When Megan Van Fossan gets in her car each morning, she runs through a mental checklist to keep her students and staff safe that day: Who are her security guards? Did any teachers call out?

As superintendent of the Sto-Rox School District, Ms. Van Fossan needs enough staff to usher students and visitors through metal detectors every day and conduct background checks for visitors. An adequate number of guards must be positioned on each floor of the district’s school buildings for extra security.

“I didn’t do that 20 years ago,” Ms. Van Fossan said. “It’s heartbreaking.” 

School administrators have amped up safety measures over the past several years, new federal data show, as the U.S. continues to reel from deadly school shootings. The most recent occurred Monday when a 28-year-old shooter entered a private Christian school in Nashville and opened fire, killing three children and three adults before being fatally shot by police. 

Advertise with us

Increased safety measures were in the spotlight this week in Pittsburgh when a series of false reports about active shooters led to large police deployments at Central Catholic and Oakland Catholic. Police on Wednesday quickly learned the 911 calls were a hoax, but proceeded into the schools to ensure students and staff were safe. Both schools were cleared by the afternoon. 

But the scare came as schools across Pennsylvania and in other states were rocked with similar false reports. Calls were received in schools in Allegheny, Beaver, Blair, Cambria, Carbon, Centre, Crawford, Erie, Fayette, Lehigh, Mercer and Northampton Counties. One school in New Jersey also received a swatting call that morning. And last week, several Ohio schools received similar false calls reporting active shooters or bomb threats. 

Almost 66% of U.S. districts control access to school grounds during school hours, according to data collected in a survey of more than 1,000 public schools in November by the Institute of Education Sciences, a research arm of the U.S. Department of Education.

About 43% of schools surveyed across the country reported having panic buttons or silent alarms installed, giving them a direct connection to law enforcement. About 64% of schools now have anonymous or confidential threat-reporting systems, while just over half have police, known as school resource officers. 

Roughly 6% of districts require metal detector checks daily. And in addition to school police, 3% of schools said nonsecurity staff can legally carry a gun on campus — a controversial tactic increasingly being pushed by Republican lawmakers following high-profile school shootings. 

Advertise with us

Almost all the schools surveyed said they have detailed plans for active shooters and bomb threats. Lockdown drills are also regularly practiced at schools.

Since the 1999 Columbine High School shooting that left 12 students and one teacher dead, more than 338,000 students have experienced gun violence in school, according to a database from The Washington Post. Of those, nine active shooter incidents were reported in 2021, compared to three last year, a K-12 school shooting database found. Last year’s shootings include Uvalde, Texas where 19 kids and two adults died at Robb Elementary School.

This year, a 25-year-old teacher at Richneck Elementary School in Newport News, Va. was allegedly shot by a first-grade student.

The problem is that many districts are focusing on “target hardening,” or tactics such as locking doors, using metal detectors and setting up cameras, said Marc Zimmerman, co-director of the National Center for School Safety at the University of Michigan. 

“We don’t have any real data on whether or not that works,” Mr. Zimmerman said. Those tactics, he added, are “not really prevention because if you have to stop a kid from bringing a gun to school you’ve already lost.”

Advertise with us

Instead, districts should shift their focus to school climate and mental health services, he said. That means administrators need to look at how teachers, parents and students interact with each other through restorative justice or anti-bullying programs. Counselors, teachers, parents, students and school resource officers should review those programs together and make any necessary improvements to ensure they are working to identify issues early on and get students referred to the right services, Mr. Zimmerman said. 

“Rarely does somebody wake up in the morning and decide to get a gun and shoot people,” he said. “It’s usually something that builds up.”

‘Columbine forced some changes’

When Randal Lutz accepted an assistant principal position at the Baldwin-Whitehall School District in 1996, there were few security measures stopping people from walking into school buildings during the day.

Doors were often unlocked as teachers filtered into their classrooms during the early morning. The main office remained open for parents and visitors throughout the day.

“You’d come into the lobby, you’d be in the hallway and basically folks would be interacting with students right in the hallway,” Mr. Lutz, who is now the district superintendent, said.

