Gov. Josh Shapiro during his second budget address called for $1.1 billion of additional dollars to be funneled into the state’s K-12 schools, a request that comes nearly a year after Pennsylvania’s education funding system was deemed unconstitutional.

During Tuesday’s address, Mr. Shapiro proposed increasing basic education funding by $1.1 billion, a 14% bump from the current year that would bring the budget line to a total of $9 billion. He also called for an additional $50 million in special education funding.

Mr. Shapiro said the state would “drive these dollars out in a more equitable manner.” Of the total, $872 million will go through a new adequacy formula “to ensure every school has the appropriate level of resources they need to serve their students.”

The proposal — which also includes additional investments in student mental health, dollars for school repairs and a cap on cyber charter tuition rates — comes on the heels of a Basic Education Funding Commission report identifying a $5.4 billion “adequacy gap” in school funding that should be made up over a seven-year period. The report was commissioned after a Commonwealth Court judge last year said the state’s education funding system created vast inequities between wealthy and poor districts based on its reliance on property taxes.

Advertise with us

Now, Mr. Shapiro said, his proposal follows “the general contours of that report,” and works to close the identified adequacy gap.

“We all know, and the Court has ruled, that we need a constitutional, comprehensive solution to guarantee every student the thorough and efficient education they are entitled to under … our state constitution,” Mr. Shapiro said. “So let’s build on the work we’ve already done together.”

During his address, Mr. Shapiro touted the 2023-24 budget as an “excellent first step.” That budget included a $567 million increase in basic education funding and a $50 million increase in special education funding. It also led to stipends for student teachers, universal free breakfast for students, mental health funding and money for school repairs.

Mr. Shapiro on Tuesday suggested additional funding that would continue to build on several initiatives such as preschool, mental health and building repairs. He also said that lawmakers should cap cyber charter school tuition rates paid by traditional public school districts.

In all, Mr. Shapiro proposed $30 million for the state Pre-K Counts program, which provides free preschool for families and children living in poverty, and said additional dollars should be allocated to student mental health programs. Last year, Mr. Shapiro sought $500 million to improve mental health services in schools.

Advertise with us

“Our students are quite literally calling out for help and support,” Mr. Shapiro said Tuesday. “We need to be there for them.”

He also said the proposed budget “builds on the downpayment we made last year to fund school repairs.” He pointed to several districts across the state including Sto-Rox, where he said officials identified $14 million of needed work such as “urgent roof repairs to prevent leaks when it rains.” During last year’s budget address, Mr. Shapiro suggested funneling $500 million to districts over the next five years for environmental repairs and upgrades.

“We need to invest a lot more to help these districts maintain safe and healthy learning environments for students,” Mr. Shapiro said. “My budget builds on the progress we made.”

In addition to putting more dollars into school programs, Mr. Shapiro said a 1997 charter school law should be updated, which requires public schools to cover tuition costs for charter and cyber schools. At the time the law was implemented, Mr. Shapiro said, few students were attending school online. Today, nearly 60,000 students go to cyber charter schools.

But under the law, cyber charters receive the same amount of money per student as brick-and-mortar schools, a cost that varies by district.

Advertise with us

“While cyber charters certainly need adequate funding to operate, logic would dictate that two students going to the same school, getting the same education, would pay the same rate,” Mr. Shapiro said. “Logic would also dictate that they need less than a brick-and-mortar charter school simply because they don’t have the same physical infrastructure. I know there’s bipartisan consensus that these antiquated laws need to be updated. So let’s come up with a uniform rate that actually reflects what it costs to send a kid to a cyber charter school.”

By leveling the playing field — Mr. Shapiro said while giving an example of setting cyber tuition rates to $8,000 per student — $262 million could be returned to traditional public schools. That money, combined with new dollars proposed in the budget, would lead to nearly $2 billion more for public schools next year.

During his address Mr. Shapiro also touched on a voucher program originally proposed last year by Senate Republicans. Mr. Shapiro initially showed support for the program, but it was ultimately nixed after it caused disagreements between lawmakers and delayed passage of the budget. On Tuesday, Mr. Shapiro reopened the door to the program, saying that it’s “something I support and consider to be unfinished business.” He said it is now up to the House and Senate to find common ground.

“Let’s not shy away from the many difficult conversations around education,” Mr. Shapiro said. “Let’s stay at it. Our challenges around education aren’t going to be solved in one budget cycle but we can make real progress toward a lasting and equitable solution. We have a once in a lifetime opportunity to do right by our kids. Let us seize this moment.”

Pennsylvania reaction

At Penn Hills, the budget address was celebrated by Superintendent John Mozzocio, who said the additional funding would help the district do several things such as enhance security and increase mental and behavioral health services.

Advertise with us

“Additionally, the district is currently in need of numerous capital improvements, especially at our Middle School,” Mr. Mozzocio said in an email. “Lastly, the increase in basic education funding would allow the district to continue offering support services in reading and math such as specialists and coaches. We hope the increases in funding come to fruition as it will help mitigate cyber/charter school costs, assist in offering competitive wages, and play a pivotal role in balancing our budget for the 24-25 school year.”

Those ideas were echoed by the Allegheny Intermediate Unit, which issued a statement saying the proposed funding increase “demonstrates a recognition of the vital role education plays in shaping the future of our communities and the overall well-being of our young people.”

Bob Scherrer, the AIU’s executive director who also testified at one of the Basic Education Funding Commission hearings, said he is encouraged by the proposed budget.

“The Basic Education Funding Commission’s work was a bipartisan effort to collect feedback from a wide variety of stakeholders across the state,” Mr. Scherrer said in the statement. “To see recommendations from the commission’s report reflected in the Governor’s proposed budget is a giant step in the right direction. Collectively, we need to continue to advocate for our students and schools across the state.”

In all, the Basic Education Funding Commission report called for an increase of $200 million in basic education funding — currently set at about $7.8 billion — in each of the next few years. Separately, it supports major “adequacy” investments that would gradually increase annual spending statewide over a seven-year period by a total of $5.4 billion.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania Schools Work Campaign, a coalition of 17 Pennsylvania organizations that advocates for adequate and equitable school funding, suggested “this is a public education budget worth fighting for.” The statement came after the group last month asked state officials to make a $2 billion “down payment” to underfunded school districts.

“The governor’s proposal to invest $1.8 billion more in our public schools – including improvements to facilities, and an adequacy investment of $872 million targeted to students who are most shortchanged by the current system, and significant investments in special education as part of this adequacy investment – puts Pennsylvania on the path to meeting the Commonwealth Court’s directive in the school funding lawsuit,” the statement reads. “We applaud Governor Shapiro for keeping his promise to propose increased, targeted investments in public schools to begin addressing the needs of all Pennsylvania school districts and the students they serve.”

Officials with the Education Law Center and Public Interest Law Center — organizations that represented plaintiffs in the fair funding lawsuit — called the proposal an “historic commitment” by the governor while also commending him for following the Basic Education Commission report.

“If fully implemented over the next seven years, the commission’s plan will mean thousands more teachers, counselors, librarians, and school nurses delivering what every child deserves: the opportunity to thrive,” the statement reads. “We look forward to legislation backing up that long-term plan, with annual targets so that school districts can plan, our leaders can be held accountable, and students can see the benefits.”

The law centers did also suggest that the seven-year timeline is “too long, and it does not yet include funding for critical strategies” such as pre-K programs.

“But we recognize his proposal for what it is: a bold, historic first step towards a system that honors the limitless potential of our students and delivers the future our communities and our children deserve,” they said. “We are ready to stand with the governor in advocating for its passage.”