Despite mixed reactions from many community members and some school directors, the North Allegheny School District will soon have its own police department.

A measure to bolster police presence in the district from two school resource officers to 12 armed police officers in all district building was unanimously approved Wednesday during a school board meeting. The vote included a measure to create the department as well as positions of police chief and officers and came a week after the plan was presented to the public.

“We have a moral obligation to protect our students and staff at all of our schools. … I hope and pray that nothing requires the response of a police officer in one of our schools, or any school district for that matter,” school director Michael Weniger said. “But the world we live in sadly presents a different reality that I think we have to accept. I would much rather be prepared than devastated, wishing we had done more.”

Under the plan, the district will create a police department with a chief and 12 officers at a cost of $65,613 per officer, including 190 days of work, estimated overtime, retirement plan costs and training, supplies and uniforms. The goal would be to ensure that the district’s 8,470 students have the same level of security regardless of which school building they attend.

Advertise with us

Currently two school resource officers employed by the McCandless Police Department are present at the intermediate and high school under a plan created in 2018. If an incident were to occur at the elementary or middle schools, students and staff would have to wait for the local police department to respond.

Now, the police chief will be charged with supervising school police officers, overseeing the creation and deployment of the department while developing use of force and other processes, policies, scheduling and procedures, the job description reads. The department will also enforce attendance laws and maintain relationships with community police.

School officers will be tasked with “providing and fostering a safe learning atmosphere for all stakeholders in the school district,” a job description reads. The officers will not have arrest powers and will defer all criminal matters to local law enforcement.

According to their job description, officers must understand how to distinguish disciplinary infractions handled by school officials from criminal activity that warrants an officer while positively communicating with students to help them feel safe and secure.

The plan was first presented by Superintendent Brendan Hyland, who said last week that his opinion about school police changed after the 2012 shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, Conn., where 20 first-graders and six teachers died. The tragedy spurred him to create an in-school police department at Plum, where he previously served as superintendent. Today that district has a police chief and five officers.

Advertise with us

“This was one of the best decisions that I have ever made as an administrator,” Mr. Hyland said of Plum’s department. “I believe and I hope that it will be the same for North Allegheny once we get this program up and running.”

Conversations around school safety have been taking place for years, largely spurred by the 1999 Columbine High School shooting that left 12 students and one teacher dead. But since then, more than 357,000 students have experienced gun violence in school, a Washington Post analysis found, the most recent being in March, when a former student shot through the doors of The Covenant School in Nashville, killing three children and three adults.

In an attempt to keep students and staff safe while in the classroom, districts across the nation – and several in the Pittsburgh region – are using metal detectors, school resource officers, panic buttons and closed campuses. This week, the Hempfield Area School District proposed changes to its search policy that could subject students and community members to more frequent searches, a response to two gun-related incidents in the past month.

And many in the region have created their own police departments, including Baldwin-Whitehall and Bethel Park.

At North Allegheny, school directors revisited the idea in September after having initial discussions in 2017 about starting their own police department. They based their decision on several studies, such as a 2021 U.S. Secret Service analysis of violence in schools that suggested school safety officers play an important role in  violence prevention while fostering positive relationships between officers and students.

Advertise with us

But the idea of school-based police departments has also received backlash from many advocates who suggest that school police can cause long-term harm to Black, brown and disabled students who are often disproportionately targeted when it comes to school discipline. Advocates also raised concerns that school officers add to the school-to-prison pipeline.

“You, the board, are intentionally creating a system of racism by building metaphorical walls that keep ‘those people’ out of our school,” McCandless resident Lynne Williams said.

“African American families will be less likely to want to move to a district where they know their children will be targeted by a police department in the school. In the year of 2023, we should be working harder to decrease systems of oppression and racism.”

School director Leslie Britton Dozier echoed similar concerns expressed last week about how school police could lead to increased exclusionary discipline such as suspensions and expulsions that disproportionately target students of color and those with disabilities.

But despite those concerns, Ms. Britton Dozier voted in favor of the department. She requested that the board receive full and detailed reporting of all citations issued, have input on hiring and the creation of police procedures, urged administrators to ensure that officers receive all necessary training and asked that any officers be immediately removed if necessary.

Advertise with us

“While I am not entirely convinced that this is the best next step, I do not want to be wrong,” Ms. Britton Dozier said. “I do not want to be in a position where I regret not supporting this security measure.”

School director Elizabeth Warner also said the decision to hire armed officers for each school building was difficult. She suggested that in addition to the police department, officials need to create a more comprehensive school safety plan that focuses on mental health and that “checks all the boxes.”

For school director Vidya Szymkowiak, creating a police department is a way to ensure that all students are protected instead of just high schoolers. She echoed earlier sentiments made by Mr. Weniger.

“What message are we sending as a district by only protecting two out of our 12 schools?” Mr. Weniger said. “We value those teachers, staff and students in the high schools more than those in our elementary and middle schools? It really pains me to say this, that those are the most innocent and dependent upon the adults for their safety and we’re not protecting them.”

He called the police department a “slam dunk.”

Advertise with us

Board President Libby Blackburn said that as a parent who sent her kids to the district, the two things she asked of school principals was to make sure they were educated and safe.

“I am thrilled that we haven’t had any major attacks at North Allegheny,” Ms. Blackburn said. “However, I consider it paramount that we make sure that we are ready to mitigate a catastrophe. This is for our staff and our students.”