Advertise with us

Today, secure entrances stop people from walking into the building. Visitors are now buzzed inside and their identification is scanned through a visitor management system. Doors are covered in tinted glass to deter anyone from seeing inside. Those visiting the school, even parents, are escorted at all times.

The measures were part of a $3.5 million project aimed at securing school buildings. Those projects are ongoing as administrators construct fences around playgrounds and design an enclosed courtyard space at a new elementary school.

The district five years ago created its own police department, made up of two armed officers who are retired state troopers and guards. It also partners with area police departments, which conduct rounds through the schools.

“It’s been a process,” Mr. Lutz said. “We can always get better, we can always look for things to approve upon. It’s tough.”

Aaron Skrbin, director of safety and security at the Allegheny Intermediate Unit, said conversations about school safety largely started after Columbine.

Advertise with us

“Columbine forced some changes,” said Mr. Skrbin, a former Woodland Hills teacher and Charter Valley and South Fayette administrator. “People started doing lockdown drills at that point. Police changed their tactics.”

While several high-profile school shootings occurred in the years after – including at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, Conn., where 20 first-graders and six teachers died in 2012 – it wasn’t until the 2018 shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., that real change began, Mr. Skrbin said. 

“Every incident up until Marjory Stoneman Douglas there’d be this hangover effect,” Mr. Skrbin said. “The incident would happen, everybody rightfully would be upset and concerned, there would be some cosmetic changes. … Then we’d forget about it.”

After Parkland — in which 17 students and staff died, setting off months of protests from survivors advocating for gun control — many states, including Pennsylvania, introduced legislation to make schools safer. 

Pennsylvania lawmakers that year required districts to appoint safety and security coordinators, mandated school safety training for all employees and established standards for school police and resource officers. Subsequent laws established finer details on things such as the number of training hours required.

Advertise with us

Last year, President Joe Biden signed into law the first major gun safety legislation in decades. The measure included funding for school safety and state crisis intervention programs. But the stricter gun control measures most sought by advocates, such as banning assault weapons and high-capacity magazines, have been repeatedly blocked by Republicans in Congress.  

Schools themselves also increased conversations about and tactics for school safety.

Penn Hills Superintendent Nancy Hines said the district uses a multi-layered system that begins at the student level. Youth engagement school specialists — known as the YESS team, who are provided through an agreement with McCandless-based Pressley Ridge, a social services nonprofit— patrol the halls and interface with students. 

If the specialists notice any tension, they will work to de-escalate it.

The district also has an arrangement with a private security company, which positions two guards in each of the schools. The guards help check-in students throughout the morning. They run visitors’ identification through screening software and walk them through metal detectors. They also monitor surveillance cameras.

Advertise with us

The district also partners with the Penn Hills Police Department. Active duty officers are posted at each school. While they are available to respond to any incidents that arise, the officers are also building relationships with students and getting to know the layout of the schools, Ms. Hines said.

Penn Hills is now constructing guard shacks at the high school and middle school driveway entrances. Through that model, visitors would check in at the shack before gaining access to school grounds. The booths could be operational by May 31.

“We built this over time and it has to just be collective open mindedness and truly due diligence every second of every day,” Ms. Hines said.

She noted that over the years, several aspects of school security have changed as administrators concentrate on therapeutic tactics aimed at building relationships between staff and students. That includes police officers, who now take time to eat lunch or play basketball with students, she said.

At Sto-Rox, efforts to keep students safe also acknowledge that many come from poverty- and and violence-stricken settings, Ms. Van Fossan said. The district has implemented student success teams, which identify children who are struggling and refer them to outside organizations. 

Advertise with us

“We just want to ensure as a district we think about those social and emotional needs first because if those are not addressed kids can’t access that rigorous, relevant instruction in classrooms,” Ms. Van Fossan said.

For Mr. Lutz, school safety is a balancing act that requires administrators not to overreact. 

“Schools are schools and the beauty of schools is that they’re places for kids to learn and to grow,” he said. “You need to build a climate that allows that to happen. Schools are not prisons and it can be very difficult to balance those two extremes.”