The attorney for Jason Cooper, one of two Plum High School teachers charged with sexually assaulting a female student, has filed a motion to dismiss the charge based on an argument that was successful in a similar case.
Michael DeRiso also represented New Brighton teacher Tiffany Leiseth, who was charged in July 2014 with two counts of institutional sexual assault for what police said were sexual relationships with two 18-year-old male students.
Through a plea agreement, Ms. Leiseth pleaded guilty in February to furnishing liquor to minors and inducing minors to purchase liquor. The sexual assault charges were dropped. She was sentenced to one year of probation and ordered not to teach again.
In that case, Mr. DeRiso argued that because the male students were 18, they were adults and able to give consent for sex.
He’s now making that same argument in a motion he filed last week in Common Pleas Court on behalf of Mr. Cooper. It’s similar to the argument that he made at Mr. Cooper’s preliminary hearing in April.
And although the district attorney’s office agreed to the plea in Ms. Leiseth’s case, Mike Manko, spokesman for District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., said the office would have no comment on Mr. DeRiso’s motion in the Plum case.
Read More
In testimony at the preliminary hearing, the female student said she had sex with Mr. Cooper, 38, of Verona, for the first time on or about Jan. 16, after her 18th birthday.
“Once you turn 18 you are at the age of majority and you are an adult. The Legislature no longer has an interest in protecting you or who you as an adult decide to have a relationship with,” Mr. DeRiso said in an interview.
Mr. DeRiso stated in his motion that the charge of institutional sexual assault should be dismissed because it is “unconstitutionally broad” in that it punishes the constitutionally protected rights of consenting adults to engage in sexual conduct.
Mr. DeRiso maintains the statute was passed to bridge the gap for students between the ages of 16 to 18 who were involved in inappropriate relationships with teachers. He said that in the past the teachers could be charged only with corruption of the morals of minors in those cases.
“There is no legitimate state interest that could be served by regulating private sexual conduct between consenting adults, even where the relationship began as teacher/student,” Mr. DeRiso wrote.
Mr. DeRiso also argues that the charge of institutional sexual assault is “unconstitutionally vague” because it fails to define the term “student.”
Mr. DeRiso filed a second motion seeking dismissal of witness intimidation and witness intimidation in a child abuse case on the grounds that Mr. Cooper did not attempt to intimidate the student when he called her after the charges were filed.
A police affidavit said the student’s father reported that Mr. Cooper called his daughter while a “no contact” order was in place.
But, Mr. DeRiso contends in the motion that testimony at Mr. Cooper’s preliminary hearing indicated he was simply calling to apologize.
Shortly after Mr. Cooper was arrested in February. a second teacher, Joseph Ruggieri, 40, of New Kensington, also was charged with institutional sexual assault, witness intimidation and corruption of a minor in connection with a sexual relationship with another female student. According to criminal affidavits, that student was 17 when the relationship started.
Mr. Ruggieri waived his case to Common Pleas Court.
Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.