized and well-understood and that it focused on academic quality and relevance and safe and inclusive school environments. The second question garnered several concerns around closing or consolidating schools — a controversial topic school directors are considering as the district faces a budget deficit and declining enrollments — and a lack of specific details in the plan.
Officials then used those responses as a guide for modifying the plan’s framework, which included changing the theme around district facilities to “optimize resources for equitable student experiences” and adding in objectives such as deepening staff capacity to support successful learning experiences. Officials also detailed which students have been historically marginalized in the district under the second theme.
But the tweaks quickly raised questions from school directors.
Board president Gene Walker quickly pointed out the objective reading, “Advance inclusionary practices that prioritize students who have been historically marginalized including African-Americans, students with disabilities, and English Language Learners.” He questioned the “benefit or kind of wisdom in this type of segregation of different groups?”
Ms. Greenway responded, saying that the specific list was included based on data and stakeholder input showing that the “district has not historically achieved equity” for those students. By being concise, she said, “it really recognizes the fact that this is something that the district has specific and direct accountability for.”
Superintendent Wayne Walters added that highlighting those individuals shows the district is listening to community feedback.
“At the same time,” Mr. Walters said, “we are open to calling out our areas of growth that we need to focus on our students specifically and give some focus and some lenses to really focusing on that work.”
Mr. Walker said he didn’t disagree with the concept but cautioned the board “to be careful when we start naming and segregating groups because ultimately we’re going to leave one out.”
But school director Tracey Reed took a different stance, suggesting that statements such as “we don’t want to leave anyone out,” are typically said “when we elevate people who we have historically left out. And so when we say things like we don’t want to leave anyone out we are where we are because we have consistently, historically, institutionally, strategically, in every way left certain communities, certain populations of kids, out.”
Ms. Reed told the board that they now have to “rejigger how we’re thinking about this whole notion of who’s left out.”
During the nearly two hour meeting, school directors also touched on the possibility of closing or consolidating schools. The discussion came weeks after the school board directed district administration to develop and present recommendations on a facilities utilization plan. The idea of closing schools has been controversial in the community, with many residents raising concerns during the strategic plan public input sessions.
“The perception is that this was solely to save money and people were offering other solutions to save money rather than consolidating or closing schools,” Ms. Greenway said of public input. “I will say in reviewing each of these comments, it is evident that the people with this perception are not equating the extremely small school and classroom sizes in some cases, with the inability to provide equitable programs and resources.”
She noted that many people suggested that if the district was considering closing schools to save money they should instead reduce the size of the district’s central administration and close the administrative office in Oakland.
In response to those suggestions, Mr. Walker said “it’s not a $26 million fix” but is something that could be part of the solution.
“I agree with many of our families and stakeholders in the fact that purely consolidating or closing schools is not going to solve our financial issues,” Mr. Walker said. “I think that should be stated. But I think it is one of the tools in the toolbox that help us to then reimagine and think strategically about how we provide the best quality education for our kids by not having our staff and resources spread so widely.”
He noted that on average the cost to staff a school building costs up to $4 million, a figure that does not include the cost of heat and roof repairs.
“That’s where the numbers really get piled up,” he said.
In addition to those major concerns, school director Devon Taliaferro also suggested that the district did not receive enough community input. She called the presentation “disappointing” because “it doesn’t let me know what the community has even really said.” And Ms. Taliaferro said the entire student body of 19,000 students was not represented while suggesting that staff such as custodians, food service workers and paraprofessionals should have been included.
“I feel like sometimes when it comes to feedback we kind of try to fit the square peg in the round hole and we do things the same way,” Ms. Taliaferro said. “I hope in the future that we can find more innovative ways to reach people.”
But Ms. Greenway said the strategic plan draft was built on three years of work and community input.
“In my professional opinion I do not think that you will get substantially more input on this strategic direction than you already have,” Ms. Greenway said. “I think it is respectful of what your community believes and wants and there’s an opportunity as you implement it to make further changes. It’s not set in stone.”
School directors are expected to vote on the revised framework during their Feb. 28 meeting.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.