HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania has a nice chunk of money in the bank, and with many of its schools in need, it’s time to spend some of it.
That was the key financial theme in Gov. Josh Shapiro’s 2024-25 budget address delivered Tuesday afternoon to hundreds of lawmakers and guests in the unusual setting of the Capitol Rotunda. Traditionally, governors deliver the annual speech in the House chamber, but that venue was off-limits this year because of water damage repairs.
The second-year Democratic governor outlined many new or expanded initiatives in a proposed $48.3 billion spending plan and said it was time to undertake them because the state will end the year with a $14 billion surplus. He went right to one of the biggest — a proposed $1.1 billion increase in K-12 education spending — early in the 90-minute speech. That would be a 14% increase and put total spending in that category near $9 billion.
Republican lawmakers were quick to criticize Mr. Shapiro’s spending strategy as excessive, and the governor acknowledged in his address that the state’s divided Legislature makes finding agreement key to getting things through. Last year’s budget process dragged on for several months.

“We need to build a more competitive Pennsylvania that starts in our classrooms, runs through our union halls and our small businesses, through our farmlands and our high rises, our college campuses, and leads to a life of opportunity and a retirement with dignity,” Mr. Shapiro said in his address.
His K-12 education proposal follows a Commonwealth Court ruling last year that found the state’s current school funding system unconstitutional. More recently, a majority of a 15-person commission that studied the issue found there is a $5.4 billion “adequacy gap” in the funding of many state’s school districts.
Read More
Among other significant proposals were $300 million for school facility and environmental repairs; putting the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education and community colleges under one governance system and giving it a 15% funding increase; and borrowing $500 million to develop sites intended to attract businesses, then repaying the debt with revenue from those businesses.
Mr. Shapiro proposed a 5% funding increase for University of Pittsburgh and other state-related universities; a new, $5 million animal testing laboratory in Western Pennsylvania, without specifying exactly where; and a proposed big boost in transit funding that would include about $40 million for Pittsburgh Regional Transit.
Mr. Shapiro’s projection of a $14 billion year-end surplus included about $6 billion in the state Rainy Day Fund and a projected year-end budget surplus of about $8 billion.
Even if all his initiatives are carried out, he said, the state would still have an $11 billion surplus at the end of fiscal 2024-25.
“Now is the time to invest some of that $14 billion surplus squirreled away here in Harrisburg,” he said. He added that it was “not a badge of honor” to take more money away from Pennsylvanians than necessary and then stash it in the bank.
Republicans could not have disagreed more.
Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward of Westmoreland County said it appeared Mr. Shapiro was trying “to become the darling of the national Democratic party.” His proposals, she said, covered “spending in so many realms without any accountability” and did nothing to address things affecting families now, like increasing costs for utility bills, food and gas.
Senate Republican majority leader Joe Pittman of Indiana County said the proposal was “absolutely fiscally irresponsible and unsustainable.” In the House, Republican leader Bryan Cutler of Lancaster County said Mr. Shapiro’s plan was like a “phishing scam” because it “looks good, it draws you in, and it makes you believe it is something it is not.”
Democrats were happy, if not ecstatic.
Sen. Jay Costa of Allegheny County, the Democratic minority leader in the chamber, said Mr. Shapiro had blazed an exciting path. In particular, the K-12 education spending proposal dealt with “embedded” wrongs in the state funding system, he said.
Rep. Matt Bradford of Montgomery County, Democratic leader in the House, called the speech amazing. “The governor knocked it out of the park,” Mr. Bradford said.
In the months ahead — as lawmakers hold hearings on the proposal and then work on spending legislation — the parties will have to work together. Democrats currently run the House and Republicans control the Senate. Mr. Shapiro highlighted that “divided government” situation in his comments.
“That means nothing gets done unless it has support from members of both parties,” he said. “We need to compromise.”
Tuesday’s address was considered historic because no governor has ever delivered the annual budget address in ornate space just inside the main Capitol entrance, with a soaring dome overhead. Less than 24 hours earlier, a throng of protestors opposed to Pennsylvania’s purchase of Israel-issued bonds occupied portions of the grand staircase where Mr. Shapiro was to speak, and 126 of them were taken into custody and led away by police.
Mr. Shapiro said a new, 10-year economic development strategy he developed provided the context for $600 million in proposed new and expanded economic investments in 2024-25.
As an example of things that work, he cited Pittsburgh’s Cocoapreneur, an incubator for Black-owned small businesses that provides them with office space and access to capital. “We need to do more of that,” he said.
Other highlights from his address included:
• Increasing financial aid at schools in the proposed combined system. Amounts would be increased enough to let Pennsylvanians making up to the median income pay no more than $1,000 per semester in tuition and fees.
• $50 million for the Whole Home Repairs Program, which distributes grants for certain home upgrades to income-eligible recipients.
• $100 million on initiatives to reduce gun violence.
• A push for lawmakers to legalize recreational marijuana use. Mr. Shapiro said nearly every other state around Pennsylvania has already done so, and his proposed budget included a small amount of revenue from a tax on “adult use cannabis” in anticipation of legislative approval.
• A strong urging to lawmakers to raise the state’s minimum wage to $15 an hour.
• Notice that his administration is working on a plan to address the crisis involving closures of rural hospitals around the state.
• Money to allow feminine hygiene products to be available free of charge in schools.
• A statement that he is willing to negotiate on voucher-style scholarships that would allow students in low-performing schools to choose to attend other schools. Last summer, Mr. Shapiro vetoed a $100 million line item in the 2023-24 budget that would have allowed such a program, angering Republicans.
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.