In Plum, a community reeling from a high school sex scandal that incensed parents wish was far behind them, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to determine who is telling the truth.

Is it former school board member Joseph Tommarello, who insists he brought an allegation of teacher misconduct to the superintendent last fall? Is it superintendent Timothy Glasspool, who says that never happened?

Is it school solicitor Lee Price, who said that in 2011 the district, with the help of school resource officer Mark Kost, conducted an investigation into allegations of an inappropriate student-teacher relationship? Is it the now-retired officer’s attorney, who flatly denies that his client was involved? Is it Plum police Chief Jeffrey Armstrong, who says that department records don’t reflect any involvement of Mr. Kost in such a probe? Or is it Mr. Glasspool, who said investigators carted out all documentation that could prove what the district is saying?

“The fact of the matter is there’s a lot of different information going out there, and I trust the law enforcement agencies and the district attorney in particular will sort through it and determine exactly what the truth is,” Plum Mayor Richard Hrivnak said Friday.

Advertise with us

Asked how he was reconciling the conflicting accounts, Mr. Hrivnak, a Plum graduate, said, “I don’t think you can. I think only those parties know what the truth is.”

At this stage, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. is the closest of anyone to having all the answers, but he is not talking yet because of the secrecy that surrounds grand jury proceedings.

Mr. Zappala’s office is conducting what appears to be a broad and deep investigation of whether anyone in the Plum School District broke the law in connection with child-abuse allegations or turned a blind eye to teacher misconduct. The inquiry was triggered by the February arrests of high school teachers Joseph Ruggieri and Jason Cooper. Prosecutors charged the men with institutional sexual assault, alleging that each had sex with a different female student. A third teacher, Drew Zoldak, was charged with intimidating a victim; police said he humiliated Mr. Ruggieri’s alleged victim in front of a class.

All three men are facing trial.

A grand jury is an extremely helpful tool to unravel a complex case, explained Bruce Antkowiak, a law professor at St. Vincent College and a former federal prosecutor. Through the use of subpoenas, testimony under oath and grants of immunity, prosecutors can assemble a tremendous amount of information in a relatively short amount of time, square testimony with records, and then make an informed decision.

Advertise with us

“It identifies people in a complicated criminal situation that the government might not have an interest in prosecuting per se, but could be valuable in getting information on higher-ups in an organization,” Mr. Antkowiak said.

Even as the grand jury moves forward, Jim Buckheit, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators, sympathizes with anyone trying to make sense of the confusing goings-on in Plum.

“Law enforcement will say right at the onset, while the investigation’s taking place and until somebody’s charged you’re not allowed to talk about any of this. This is very difficult for everyone involved because you’re under orders not to disclose anything,” Mr. Buckheit said. “The rumor mill certainly spreads information, and most of the time it’s not accurate. So it’s very hard.”

Calling the Plum situation a “tragedy,” Mr. Buckheit said the most administrators can do is to reassure the community that the school is keeping its students safe and taking all appropriate steps.

Against the backdrop of the faculty arrests and ongoing investigation, district administrators Wednesday held a question-and-answer session with the media. Board President Sal Colella and Mr. Price read statements in an effort to explain and defend the district’s actions.

Advertise with us

To some, administrators ended up clouding the issues rather than clarifying them.

“Nothing changed in my understanding. There’s still so many questions to be answered,” said Luke Streussnig, 18, who just graduated from Plum and attended the meeting Wednesday. “Now nobody knows who to believe here. Now we’re all running around like chickens with our heads cut off trying to figure out what’s right and what’s wrong.”

Administrators offered no explanation of how former board member Mr. Tommarello and Mr. Glasspool could have such vastly different recollections of whether the two talked in the fall about an allegation of an inappropriate relationship between Mr. Ruggieri and a student. And they provided no details about how an allegation of an inappropriate relationship came to them in 2011; how it was investigated; who was involved in looking into the claims; or why a school resource officer would be involved and neither document his actions for his department nor inform a superior officer.

Attorney Phillip DiLucente said his client “was shocked and utterly disgusted” when Mr. Price said that Mr. Kost was involved in the 2011 probe of whether Mr. Ruggieri was involved with a female student.

“There was no context to it. So he throws out this general statement that Mark Kost knew,” Mr. DiLucente said Friday. “Well, let’s be a little bit more specific. What did he know about it? He knows about a lot of things all the time. What was actually told to him by whom and under what circumstances? And was there any type of complaint recognized for law enforcement to get involved?”

Advertise with us

Mr. DiLucente challenged the school district to provide evidence that Mr.Kost knew of the allegations of sexual misconduct.

Mr. Glasspool said such proof exists — but prosecutors took all of it last month.

So far the district attorney’s office is keeping mum. Mike Manko, the DA’s spokesman, said he could not discuss anything pertaining to the Plum investigation.

By declining comment, Mr. Manko put into stark relief a major impediment for the public in resolving contradictory accounts in Plum: everything is a secret. Grand juries are secret. Allegations of child abuse are secret. Personnel issues are secret. And ongoing police investigations, at least in the eyes of police, are supposed to be secret, too.

Nonetheless, Mr. DiLucente endorsed the idea of a grand jury.

Advertise with us

“I think what Steve Zappala’s doing is really smart — if there was ever a case to have in front of a grand jury this was it,” Mr. DiLucente said. “There’s a lot of finger-pointing.”

Mary Niederberger contributed. Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.